世界地理研究 ›› 2022, Vol. 31 ›› Issue (3): 466-477.DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1004-9479.2022.03.2020858
• 世界政治与经济 • 下一篇
收稿日期:
2020-12-04
修回日期:
2021-03-12
出版日期:
2022-05-15
发布日期:
2022-05-17
通讯作者:
黄贤金
作者简介:
钟苏娟(1998-),女,硕士研究生,研究方向为资源环境与可持续发展,E-mail:sjzhong32@163.com。
基金资助:
Sujuan ZHONG(), Xiyan MAO, Xianjin HUANG()
Received:
2020-12-04
Revised:
2021-03-12
Online:
2022-05-15
Published:
2022-05-17
Contact:
Xianjin HUANG
摘要:
全球地缘政治竞争回潮与资源环境危机推动国际河流水资源开发利用成为影响国家地缘安全的关键变量。通过对既有文献的梳理,发现国际河流水资源开发利用在“稀缺-冲突”范式下激化流域各国的矛盾,引发的水资源冲突联合域外势力进一步作用于国家地缘安全;在地缘安全视角下,中国国际河流的水资源开发利用经历了从“弱安全化”到“强安全化”再到“去安全化”的演进;水环境治理、水量分配及水开发利益协调是水资源开发利用中的核心议题,涉及的跨境水资源污染、水权分配以及水电开发争议等问题与国家地缘安全密切相关;东北、西北及西南三大国际河流密集区水资源开发利用方式地域分异明显,在差异化的地缘环境下带来多元的地缘安全威胁;最后基于“一带一路”及“人类命运共同体”等背景对中国未来外交提出建议。
钟苏娟, 毛熙彦, 黄贤金. 地缘安全视角下的中国国际河流水资源开发利用[J]. 世界地理研究, 2022, 31(3): 466-477.
Sujuan ZHONG, Xiyan MAO, Xianjin HUANG. Water resources exploitation and utilization of international rivers in China from the perspective of geo-security[J]. World Regional Studies, 2022, 31(3): 466-477.
类型 | 境内名称 | 境外名称 | 流域国家 | 开发利用 | 主要问题 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
东北地区 | 黑龙江 | 阿穆尔河 | 中国、蒙古国、朝鲜、俄罗斯 | 水电开发、农业灌溉、国际通航、跨境贸易 | 水环境污染、水土流失、洪涝灾害 |
鸭绿江 | 鸭绿江 | 中国、朝鲜 | |||
图们江 | 图们江 | 中国、朝鲜、俄罗斯 | |||
绥芬河 | 绥芬河 | 中国、俄罗斯 | |||
西北地区 | 乌伦古河 | 乌伦古河 | 中国、蒙古国 | 农业灌溉、城市供水、生态供水 | 开发力度不足、灌排基础设施欠缺、地下水-地表水开发失衡 |
额尔齐斯河 | 鄂毕河 | 中国、哈萨克斯坦、蒙古国、俄罗斯 | |||
伊犁河 | 巴尔喀什湖 | 中国、哈萨克斯坦、吉尔吉斯斯坦 | |||
塔里木河 | 阿克苏河 | 阿富汗、中国、哈萨克斯坦、吉尔吉斯斯坦、塔吉克斯坦 | |||
额敏河 | 阿拉湖 | 中国、哈萨克斯坦 | |||
西南地区 | 独龙江 | 伊洛瓦底江 | 中国、印度、缅甸 | 水电开发、航运贸易、农业灌溉 | 水电站开发争议、气候变化、生态环境保护、域外势力干预 |
怒江 | 萨尔温江 | 中国、缅甸、泰国 | |||
澜沧江 | 湄公河 | 中国、缅甸、老挝、泰国、柬埔寨、越南 | |||
珠江 | 奇穷河/北江 | 中国、越南 | |||
雅鲁藏布江 | 恒河-布拉马普特拉河-梅格纳河/巴吉拉提河 | 孟加拉国、不丹、中国、印度、缅甸、尼泊尔 | |||
森格藏布河/狮泉河 | 印度河 | 阿富汗、中国、印度、尼泊尔、巴基斯坦 | |||
北仑河 | 北仑河 | 中国、越南 | |||
元江/红河 | 红河 | 中国、老挝、越南 | |||
先安江 | 先安江 | 中国、越南 |
表1 中国国际河流的水资源开发利用
Tab.1 Water resources exploitation and utilization of international rivers in China
类型 | 境内名称 | 境外名称 | 流域国家 | 开发利用 | 主要问题 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
东北地区 | 黑龙江 | 阿穆尔河 | 中国、蒙古国、朝鲜、俄罗斯 | 水电开发、农业灌溉、国际通航、跨境贸易 | 水环境污染、水土流失、洪涝灾害 |
鸭绿江 | 鸭绿江 | 中国、朝鲜 | |||
图们江 | 图们江 | 中国、朝鲜、俄罗斯 | |||
绥芬河 | 绥芬河 | 中国、俄罗斯 | |||
西北地区 | 乌伦古河 | 乌伦古河 | 中国、蒙古国 | 农业灌溉、城市供水、生态供水 | 开发力度不足、灌排基础设施欠缺、地下水-地表水开发失衡 |
额尔齐斯河 | 鄂毕河 | 中国、哈萨克斯坦、蒙古国、俄罗斯 | |||
伊犁河 | 巴尔喀什湖 | 中国、哈萨克斯坦、吉尔吉斯斯坦 | |||
塔里木河 | 阿克苏河 | 阿富汗、中国、哈萨克斯坦、吉尔吉斯斯坦、塔吉克斯坦 | |||
额敏河 | 阿拉湖 | 中国、哈萨克斯坦 | |||
西南地区 | 独龙江 | 伊洛瓦底江 | 中国、印度、缅甸 | 水电开发、航运贸易、农业灌溉 | 水电站开发争议、气候变化、生态环境保护、域外势力干预 |
