Research on the changes of China's fruit planting distribution and its influence effect: Based on the perspective of price changes of rural labor

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1004-9479.2023.09.2021645

Abstract

Abstract:

On deriving the impact model of the evolution of the fruit industry distribution in China and the datum of 22 major provinces planting fruit in 1985-2019, it studies the impact of agricultural labor price, non-agricultural labor prices and the proportion of wage in farmers' income on the distribution evolution of fruit industry empirically. The results show that: The increases of agricultural labor price, non-agricultural labor prices and the proportion of wages in farmers' income bring a substitution effect on fruit planting in provinces from eastern areas, which results in a decline or unchanging acreage of fruit planting, that is the acreage proportions in provinces from eastern areas decrease; There are inhibitory effect of agricultural labor price, non-agricultural labor prices and the proportion of wages in farmers' income on fruit planting by which the substitution effect and the income effect offset each other, so that the proportion of fruit planting in middle areas has no significant change; There are comparative advantage produced by lower agricultural labor price and lower non-agricultural labor prices and income effect produced by increasing wages which stimulate the acreages of fruit planting expand and the acreages proportion increase in large scale in provinces from northwest and southwest areas so that a distribution of "westward and inward expansion" of the fruit plant in China is forming.Therefore, it is necessary to solve the problems of excessively high prices of rural labor in areas suitable for fruit plant and low prices of rural labor in unsuitable areas.

Key words: price of agricultural labor, price of non-agricultural labor, the proportion of wages in farmers' income, fruit planting distribution

摘要：

在推导中国水果产业布局演变的影响模型基础上，以1985—2019年中国22个水果主产省为研究对象，探讨农业劳动价格、非农劳动价格和工资收入占比对我国水果产业布局演变的影响效应。结果表明：农业劳动价格、非农劳动价格和工资收入占比的提高对东部水果种植产生替代效应，造成东部各省区水果种植面积减少或增幅不明显，比重下降；农业劳动价格、非农劳动价格和工资收入占比对中部水果种植的影响具有省际异质性，产生的替代效应和收入效应相互抵消，导致中部整体水果种植比重无显著变化；西北、西南地区较低的农业劳动工价和非农劳动价格使其具有劳动成本比较优势，工资收入占比提高产生收入效应，使西北、西南地区水果种植面积大幅增加，比重上升，促成我国水果种植布局“西移内扩”。因此，优化水果产业布局要解决水果适宜区农村劳动力价格过高和非适宜区农村劳动力价格过低等问题。

关键词: 农业劳动价格, 非农劳动价格, 工资收入占比, 水果产业布局

You HU, Xin CHEN, Chunjie QI. Research on the changes of China's fruit planting distribution and its influence effect: Based on the perspective of price changes of rural labor[J]. World Regional Studies, 2023, 32(9): 93-108.

胡友, 陈昕, 祁春节. 中国水果产业布局演变及其影响效应研究[J]. 世界地理研究, 2023, 32(9): 93-108.

