Cultural limitation analysis of participation in tourism development in scenic area dependent communities: The case study of the communities in Shibing Karst Heritage Site

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1004-9479.2023.06.2021200

Abstract

Abstract:

The current discussion on the limitation factors of community participation in tourism development is less in-depth analysis from the cultural perspective. Therefore, based on the analysis framework of cultural limitation, this study applies qualitative research method to study dependent communities in Shibing karst world natural heritage site. The conclusions are as follows: (1) Community participation in tourism depending the scenic area is not completely linear development. The tourism development of communities around the Shibing karst heritage site in recent 30 years has experienced three stages from the "free-ride" participation, the spontaneous organizational participation in the medium-term to the current development dilemma. (2)In the stage dilemma of dependent community participation in tourism, cultural restrictive factors are particularly prominent.The survey found that local tourism in Shibing karst can not support the employment and livelihood of residents at all.In particular, community participation in tourism is significantly affected by cultural restrictive factors that work together between local and community.(3)The development and change of tourism participation in heritage site are caused by several cultural limitations based on place, such as the consciousness of community participation, the ability of community participation, the leadership of community participation, the cohesion of community participation and collective action. Throughout an in-depth evaluation of the community participation in tourism development, this research provides a more effective analytical framework for the cultural limitations of community participation in tourism development, and provides some references for the development of rural tourism, the formulation of local government tourism policies and "rural revitalization".

Key words: community participation in tourism, cultural limitation, Shibing Karst, world heritage site, Guizhou

摘要：

当前对社区参与旅游发展的限制性因素的探讨较少从文化方面深入分析。本文在建立文化限制性因素分析框架的基础上，运用质性研究方法，对贵州省施秉喀斯特世界自然遗产地的依附型社区进行案例分析。研究发现：（1）景区依附型社区参与旅游并非呈线性发展，遗产地社区20余年来的旅游发展经历了“搭便车”参与、中期的自发组织性参与到目前发展陷入困境等阶段；（2）依附型社区参与旅游的阶段性发展困境中，文化限制性因素尤为突出；（3）遗产地社区参与旅游的发展变化是由地方的社区参与意识、社区参与能力、社区参与领导力、社区参与凝聚力以及社区参与集体行动力等若干文化限制性因素所致。研究对社区参与旅游发展状况的深入评估，为分析文化限制性提供了一个较为有效的框架，对乡村旅游发展、地方政府旅游政策的制定以及“乡村振兴”等具有参考意义。

关键词: 社区参与旅游, 文化限制性, 施秉喀斯特, 世界遗产地, 贵州省

Shian YE, Fangjuan DU, Kehua WU, Shurong ZHUANG, Yuxuan LIU. Cultural limitation analysis of participation in tourism development in scenic area dependent communities: The case study of the communities in Shibing Karst Heritage Site[J]. World Regional Studies, 2023, 32(6): 142-156.

叶仕安, 杜芳娟, 吴克华, 庄淑蓉, 刘宇炫. 景区依附型社区参与旅游发展的文化限制性分析[J]. 世界地理研究, 2023, 32(6): 142-156.