怒江 | 萨尔温江 | 中国、缅甸、泰国 | |||
澜沧江 | 湄公河 | 中国、缅甸、老挝、泰国、柬埔寨、越南 | |||
珠江 | 奇穷河/北江 | 中国、越南 | |||
雅鲁藏布江 | 恒河-布拉马普特拉河-梅格纳河/巴吉拉提河 | 孟加拉国、不丹、中国、印度、缅甸、尼泊尔 | |||
森格藏布河/狮泉河 | 印度河 | 阿富汗、中国、印度、尼泊尔、巴基斯坦 | |||
北仑河 | 北仑河 | 中国、越南 | |||
元江/红河 | 红河 | 中国、老挝、越南 | |||
先安江 | 先安江 | 中国、越南 |
1 | 安宁,蔡晓梅.跨学科视角下"地缘政治"概念及其研究范式.地理科学,2020,40(9):1412-1420. |
AN N, CAI X. Debates on the concept of 'geopolitics' and its research paradigm from an interdisciplinary perspective. Scientia Geographica Sinica,2020,40(9):1412-1420. | |
2 | 卢函,杜德斌,桂钦昌,等.跨界水冲突、合作与全球水政治关系时空演化.资源科学,2020,42(6):1162-1174. |
LU H, DU D, GUI Q, et al. Spatiotemporal evolution of transboundary water conflict, cooperation, and global hydro-political relations. Resources Science, 2020, 42(6):1162-1174. | |
3 | MCCRACKEN M, WOLF A. Updating the register of international river basins of the world. International Journal of Water Resources Development, 2019, 35(5): 732-782. |
4 | 罗贤,倪广恒,孔令杰,等.全球变化下的跨境水资源科学调控与利益共享研究.中国基础科学,2019,21(4):28-34. |
LUO X, NI G, KONG L, et al. Research advances of scientific regulation and benefit sharing on cross-border water resources under global change. China Basic Science,2019,21(4):28-34. | |
5 | 韩叶.水权的合法性:国际河流水资源分配中的规范竞争.外交评论(外交学院学报),2014,31(5):139-156. |
HAN Y. Legality of water rights: Normative competition in water resources allocation in international rivers. Foreign Affairs Review,2014,31(5):139-156. | |
6 | 王江,张明.国际河流水资源争端研究:规范诠释、目标指引与策略举要(英文).China Legal Science,2020,8(5):115-134. |
WANG J, ZHANG M. Disputes over international river water resources: Normative interpretation, target guidance and strategies enumeration. China Legal Science,2020,8(5):115-134. | |
7 | 李明亮,侯杰.跨界河流利用和保护合作的国际规则分析.水利规划与设计,2020(8):5-8+29. |
LI M, HOU J. Analysis of international rules for cooperation on use and protection of transboundary rivers. Water Resources Planning and Design,2020(8):5-8+29. | |
8 | 王志坚,何其二.简论国际河流水政治复合体.水利经济,2013,31(4):36-39+74-75. |
WANG Z, HE Q. On hydropolitical complex of international rivers. Journal of Economics of Water Resources,2013,31(4):36-39+74-75. | |
9 | 于宏源,李坤海.地缘性介入与制度性嵌构:美国亚太区域水安全外交战略.国际安全研究,2020,38(5):58-80+158. |
YU H, LI K. Geographical intervention and institutional embedding: The US diplomatic strategy for water security in the Asia-Pacific region. Journal of International Security Studies,2020,38(5):58-80+158. | |
10 | 杨晓萍. 超越"稀缺-冲突"视角:中印崛起背景下跨境水资源问题. 国际论坛, 2012(4):37-43. |
YANG X. Beyond 'scarcity-conflict' perspective: trans-boundary water in the context of emerging India and rising China. International Forum, 2012(4):37-43. | |