Figures/Tables 8

References 57

1	邓秀新.关于我国水果产业发展若干问题的思考.果树学报,2021,38(1):121-127.
	DENG X. Thoughts on the development of China's fruit industry. Journal of Fruit Science,2021,38(1): 121-127.
2	白秀广,陈晓楠,霍学喜.气候变化对苹果主产区单产及全要素生产率增长的影响研究.农业技术经济,2015(8):98-111.
	BAI X, CHEN X, HUO X. Impact of climate change on the yield and total factor productivity growth of the main producing areas of apple. Agricultural Technology and Economy, 2015(8): 98-111.
3	陈志峰,张伟利,严小燕,等.福建省县域茶叶产业竞争力分析与优化布局.经济地理,2017,37(12):145-152.
	CHEN Z, ZHANG W, YAN X, et al. Analysis of industrial competitiveness and spatial optimization of county tea industry in Fujian Province. Economic Geography,2017,37(12): 145-152.
4	张宇翔."十四五"时期优化农业生产布局的思考与建议.宏观经济管理,2020(8):6-12.
	ZHANG Y. Thoughts and suggestions on optimizing the layout of agricultural production during the "14th Five-Year Plan" period. Macroeconomic Management,2020(8): 6-12.
5	张有望,章胜勇.中三角地区柑橘生产的空间布局变迁及影响因素分析.农业现代化研究,2016,37(4):687-693.
	ZHANG Y, ZHANG S. Study on citrus production's spatial distribution, changes and influencing factors in Central Delta Area. Research of Agricultural Modernization,2016,37(4): 687-693.
6	唐荣莉,姚雄,王春萍,等.基于空间统计的重庆市水稻生产地理集聚时空演变.中国生态农业学报,2018,26(7):958-970.
	TANG R, YAO X, WANG C, et al. Spatiotemporal evolution of rice production geographical agglomeration in Chongqing based on spatial statistics. Chinese Journal of Eco-Agriculture,2018,26(7): 958-970.
7	杨春,陆文聪.中国粮食生产空间布局变迁实证.经济地理,2008,28(5):813-816.
	YANG C, LU W. Empirical analysis of grain production spatial distribution changing in China. Economic Geography, 2008,28(5): 813-816.
8	王世尧,王树进.中国省区蔬菜种植面积变化中农户决策行为因素的实证分析.经济地理,2013,33(9):128-134.
	WANG S, WANG S. Empirical analysis of farmers' decision-making behavioral factors in the change of vegetable planting area in Chinese provinces. Economic Geography, 2013, 33(9): 128-134.
9	李谷成.人力资本与中国区域农业全要素生产率增长——基于DEA视角的实证分析.财经研究,2009,35(8):115-128.
	LI G. Human capital and TFP growth of regional agriculture in China: Empirical study based on Data Envelopment Analysis. Financial Research, 2009, 35(8): 115-128.
10	高道明,王丽红,田志宏.我国小麦生产的要素替代关系研究.中国农业大学学报,2018,23(6):169-176.
	GAO D, WANG L, TIAN Z. Research on the factor substitution relationships of wheat production. Journal of China Agricultural University, 2018, 23(6): 169-176.
11	姜天龙,郭庆海.农户收入结构支撑下的种粮积极性及可持续性分析——以吉林省为例.农业经济问题,2012,33(6):14-20.
	JIANG T, GUO Q. Producers' enthusiasm for grain production and policy support under the income structure: Case of Jilin Province. Issues in Agricultural Economics, 2012, 33(6): 14-20.
12	罗万纯,陈永福.中国粮食生产区域格局及影响因素研究.农业技术经济,2005(6):58-64.
	LUO W, CHEN Y. Variables affecting grain production in China: Regional patterns. Agricultural Technology Economy,2005(6):58-64.
13	刘玉杰,杨艳昭,封志明.中国粮食生产的区域格局变化及其可能影响.资源科学,2007,29(2):8-14.
	LIU Y, YANG Y, FENG Z. The change of the main regions for China's food grain production and its implications. Resources Science,2007,29(2):8-14.
14	钟甫宁,刘顺飞.中国水稻生产布局变动分析.中国农村经济,2007(9):39-44.
	ZHONG F, LIU S. An analysis of changes in regional distribution of paddy rice production in China. China Rural Economy,2007(9):39-44.
15	钟甫宁,胡雪梅.中国棉花生产区域格局及影响因素研究. 农业技术经济,2008(1):4-9.
	ZHONG F, HU X. Research on China's cotton production regional pattern and influencing factors. Agricultural Technology Economy,2008(1):4-9.
16	朱启荣.中国棉花主产区生产布局分析.中国农村经济,2009(4):31-38.
