具身视角下遗产地研学旅行中遗产认同的建构研究

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1004-9479.2023.08.2021870

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

民族文化遗产是加深群体文化认知、产生情感共鸣、凝聚认同的重要媒介，研究中小学生在遗产地如何通过研学旅行的生理身体实践获得旅游体验、建构社会身体、形成认同对深挖民族文化遗产价值、提升研学旅行成效具有重要意义。对曾前往永顺老司城遗产地开展过研学旅行的48位中小学生进行半结构式访谈，运用扎根理论进行数据处理，基于生理身体与社会身体交叉的研究视角，建构遗产地研学旅行中具身体验的理论模型。研究发现：（1）生理身体实践、研学旅行情境、感官知觉体验是影响社会身体形成的重要因素；（2）文化遗产地研学旅行体验的本质是中小学生的具身性等生理身体和社会身体获得统一的过程，是旅游具身体验表征和非表征的结合；（3）中小学生通过研学旅行形成了对文化遗产的独特认知及深厚情感，这是遗产认同建构的结果；（4）遗产认同的强弱受具身体验的影响，旅游具身体验的全过程既包括从生理身体进入感官知觉体验，还包括社会身体的形成使得自我生存意义得以体现。

关键词: 研学旅行, 具身体验, 生理身体, 社会身体, 遗产认同

Abstract:

Ethnic cultural heritage is an important medium for deepening group cultural cognition, generating emotional resonance and cohesion of identity. How primary and secondary school students can gain travel experience, construct social body, and form identity through the physical and physical practice of study trips in heritage sites are important for digging deeply into the value of ethnic cultural heritage. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 48 elementary and middle school students who had traveled to the Old Sicheng Heritage Site of Yongshun to conduct research trips. The grounded theory was used for data processing, and based on the research perspective of the intersection of physical body and social body, the embodied experience of the research trip to the heritage site was constructed the theoretical model. The research finds that: (1) Physiological and physical practice, study trip situation, sensory perception experience are important factors that affect the formation of the social body. (2) The essence of cultural heritage study trip experience is the process by which elementary and middle school students' embodied physical bodies and social bodies are unified, and it is a combination of representation and non-representation of embodied travel experience. (3) Primary and secondary school students have formed a unique cognition and deep emotion of cultural heritage through study trips, which is the result of the construction of heritage identity. (4) The strength of heritage identity is affected by the embodied experience; The whole process of tourism embodied experience includes not only the entry from the physical body to the sensory perception experience, but also the formation of the social body so that the meaning of self-existence can be reflected.

Key words: study trip, embodied experiences, physical body, social body, heritage identity

何银春, 陈果. 具身视角下遗产地研学旅行中遗产认同的建构研究[J]. 世界地理研究, 2023, 32(8): 166-178.

Yinchun HE, Guo CHEN. A study on the construction of heritage identity in the study trip of heritage sites from the embodied perspective[J]. World Regional Studies, 2023, 32(8): 166-178.