11 | BULLOCH J, DARWISH A. Water Wars: Coming Conflicts in the Middle East. British: Victor Gollancz. 1993. |
12 | ZEITOUN M., WARNER J. Hydro-hegemony-a framework for analysis of trans-boundary water conflicts. Water Policy, 2006, 8(5): 435-460. |
13 | 胡志丁,王学文.大国地缘战略交汇区的时空演变:特征、规律及其原因.热带地理,2019,39(6):833-843. |
HU Z, WANG X. Temporal and spatial evolution characteristics and laws of geostrategic intersections in great powers. Tropical Geography,2019,39(6):833-843. | |
14 | 杜德斌,刘承良,胡志丁,等."亚洲水塔"变化对中国周边地缘政治环境的影响.世界地理研究,2020,29(2):223-231. |
DU D, LIU C, HU Z, et al. The impact of "Asian Water Tower" change on the geopolitical environment around China. World Regional Studies, 2020,29(2):223-231. | |
15 | 何大明,刘昌明,冯彦 等.中国国际河流研究进展及展望.地理学报,2014,69(9):1284-1294. |
HE D, LIU C, FENG Y, et al. Progress and perspective of international river researches in China. Acta Geographica Sinica,2014,69(9):1284-1294. | |
16 | 何大明,苟俊华.全球变化对跨境淡水资源利用和管理的影响.自然资源学报,1999(3):3-5. |
HE D, GOU J. Impacts of global changes upon utilization and management of transboundary fresh water resources. Journal of Natural Resources,1999(3):3-5. | |
17 | 何大明,刘昌明,杨志峰.中国国际河流可持续发展研究.地理学报,1999(S1):3-5. |
HE D, LIU C, YANG Z. Study for the sustainability of international rivers in China. Acta Geographica Sinica,1999(S1):3-5. | |
18 | 贾生元,戴艳文.国际河流黑龙江生态环境保护与可持续利用探讨.黑河学刊,2000(4):36-37. |
JIA S, DAI Y. Discussion on ecological environment protection and sustainable utilization of international rivers in Heilongjiang province. Heihe Journal,2000(4):36-37. | |
19 | 冯彦,何大明.多瑙河国际水争端仲裁案对我国国际河流开发的启示.长江流域资源与环境,2002(5):471-475. |
FENG Y, HE D. Revelation of the water uses in international rivers of China from the water dispute case on the Danube by international court of justice. Resources and Environment in the Yangtze Basin,2002(5):471-475. | |
20 | 胡翊.基于"去安全化"视角下中印跨界水资源的合作.印度洋经济体研究,2019(3):70-85+153-154. |
HU X. Cooperation between China and India in transboundary water resources from the perspective of "Desecuritization". Indian Ocean Economic and Political Review,2019(3):70-85+153-154. | |
21 | 肖阳.十八大以来中国周边水外交的回顾与展望.中国周边外交学刊,2017(2):70-91. |
XIAO Y. Retrospect and prospect on China's water diplomacy since the 18th National Congress of Chinese Communist Party. Journal of China's Neighboring Diplomacy,2017(2):70-91. | |
22 | 李昕蕾,华冉.国际流域水安全复合体中的安全秩序建构——基于澜沧江-湄公河流域水冲突-合作事件的分析.社会科学,2019(3):17-35. |