	ZHU Q. An analysis of production location in China's main cotton growing areas. China Rural Economy,2009(4):31-38.
17	揭懋汕,雪燕,薛领. 我国棉花生产的空间格局演化及集聚因素分析. 农业现代化研究,2015(3):387-393.
	JIE M, XUE Y, XUE L. Analysis of the spatial pattern evolution and agglomeration factors of cotton production in my country. Research of Agricultural Modernization,2015(3):387-393.
18	薛晓聪,樊斌. 中国奶牛养殖生产布局时空演变分析. 中国畜牧杂志,2019,55(11):174-179.
	XUE X, FAN B. Analysis on temporal and spatial evolution in production distribution of dairy cow farming in China. Chinese Journal of Animal Husbandry,2019,55(11):174-179.
19	周曙东,景令怡,孟桓宽,等. 中国花生主产区生产布局演变规律及动因挖掘. 农业技术经济,2018(3):100-109.
	ZHOU S, JING L, MENG H, et al. Analysis on spatial distribution evolution of main peanut production areas in China and its influencing factors. Agricultural Technology Economy,2018(3):100-109.
20	薛龙飞,张雯丽,杨晨. 中国特色油料作物生产区域变动及其影响因素分析. 农业现代化研究,2019,40(5):755-763.
	XUE L, ZHANG W, YANG C. The production concentration shift of China's specialty oil crops and the influencing factors. Research of Agricultural Modernization,2019,40(5):755-763.
21	袁斌,张燕媛,陈超. 中国苹果产业格局演化及机制分析——基于农户决策的微观视角. 干旱区资源与环境,2017,31(6):32-37.
	YUAN B, ZHANG Y, CHEN C. Spatial pattern evolution and its driving factors for apple industry in China--Based on micro perspective of farmers' decision making. Arid Land Resources and Environment,2017,31(6):32-37.
22	张聪颖,畅倩,霍学喜. 中国苹果生产区域变迁分析. 经济地理,2018,38(8):141-151.
	ZHANG C, CHANG Q, HUO X. Analysis on the layout of China's apple production transition. Economic Geography, 2018,38(8):141-151.
23	胡友,陈昕,祁春节. 农村劳动价格、收入结构变化与柑橘种植布局变迁. 农业现代化研究,2021,42(3):496-506.
	HU Y, CHEN X, QI C. Rural labor price, farm income structure changes, and citrus production layout evolution. Research of Agricultural Modernization,2021,42(3):496-506.
24	叶露,李玉萍,李茂芬,等. 我国芒果布局时空变迁及对劳动力市场的反应研究. 西南农业学报,2021,34(5):1054-1061.
	YE L, LI Y, LI M, et al. Spatiotemporal change of mango production distribution and its response to labor market in China. Southwest Journal of Agriculture,2021,34(5):1054-1061.
25	李二玲,庞安超,朱纪广. 中国农业地理集聚格局演化及其机制. 地理研究,2012,31(5):885-898.
	LI E, PANG A, ZHU J. Analysis of the evolution path and mechanism of China's agricultural agglomeration and geographic pattern. Geographical Research,2012,31(5):885-898.
26	张强强,司瑞石,施凡基,等. 中国水果生产集中化水平的演进趋势. 中国农业资源与区划,2021,42(2):96-108.
	ZHANG Q, SI R, SHI F, et al. The evolution trend of Chinese fruit production concentration level. China Agricultural Resources and Regionalization,2021,42(2):96-108.
27	李光泗,朱丽莉. 农村劳动力流动对中国粮食生产影响研究:基于省域动态面板数据的实证分析. 统计与信息论坛,2014(10):24-30.
	LI G, ZHU L. A study on the effect mechanism of the rural labor flow on the grain production: Based on the empirical analysis of the dynamic panel data of provinces. Forum on Statistics and Information,2014(10):24-30.
28	李谷成,卢毓,尹朝静. 中国农产品比较优势动态变化的实证分析. 华中农业大学学报(社会科学版),2014(2):61-67.
	LI G, LU Y, YIN C. An empirical analysis on dynamics of agricultural products' comparative advantages in China. Journal of Huazhong Agricultural University (Social Science Edition),2014(2):61-67.
29	黄玛兰,李晓云,曾琳琳. 农村劳动力价格上涨与劳动力转移对作物种植结构的区域性影响差异. 农业现代化研究,2019,40(1):98-108.
	HUANG M, LI X, ZENG L. Different reginal impacts of rural labor price increase and rural labor mitigation on crop structure in China. Research on Agricultural Modernization, 2019, 40(1): 98-108.