参考文献

1	中华人民共和国教育部等 11 部门. 教育部等11 部门关于推进中小学生研学旅行的意见 (2016-12-02)[2022-04-28]..
11	Departments including the Ministry of Education of the Ministry of Education of the People's Republic of China.Opinions of 11 Departments including the Ministry of Education on Promoting Research and Study Travel for Primary and Secondary School Students (2016-12-02) [2022-04-28]..
2	袁长林. 研学旅行课程资源设计:原则、向度与路径.课程.教材.教法,2021,41(2):32-36.
2	YUAN C.The curriculum resources design for research trips: Principles, dimensions and paths. Curriculum,Teaching Material and Method,2021,41(2):32-36.
3	吴儒练, 李洪义, 田逢军. 中国国家级研学旅行基地空间分布及其影响因素. 地理科学,2021,41(7):1139-1148.
3	WU R, LI H, TIAN F. The spatial distribution and its influencing factors of China's national study travel bases. Scientia Geographica Sinica,2021,41(7):1139-1148.
4	金龙. 文旅融合背景下公共图书馆研学旅游服务创新策略. 图书馆工作与研究,2019(5):123-128.
4	JIN L. Research on study tourism service innovation strategy of public library under the background of culture and tourism integration. Library Work and Study, 2019(5): 123-128.
5	周林兴, 邹莎. 文旅融合时代档案馆研学服务探析. 档案学研究,2021(3):65-72.
5	ZHOU L, ZOU S. Study tour service of archives in the era of culture and tourism integration. Archives Science Study, 2021(3): 65-72.
6	马翀炜. 世界遗产与民族国家认同. 云南师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2010,42(4):28-34.
6	MA C. World heritages and the identity of the nation-state. Journal of Yunnan Normal University(Humanities and Social Sciences Edition),2010,42(4):28-34.
7	董艳, 高雅茹, 赵亮, 等. 情境感知视域下研学旅行课程设计探究——以"乔家大院民俗博物馆研学基地"为例. 现代教育技术,2021,31(4):119-125.
7	DONG Y, GAO Y, ZHAO L, et al. A preliminary study on the curriculum design of study tour based on context awareness theory--Taking folklore museum study tour base of Qiao's grand courtyard as an example. Modern Educational Technology,2021,31(4):119-125.
8	杨德军, 王禹苏, 余发碧. 满意与期待:北京中小学研学旅行课程实施状况调研. 中小学管理,2021(2):34-37.
8	YANG D, WANG Y, YU F. Satisfaction and expectations: Investigation on the implementation status of study travel courses in Beijing primary and secondary schools. School Administration,2021(2):34-37.
9	吴支奎, 杨洁. 研学旅行:培育学生核心素养的重要路径.课程.教材.教法,2018,38(4):126-130.
9	WU Z, YANG J. Study tours: An important path to cultivate students key competency. Curriculum, Teaching Material and Method,2018,38(4):126-130.
10	郭涵. 价值引领: 高中教育的重要使命. 人民教育,2018(11):36-39.
10	GUO H. Value guidance: The important mission of high school education. People's Education,2018(11):36-39.
12	邹太龙. 中小学研学旅行亟须处理好五对关系. 教育理论与实践,2019,39(11):9-11.
12	ZOU T. Five pairs of relationships must be dealt with urgently in the study trip of elementary and middle schools. Theory and Practice of Education,2019,39(11):9-11.
13	谢辉基,杨振之.论旅游体验研究中的"身体"现象及其认知.旅游学刊,2020,35(7):117-132.
13	XIE H, YANG Z. On the phenomena and cognition of the "body" in the research of tourism experience. Tourism Tribune,2020,35(7):117-132.
14	樊友猛, 谢彦君. 旅游体验研究的具身范式. 旅游学刊,2019,34(11):17-28.
14	FAN Y, XIE Y. Embodiment paradigm of tourist experience research. Tourism Tribune,2019,34(11): 17-28.
15	樊友猛. 旅游具身体验研究进展与展望. 旅游科学,2020,34(1):1-19.
15	FAN Y. Research progress and prospect on tourist embodied experiences. Tourism Science,2020,34(1):1-19.
16	中华人民共和国文化和旅游部. "十四五"文化和旅游发展规划. (2021-04-29) [2022-01-09]..
16	Ministry of Culture and Turism of the People's Republic of China."14th Five-Year"cultural and tourism development plan.(2021-04-29) [2022-01-09]. .
17	张朝枝, 屈册, 金钰涵. 遗产认同: 概念、内涵与研究路径. 人文地理,2018,33(4):20-25.
17	ZHANG C, QU C, JIN Y. Heritage identity: Concept connotation and research approches. Human Geography,2018,33(4):20-25.
18	ROPPOLA T, UZZELL D, PACKER J, et al. National identities and war heritage: Acceptance and resistance of an authorised heritage discourse among visitors to the Australian War Memorial. International Journal of Heritage Studies, 2020(1):1-16.
19	魏爱棠,彭兆荣.遗产运动中的政治与认同.厦门大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2011(5):1-8.
19	WEI A, PENG Z. On the politics and identity in the movement of heritage. Journal of Xiamen University(Arts＆Social Sciences),2011(5):1-8.