LI X, HUA R. Security order construction in the water security complex of international basin: Based on the water-event analysis of Lancang-Mekong river. Journal of Social Sciences,2019(3):17-35. | |
23 | 谢永刚,王建丽,潘娟.中俄跨境水污染灾害及区域减灾合作机制探讨.东北亚论坛,2013,22(4):82-91+129. |
XIE Y, WANG J, PAN J. Discussion on Sino-Russia cross-border water pollution and cooperation mechanisms for regional disaster deduction. Northeast Asia Forum,2013,22(4):82-91+129. | |
24 | 谢建英.中国跨界水污染治理的困境与出路.法制博览,2019(3):194+193. |
XIE J. The plight and outlet of transboundary water pollution control in China. Legality Vision,2019(3):194+193. | |
25 | 吴凤平,黄子桐,邵志颖,等.构建应对疫情的跨境河流水源保护新机制.水利经济,2020,38(5):6-11+75. |
WU F, HUANG Z, SHAO Y, et al. Constructing a new mechanism of water source protection for cross-border rivers in response to epidemic situation. Journal of Economics of Water Resources,2020,38(5):6-11+75. | |
26 | 李志斐.气候变化与中国周边地区水资源安全.国际政治研究,2015,36(4):37-55+5-6. |
LI Z. Climate change and water security in China's periphery. The Journal of International Studies,2015,36(4):37-55+5-6. | |
27 | STEFANO L, DUNCAN J, DINAR S, et al. Climate change and the institutional resilience of international river basins. Journal of Peace Research, 2012, 49(1): 193-209. |
28 | 何大明,刘恒,冯彦,等.全球变化下跨境水资源理论与方法研究展望.水科学进展,2016,27(6):928-934. |
HE D, LIU H, FENG Y, et al. Perspective on theories and methods study of transboundary water resources under the global change. Advances in Water Science,2016,27(6):928-934. | |
29 | 刘宗瑞,周海炜,赵又霖.国际河流跨境洪灾防治的合作特征及演进趋势——基于防洪合作协议的内容分析.中国人口·资源与环境,2015,25(12):78-84. |
LIU Z, ZHOU H, ZHAO Y. Cooperation characters and evolution trends of international rivers' cross-border flood prevention based on the content analysis of flood prevention cooperation agreements. China Population, Resources and Environment,2015,25(12):78-84. | |
30 | 王志坚,翟晓敏.我国东北国际河流与东北亚安全.东北亚论坛,2007(4):70-73. |
WANG Z, ZHAO X. Northeast international rivers of China and northeast Asia' security. Northeast Asia Forum,2007(4):70-73. | |
31 | 冯彦.国际河流水资源利用与管理.北京:科学出版社,2019. |
FENG Y. Utilization and management of international river water resources. Beijing: China: Science Press, 2019. | |
32 | 葛勇平,苏铭煜.公平合理利用原则在国际水法中的适用局限及其反思.河海大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2020,22(1):91-98. |
GE Y, SU M. The application limitation of the principle of equitable and reasonable utilization in international water law and its reflection. Journal of Hohai University(Philosophy and Social Sciences), 2020,22(1):91-98. | |
33 | 何艳梅.联合国国际水道公约生效后的中国策略.上海政法学院学报(法治论丛),2015,30(5):44-57. |