30	郑祥江,杨锦秀. 农业劳动力转移对农业生产的影响研究. 华南农业大学学报(社会科学版),2015,14(2):50-56.
	ZHENG X, YANG J. Study on the impact of rural labor transfer on agricultural production. Journal of South China Agricultural University (Social Science Edition), 2015, 14(2): 50-56.
31	杨帆,夏海勇. 我国农业部门劳动力投入的经济增长效应. 人口与经济,2012(5):8-13.
	YANG F, XIA H. The economic growth effect of labor input in China's agricultural sector. Population and Economy, 2012(5): 8-13.
32	范东君,朱有志. 农业劳动力外流对粮食生产影响研究——基于二元经济背景. 河北经贸大学学报,2012,33(1):39-43.
	FAN D, ZHU Y. The outflow of agricultural labor force on grain production affection in the context of the dual economy. Journal of Hebei University of Economics and Trade, 2012, 33(1): 39-43.
33	尹朝静,范丽霞,李谷成,等. 劳动力成本上升背景下油菜生产发展方式转型研究. 中国农业大学学报,2015,20(6):297-304.
	YIN C, FAN L, LI G, et al. Research on the transformation of rape production mode as the growth of labor cost. Journal of China Agricultural University,2015,20(6):297-304.
34	THIRTLE C, TOWNSEND R, ZYL J V. Testing the induced innovation hypothesis: an error correction model of South African agriculture. Agricultural Economics, 1998, 19(1-2):145-157.
35	DONG S. Declining energy intensity in the U.S. agricultural sector: Implications for factor substitution and technological change. Sustainability,2015,7(10):13192-13205.
36	周振,马庆超,孔祥智. 农业机械化对农村劳动力转移贡献的量化研究. 农业技术经济,2016(2):52-62.
	ZHOU Z, MA Q, KONG X. The quantitative study on the contribution of agricultural mechanization to the transfer of rural labor force. Agricultural Technology and Economy, 2016(2): 52-62.
37	TAKESHIMA H, PRATT N A, DIAO X. Agricultural mechanization patterns in Nigeria: Insights from farm household typology and agricultural household model simulation. IFPRI Discussion Paper,2013(9):01291.
38	李谷成,梁玲,尹朝静,等. 劳动力转移损害了油菜生产吗?——基于要素产出弹性和替代弹性的实证. 华中农业大学学报(社会科学版),2015(1):7-13.
	LI G, LIANG L, YIN C, et al. Did labor transfer harm production of rapeseeds in China?--Based on factor production elasticity and substitution elasticity. Journal of Huazhong Agricultural University (Social Science Edition), 2015(1): 7-13.
39	向云,祁春节,王伟新. 柑橘生产的要素替代关系及增长路径研究——基于主产区面板数据的实证分析. 中国农业大学学报,2017,22(7):200-209.
	XIANG Y, QI C, WANG W. Key factor substitution and growth path of citrus production: An empirical analysis based on the panel data of main production area. Journal of China Agricultural University, 2017, 22(7): 200-209.
40	吴伟伟,刘耀彬. 非农收入对农业要素投入结构的影响研究. 中国人口科学,2017(2):70-79.
	WU W, LIU Y. The impact of non-agricultural income on input structure of agricultural factors under the background of rural labour migration. China Population Science, 2017(2): 70-79.
41	盖庆恩,朱喜,史清华. 劳动力转移对中国农业生产的影响. 经济学(季刊),2014,13(3):1147-1170.
	GAI Q, ZHU X, SHI Q. Labors migration and Chinese agricultural production. Economics (Quarterly), 2014, 13(3): 1147-1170.
42	潘泽瀚,王桂新. 中国农村劳动力转移与农村家庭收入——对山区和非山区的比较研究. 人口研究,2018,42(1):44-59.
	PAN Z, WANG G. Rural labor transfer and rural household income in China: A comparison between mountainous and non-mountainous areas. Population Research, 2018, 42(1): 44-59.
43	LI L, WANG C, SEGARRA E, et al. Migration, remittances and agricultural productivity in small farming systems in northwest China. China Agricultural Economic Review, 2013 (1) :15-23.
44	钟甫宁. 正确认识粮食安全和农业劳动力成本问题. 农业经济问题,2016,37(1):4-9.
	ZHONG F. Understanding issues regarding food security and rising labor costs. Issues of Agricultural Economics, 2016, 37(1): 4-9.