20	JANAKIRAMAN A. Constructing national identity through world heritage: The international and intranational politics of the built environment in Ahmadabad. International Journal of Heritage Studies,2021(2):1-17.
21	屈册, 张朝枝. 谁的遗产?——元阳梯田旅游经营者遗产认同比较. 热带地理,2016,36(4):524-531.
21	QU C, ZHANG C. Whose heritage?--A comparison between nonlocal and local tourism business's heritage identities in the Yuanyang terraces area. Tropical Geography,2016,36(4):524-531.
22	屈册, 张朝枝.元阳梯田原住民的遗产认同: 基于话语分析的视角.旅游学刊,2016,31(7):43-51.
22	QU C, ZHANG C. Aboriginal heritage identity in Yuanyang rice terraces:On the perspective of discourse analysis.Tourism Tribune,2016,31(7):43-51.
23	何银春, 梁越, 曾斌丹. 遗产化进程中遗产认同的内涵及形成路径——以世界遗产永顺老司城为例. 热带地理,2019,39(5):749-758.
23	HE Y, LIANG Y, ZENG B. The connotation and formation path of heritage identity in the process of heritagization: A case study of the Laosicheng world heritage, Yongshun. Tropical Geography, 2019,39(5):749-758.
24	GLASER B, STRAUSS A. The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research. Chicago: Aldine Publishing Company, 1967.
25	吴毅, 吴刚, 马颂歌. 扎根理论的起源、流派与应用方法述评——基于工作场所学习的案例分析. 远程教育杂志,2016,34(3):10.
25	WU Y, WU G, MA S. Review on the origin, genre and application of the grounded theory method. Journal of Distance Esucation,2016,34(3):10.
26	李江敏, 王青, 朱镇. 非物质文化遗产活态传承: 体验价值体系、测量与检验. 旅游学刊,2020,35(11):78-89.
26	LI J, WANG Q, ZHU Z. Living transmission of intangible cultural heritage: Experience value system, measurement and test. Tourism Tribune,2020,35(11):78-89.
27	陶伟, 王绍续, 朱竑. 身体、身体观以及人文地理学对身体的研究. 地理研究,2015,34(6):1173-1187.
27	TAO W, WANG S, ZHU H. The body, the view of body, and the study of body in human geography. Geographical Reseach,2015,34(6):1173-1187.
28	ALLEN-COLLINSON J, OWTON H. Intense embodiment: Senses of heat in women's running and boxing. Body & Society,2015,21(2):245-268.
29	ELLIS G, BARRY J, ROBINSON C.Many ways to say 'no',different ways to say 'yes':Applying Q-methodology to understand public acceptance of wind farm proposals.Journal of Environmental Planning & Management,2007,50(4):517-551.
30	邓凯文. 情感认同: 培育社会主义核心价值观的着力点. 广西社会科学,2016(12):13-17.
30	DENG K. Emotional identification: The focal point of cultivating the core values of socialism. Guangxi Social Sciences,2016(12):13-17.
31	刘吉昌, 曾醒. 情感认同是铸牢中华民族共同体意识的核心要素. 中南民族大学学报(人文社会科学版),2020,40(6):11-16.
31	LI J, ZHENG X. Emotional identity is the core element to consolidate the consciousness of the Chinese nation's community. Journal of South-Central University for Nationalities(Humanities and Social Sciences),2020,40(6):11-16.
32	黄敏瑶, 张敏. 具身实践下的地方认知: 非表征理论与南京马拉松. 地理研究,2019,38(6):77-88.
32	HUANG M, ZHANG M. Cognition of place in embodied practice: Non-representational theory and Nanjing marathon. Geographical Reseach,2019,38(6):77-88.
33	李荣荣,麻彦坤,叶浩生.具身的情绪:情绪研究的新范式.心理科学,2012,35(3):754-759.
33	LI R, MA Y, YE H.The embodiment of emotion: A new paradigm in the study of emotion.Journal of Psychological Science,2012,35(3):754-759.
34	邓纯考, 孙芙蓉, 李子涵. 具身认知视角下研学旅行与学校课程的衔接. 中国教育学刊,2020(10):82-86.
34	DENG C, SUN F, LI Z. The connection between research trip and school curriculum from the perspective of embodied cognition. Journal of the Chinese Society of Education,2020(10):82-86.
35	赵现红. 基于游客体验视角的现代节事旅游开发研究——以开封菊花文化节为例. 地域研究与开发,2014,33(3):117-121.
35	ZHAO X. A study on development of modern FSE based on tourist experience: An example of Kaifeng chrysanthemum show. Areal Research and Development,2014,33(3):117-121.
36	罗赟敏,先巴,唐仲霞.近十年国内宗教旅游研究综述.资源开发与市场,2018,34(6):850-854.
36	LUO Y, XIAN B, TANG Z. Systematic review of religious tourism for recent ten years in China. Resource Development ＆ Market,2018,34(6):850-854.
37	宋竹芳, 张高军, 李树民. 黑亦非黑: 基于线上数据的黑色旅游体验及群体比较. 旅游学刊,2019,34(5):90-104.
37	SONG Z, ZHANG G, LI S. Is dark tourism all darkness? A groups comparison study of tourist experience based on UGC. Tourism Tribune,2019,34(5):90-104.