HE Y. China's strategy after the entry into force of UN convention on international watercourses. Journal of Shanghai University of Political Science & Law (The Rule of Law Forum),2015,30(5):44-57. | |
34 | 余世维,冯彦,王文玲.«国际水道非航行使用法公约»被认可的区域差异性.地理学报,2017,72(2):303-314. |
YU S, FENG Y, WANG W. Differences among the parties of "Convention on the Law of the Non-navigational Uses of International Watercourses". Acta Geographica Sinica,2017,72(2):303-314. | |
35 | 何大明,冯彦,陈丽晖,等.跨境水资源的分配模式、原则和指标体系研究.水科学进展,2005(2):255-262. |
HE D, FENG Y, CHEN L, et al. Study on models, principles and index system on trans-boundary water resources allocation. Advances in Water Science,2005(2):255-262. | |
36 | 孙周亮,刘艳丽,张建云,等.澜湄合作机制下的跨境水资源分配模式研究.水资源研究,2020,9(3):270-278. |
SUN Z, LIU Y, ZHANG J, et al. Allocation modes of trans-boundary water resources under the cooperation mechanism in Lancang-Mekong river basin. Journal of Water Resources Research,2020,9(3):270-278. | |
37 | 冯彦,何大明,李运刚.基于国际法的跨境水分配关键指标及其特征.地理学报,2013,68(3):357-364. |
FENG Y, HE D, LI Y. Key indicators and the characteristics of trans-boundary water allocation based on international treaties. Acta Geographica Sinica,2013,68(3):357-364. | |
38 | 冯彦,何大明,王文玲.基于河流健康及国际法的跨境水分配关键指标及阈值.地理学报,2015,70(1):121-130. |
FENG Y, HE D, WANG W. Key indicators and the thresholds of trans-boundary water allocation based on river health and international treaties. Acta Geographica Sinica,2015,70(1):121-130. | |
39 | 洪菊花,骆华松.中国与东南亚地缘环境和跨境河流合作.世界地理研究,2015,24(1):29-37. |
HONG J, LUO H. Geopolitical environment and cooperation of transboundary river between China and southeast Asia. World Regional Studies,2015,24(1):29-37. | |
40 | 钟华平,刘恒,耿雷华.怒江水电梯级开发的生态环境累积效应.水电能源科学,2008(1):52-55+59. |
ZHONG H, LIU H, GENG L. Ecology and environment cumulative effects of cascaded hydropower development in Nujiang river. Water Resources and Power,2008(1):52-55+59. | |
41 | PITTOCK J, DUMARESQ D, BASSI M. Modeling the hydropower–food nexus in large river basins: A mekong case study. Water, 2016, 8(10): 425. |
42 | KESKINEN M, SOMETH P, SALMIVAARA A, et al. Water-energy-food nexus in a transboundary river basin: The case of Tonle Sap Lake, Mekong River Basin. Water, 2015, 7(10): 5416-5436. |
43 | CHEN X, XU B, ZHENG Y, et al. Nexus of water, energy and ecosystems in the upper Mekong River: A system analysis of phosphorus transport through cascade reservoirs. Science of The Total Environment, 2019(671): 1179-1191. |
44 | 许长新,孙洋洋.基于"一带一路"战略视角的中国周边水外交.世界经济与政治论坛,2016(5):110-121. |