45	周曙东, 乔辉. 农产品价格对不同规模农户种植面积的影响——以大田商品作物花生为例. 南京农业大学学报(社会科学版), 2018,18(1):115-123.
	ZHOU S, QIAO H. Different impacts of agricultural product price on different planting scale farmer's planting acreage: Taking field commodity crop peanut as an example. Journal of Nanjing Agricultural University (Social Science Edition), 2018, 18(1): 115- 123.
46	易小兰, 颜琰. 劳动力价格对粮食生产的影响及区域差异.华南农业大学学报 (社科版), 2019, 18(6): 70-83.
	YI X, YAN Y. The impact of rural labor price fluctuation on grain production and its regional differences. Journal of South China Agricultural University (Social Science Edition), 2019, 18(6): 70-83.
47	杨进,钟甫宁,陈志钢,等. 农村劳动力价格、人口结构变化对粮食种植结构的影响. 管理世界,2016(1):78-87.
	YANG J, ZHONG F, CHEN Z, et al. Rural labor price, population structure and grain planting structure. Management World, 2016(1): 78-87.
48	徐志刚, 宁可, 朱哲毅,等. 市场化改革、要素流动与我国农村内部收入差距变化. 中国软科学, 2017(9):38-49.
	XU Z, NING K, ZHU Z, et al. Market-oriented reforms, factor mobility and rural income disparity. China Soft Science, 2017(9): 38-49.
49	包玉泽, 于颖, 周怡,等. 中国蔬菜产业的布局及其演化研究:1990—2014年.干旱区资源与环境,2018, 32(11):53-58.
	BAO Y, YU Y, ZHOU Y, et al. Layout and evolutionary of China's vegetable industry: From 1990 to 2014. Arid Land Resources and Environment, 2018, 32(11): 53-58.
50	王秀红. 中国蔬菜生产的农业物质投入及其潜在风险评价. Journal of Resources and Ecology,2016,7(4):269-274.
	WANG X. Agricultural material inputs and the potential risk assessment for vegetable production in China. Journal of Resources and Ecology,2016,7(4):269-274.
51	王彩峰, 史建民. 山东省苹果种植面积的时空演变特征分析. 中国农业资源与区划, 2017, 38(12):170-177.
	WANG C, SHI J. Study of spatio-temporal evolution characteristics of apple planting area in Shandong Province. China Agricultural Resources and Regional Planning, 2017, 38(12):170-177.
52	耿献辉, 卢华, 周应恒. 劳动力成本上升对我国水果产业的影响——以梨产业为例. 农林经济管理学报, 2014, 13(5): 461-466.
	GENG X, LU H, ZHOU Y. Impact of rising labor cost on China's fruit industry: A case study of pear industry. Journal of Agricultural and Forestry Economic Management, 2014, 13(5): 461-466.
53	周曙东,乔辉. 农产品价格对不同规模农户种植面积的影响——以大田商品作物花生为例. 南京农业大学学报(社会科学版),2018,18(1):115-123.
	ZHOU S, QIAO H. The impact of agricultural product prices on the planting area of farmers of different scales: Taking the field commercial crop peanut as an example. Journal of Nanjing Agricultural University (Social Science Edition), 2018,18(1):115-123.
54	王伟新,向云,祁春节. 中国水果产业地理集聚研究:时空特征与影响因素. 经济地理,2013(8):97-103.
	WANG W, XIANG Y, QI C. Research on the geographic agglomeration of China's fruit industry: Temporal and spatial features and influencing factors. Economic Geography, 2013(8):97-103.
55	王秋萍.山西水果产业发展的利弊因素分析.中国果业信息,2017,34(11):9-11.
	WANG Q.Analysis on the advantages and disadvantages of the development of Shanxi's fruit industry. China Fruit Industry Information,2017,34(11):9-11.
56	乔德华,魏胜文,王恒炜,等. 甘肃苹果产业发展优势及提质增效对策. 中国农业资源与区划,2016,37(8):168-174.
	QIAO D, WEI S, WANG H, et al. The apple industry development advantages in Gansu and quality efficiency countermeasures. China Agricultural Resources and Regional Planning,2016,37(8):168-174.
57	王秀红. 中国蔬菜生产的农业物质投入及其潜在风险评价. 资源与生态学报(英文版),2016,7(4):269-274.
	WANG X. Agricultural material input and potential risk assessment of vegetable production in China. Journal of Resources and Ecology (English Edition),2016,7(4):269-274.

变量类别	变量名称	变量定义	定义出处
被解释变量	水果种植面积比重	水果种植面积占全国比重/%	易小兰等^[46]
核心变量	农业劳动价格	农业劳动日工价/元	杨进等^[47]
	非农劳动价格	人均非农就业工资收入/元	徐志刚等^[48]
	工资收入占比	农村家庭工资性收入/农村家庭总收入/%	徐志刚等^[25]
控制变量	非农就业机会	（农村劳动力总数－农业从业人数）/农村劳动力总数/%	包玉泽等^[49]
	物质投入	农业生产资料价格指数（1985年=100）	王秀红^[50]
	水果价格	鲜果零售价格指数（1985年=100）	周曙东等^[45]
	生长期月平均累计降水	主产省主要园林水果生长期（1—8月）月平均累计降水/mm	—
	生长期月平均气温	主产省主要园林水果生长期（1—8月）月平均气温/℃	—
	种植习惯	上期水果种植面积比重/%	王彩峰等^[51]
	农林经济政策	农林特产税政策，2004年前取值为0，2004年后取值为1	耿献辉等^[52]
	交通运输条件	铁路和公路里程数总和/行政区域面积/%	白秀广等^[2]

变量类别	变量名称	变量定义	定义出处
被解释变量	水果种植面积比重	水果种植面积占全国比重/%	易小兰等^[46]
核心变量	农业劳动价格	农业劳动日工价/元	杨进等^[47]
	非农劳动价格	人均非农就业工资收入/元	徐志刚等^[48]
	工资收入占比	农村家庭工资性收入/农村家庭总收入/%	徐志刚等^[25]
控制变量	非农就业机会	（农村劳动力总数－农业从业人数）/农村劳动力总数/%	包玉泽等^[49]
	物质投入	农业生产资料价格指数（1985年=100）	王秀红^[50]
	水果价格	鲜果零售价格指数（1985年=100）	周曙东等^[45]
	生长期月平均累计降水	主产省主要园林水果生长期（1—8月）月平均累计降水/mm	—
	生长期月平均气温	主产省主要园林水果生长期（1—8月）月平均气温/℃	—
	种植习惯	上期水果种植面积比重/%	王彩峰等^[51]
	农林经济政策	农林特产税政策，2004年前取值为0，2004年后取值为1	耿献辉等^[52]
	交通运输条件	铁路和公路里程数总和/行政区域面积/%	白秀广等^[2]