XU C, SUN Y. China's neighboring water diplomacy based on the "Belt and Road" strategic perspective. Forum of World Economics & Politics,2016(5):110-121. | |
45 | 李兴,耿捷."安全化"与"去安全化":中哈跨界河流合作中的问题与对策.国外理论动态,2019(11):115-127. |
LI X, GENG J."Securitization" and "Desecuritization": Problems and countermeasures in Sino-Kazakhstan cross-border river cooperation. Foreign Theoretical Trends,2019(11):115-127. | |
46 | 孙才志,王中慧.中国和"一带一路"沿线国家农产品虚拟水贸易的驱动因素.水利经济,2020,38(1):1-7+28+85. |
SUN C, WANG Z. Driving factors for virtual water trade of agricultural products between China and countries along "Belt and Road". Journal of Economics of Water Resources,2020,38(1):1-7+28+85. | |
47 | 陈霁巍.中国跨界河流合作回顾与展望.边界与海洋研究,2019,4(5):60-70. |
CHEN J. Cooperation and prospective on transboundary rivers between China and its neighboring countries.Journal of Boundary and Ocean Studies,2019,4(5):60-70. | |
48 | 周连义,李冉,朱晖.恢复图们江出海权对东北亚区域经济政治和我国东北地区的影响和对策.海洋开发与管理,2020,37(2):36-40. |
ZHOU L, LI R, ZHU H. The influence and strategy of restoring the right of access to Japan Sea through Tumen river on the regional economy and politics of northeast Asia and the northeast China. Ocean Development and Management,2020,37(2):36-40. | |
49 | 赵玉明.中亚地区水资源问题:美国的认知、介入与评价.俄罗斯东欧中亚研究,2017(3):79-89+157. |
ZHAO Y. Water resource problem in central Asia: American cognition, intervention and evaluation. Russian, East European & Central Asian Studies,2017(3):79-89+157. | |
50 | 何流.伊犁河流域水资源开发利用现状分析及对策.陕西水利,2019(7):49-51. |
HE L.Analysis and countermeasures on the present situation of water resources development and utilization in Yili river basin. Shaanxi Water Resources,2019(7):49-51. | |
51 | 姜志文,蒋伟.额敏河流域综合开发的社会效益和生态效应分析.吉林水利,2015(8):32-36+40. |
JIANG Z, JIANG W. Social and ecological effect in the comprehensive development of Emin River. Jilin Water Resources,2015(8):32-36+40. | |
52 | 马亚华,周亚兰,黄丹华.海上丝路背景下南亚地缘格局的解构与再建构——基于印巴均势视角.世界地理研究,2020,29(3):439-450. |
MA Y, ZHOU Y, HUANG D. On the restructuring of geopolitics in South Asia under the background of Maritime Silk Road——From perspective of strategic balance between India and Pakistan. World Regional Studies,2020,29(3):439-450. | |
53 | 李志斐.中印领土争端中的水资源安全问题.南亚研究季刊,2013(4):29-34+4. |
LI Z. Water resource security involved in China——India territorial disputes. South Asian Studies Quarterly,2013(4):29-34+4. |
[1] | 郭利丹, 井沛然, 张玉阔. 中国国际河流研究热点与前沿的可视化分析[J]. 世界地理研究, 2022, 31(3): 490-502. |
[2] | 刘晓凤, 张文雅, 程小兰, 王雨, 葛岳静. 跨域水治理中的尺度重构:以东江为例[J]. 世界地理研究, 2021, 30(2): 297-307. |
阅读次数 | ||||||
全文 |
|
|||||
摘要 |
|
|||||