年份	CR_5-A	CR_7-A	区域分布
1985	54.03	64.76	山东、河北、辽宁、广东、河南、四川、福建
1990	52.24	62.99	河北、山东、广东、辽宁、陕西、福建、四川
1995	49.78	61.59	河北、山东、广东、陕西、福建、广西、新疆
2000	50.02	61.20	河北、广东、广西、山东、陕西、福建、河南
2005	47.10	57.71	河北、广东、广西、陕西、山东、福建、四川
2010	46.04	56.68	陕西、广东、新疆、广西、河北、山东、四川
2015	44.05	54.75	陕西、广西、新疆、广东、四川、河北、山东
2018	43.57	53.78	广西、陕西、新疆、广东、四川、云南、贵州
2019	43.49	54.50	广西、陕西、广东、新疆、四川、云南、贵州

年份	CR_5-A	CR_7-A	区域分布
1985	54.03	64.76	山东、河北、辽宁、广东、河南、四川、福建
1990	52.24	62.99	河北、山东、广东、辽宁、陕西、福建、四川
1995	49.78	61.59	河北、山东、广东、陕西、福建、广西、新疆
2000	50.02	61.20	河北、广东、广西、山东、陕西、福建、河南
2005	47.10	57.71	河北、广东、广西、陕西、山东、福建、四川
2010	46.04	56.68	陕西、广东、新疆、广西、河北、山东、四川
2015	44.05	54.75	陕西、广西、新疆、广东、四川、河北、山东
2018	43.57	53.78	广西、陕西、新疆、广东、四川、云南、贵州
2019	43.49	54.50	广西、陕西、广东、新疆、四川、云南、贵州

地区	农业劳动价格								非农劳动价格
地区	1985	1990	1995	2000	2005	2010	2015	2019	1985	1990	1995	2000	2005	2010	2015	2019
辽宁	4.99	8.05	14.86	23.72	26.57	34.57	53.00	67.37	143	261	486	883	1 212	2 650	4 730	5 645
山东	3.62	5.16	9.74	18.60	23.21	30.02	61.47	81.07	81	168	409	851	1 438	2 958	5 140	6 550
山西	3.65	4.87	8.06	15.93	20.42	29.05	51.22	66.56	110	165	367	726	1 178	2 109	4 922	5 736
陕西	2.42	3.27	5.74	10.82	12.35	20.07	47.50	77.78	39	88	186	446	757	1 734	3 548	4 621
江苏	3.50	3.86	13.92	24.22	27.48	41.16	95.70	133.93	135	301	822	1 663	2 786	4 896	8 015	10 222
河北	3.37	4.71	8.26	17.96	19.99	28.05	52.73	64.33	89	171	441	949	1 294	2 653	5 812	7 454
河南	3.00	4.00	7.35	13.24	14.95	23.28	42.88	54.88	45	79	164	474	854	1 944	3 728	5 336
新疆	4.46	6.11	10.53	14.55	28.94	44.85	72.11	91.29	38	54	64	105	196	556	2 131	2 945
甘肃	2.41	3.16	6.13	11.45	13.09	19.13	38.68	52.90	40	81	92	355	587	1 199	1 975	2 535
安徽	3.24	4.16	7.38	12.81	14.76	20.95	40.44	53.46	36	77	234	548	1 010	2 204	3 983	5 058
贵州	2.15	2.80	2.20	3.69	10.41	15.76	39.56	50.71	27	47	146	275	583	1 304	2 897	4 276
福建	3.41	5.65	11.31	20.82	23.65	34.25	51.41	68.84	74	157	521	1 069	1 651	3 095	6 187	8 215
浙江	3.04	3.43	12.54	19.86	23.33	37.60	106.87	185.82	163	354	1 110	2 001	3 239	5 822	13 087	16 898
江西	3.51	4.93	9.85	17.07	19.16	29.65	54.22	76.34	53	87	320	744	1 228	2 395	4 393	6 121
湖北	3.89	4.90	10.57	19.78	15.19	29.30	49.73	94.32	50	82	192	548	942	2 186	3 683	4 887
湖南	3.30	4.35	8.39	14.56	16.61	23.11	57.84	91.23	54	85	268	790	1 229	2 656	4 515	5 769
广东	4.88	7.65	14.94	21.57	21.78	28.95	79.66	109.95	77	236	712	1 362	2 562	4 800	6 724	8 511
广西	1.88	2.57	3.95	14.31	13.71	20.08	54.03	77.88	27	60	202	484	907	1 707	2 549	3 691
四川	1.58	1.85	3.35	7.50	14.88	22.75	49.50	66.29	47	84	209	607	955	2 248	3 464	4 311
重庆	4.07	4.77	8.64	9.72	11.64	17.97	61.78	90.32	47	84	209	623	1 089	2 335	3 583	4 848
海南	1.93	7.63	14.26	21.93	20.57	29.62	53.80	65.91	77	61	54	151	473	1 262	4 251	5 611
云南	2.40	2.52	3.85	6.62	11.66	19.02	37.43	50.98	36	77	121	264	348	930	2 316	3 260