Figures/Tables 6

References 53

1	孙九霞, 保继刚. 从缺失到凸显: 社区参与旅游发展研究脉络. 旅游学刊, 2006, 21(7): 63-68.
	SUN J, BAO J. From absence to distinction: The research context of community participation in tourism development. Tourism Tribune, 2006, 21(7): 63-68.
2	苏明明, Geoffrey W. 遗产旅游与社区参与——以北京慕田峪长城为例. 旅游学刊, 2012, 27(7): 19-27.
	SU M, GEOFFREY W. Heritage tourism and community participation: A case study of Mutianyu Great Wall in Beijing. Tourism Tribune, 2012, 27(7): 19-27.
3	保继刚, 孙九霞. 雨崩村社区旅游: 社区参与方式及其增权意义. 旅游论坛, 2008, 1(1): 58-65.
	BAO J, SUN J. Community participation in tourism of Yubeng village: Means of participation and its significance for empowerment. Tourism Forum, 2008, 1(1): 58-65.
4	王新歌, 席建超, 陈田. 社区居民生计模式变迁与土地利用变化的耦合协调研究——以大连金石滩旅游度假区为例. 旅游学刊, 2017, 3203: 107-116.
	WANG X, XI J, CHEN T. Coupling coordination between livelihoods and land use change in local community: Case study of Jinshitan Resort, China. Tourism Tribune, 2017, 32(3): 107-116.
5	卢松, 周小凤, 张小军, 等. 旅游驱动下的传统村落城镇化研究——以世界文化遗产宏村为例. 热带地理, 2017, 37(3): 293-303.
	LU S, ZHOU X, ZHANG X, et al. Tourism-driven urbanization in ancient rural area: A case study of the Hongcun village. Tropical Geography, 2017, 37(3): 293-303.
6	BULTER R W. The concept of a tourist area cycle of evolution: Implications for management of resources[J]. Canadian Geographer, 1980, 24(1): 5-12.
7	王华, 龙慧, 郑艳芬. 断石村社区旅游:契约主导型社区参与及其增权意义. 人文地理, 2015, 30(5): 106-110.
	WANG H, LONG H, ZHENG Y. Community tourism of Duanshi village: The contract dominant community participation and its empowerment practice. Human Geography, 2015, 30(5): 106-110.
8	武晓英, 李辉. 民族社区参与旅游发展的阶段性探讨——以西双版纳民族旅游地为例. 云南地理环境研究, 2014, 26(3): 19-24.
	WU X, LI H. The stage investigation of national community participation in tourism development: As Xishuangbanna national tourist destination example. Yunnan Geographic Environment Research, 2014, 26(3): 19-24.
9	MACDONALD R, JOLLIFFE L. Cultural rural tourism[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 2003, 30(2): 307-322.
10	保继刚, 孙九霞. 社区参与旅游发展的中西差异. 地理学报, 2006,61(4): 401-413.
	BAO J, SUN J. A contrastive on the difference in community participation in tourism between China and the West. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2006,61(4): 401-413.
11	王华, 梁舒婷. 乡村旅游地空间生产与村民角色转型的过程与机制——以丹霞山瑶塘村为例. 人文地理, 2020, 35(3): 131-139.
	WANG H, LIANG S. The process and interaction mechanism between rural tourism space production and role change of villages: A case study of Yaotang village in MT. Danxia. Human Geography, 2020, 35(3): 131-139.
12	张敏敏, 傅新红. 民族旅游开发对乡村身份认同的影响研究——以川、滇交界处的泸沽湖景区为例. 西南民族大学学报(人文社科版), 2020, 41(1): 31-38.
	ZHANG M, FU X. Research on the influence of ethnic tourism development on rural identity: A case study of the Lugu Lake scenic spot at the junction of Sichuan and Yunnan. Journal of Southwest Minzu University (Humanities and Social Science), 2020, 41(1): 31-38.
13	乔淑英. 旅游开发背景下海南黎族社会文化变迁研究——以海南槟榔谷黎苗文化旅游景区、社区访谈透视. 青海民族研究, 2017, 28(4): 86-90.
	QIAO S. On social and culture change of Li people on Hainan island under the tourism development background: Perspective from interviewing communities and Binglanggu Li and Miao culture tourism scenic spot of Hainan. Qinghai Journal of Ethnology, 2017, 28(4): 86-90.
14	孟凯, 保继刚. 旅游发展引导下依附型乡村的城市化及其演化特征分析——以河南五家台村为例. 旅游论坛, 2019, 12(6): 32-40.
	MENG K, BAO J. Analysis of urbanization and evolution characteristics of dependent villages led by tourism development: A case study of Wujiatai village in Henan Province. Tourism Forum, 2019, 12(6): 32-40.
15	杨兴柱, 杨周, 朱跃. 世界遗产地乡村聚落功能转型与空间重构——以汤口、寨西和山岔为例. 地理研究, 2020, 39(10): 2214-2232.
	YANG X, YANG Z, ZHU Y. Rural settlements functional transformation and spatial restructuring in world heritage sites: Take Tangkou, Zhaixi and Shancha as examples. Geographical Research, 2020, 39(10): 2214-2232.
16	刘长运, 刘哲. 景区依附型旅游小企业"社区型"发展模式探讨——以重渡沟景区为例. 经济地理, 2013, 33(10): 188-192.
	LIU C, LIU Z. On the community-based development model of scenery adhered small tourism enterprises—Chongdugou scenery for instance. Economic Geography, 2013, 33(10): 188-192.
17	李瑛, 黄丹, 朱莹, 等. 景区带村扶贫模式下农户参与旅游的经济效率——以秦巴山区旅游扶贫重点村为例. 资源科学, 2020, 42(9): 1827-1836.
	LI Y, HUANG D, ZHU Y, et al. Economic efficiency of farmer participation in tourism-led village poverty alleviation: A case study of key poverty-stricken villages in the Qinling-Daba Mountains. Resources Science, 2020, 42(9): 1827-1836.
18	孔令英, 李媛彤. 能人带户旅游扶贫模式下农户增权效应研究——基于易县狼牙山地区的案例分析. 农业现代化研究, 2020, 41(2): 210-218.
	KONG L, LI Y. Study on the empowerment effect of rural households under the tourism poverty alleviation model of village elites leading households: A case study of Langya Mountain area in Yixian County. Research of Agricultural Modernization, 2020, 41(2): 210-218.
19	TIAN L, PU W, LIU L. Tourism islanding effect: A conceptual framework// LUO Y, JIANG J, BI D. Tourism Product Development in China, Asian and European Countries. Singapore: Springer, 2020: 235-251.
20	王咏, 陆林. 基于社会交换理论的社区旅游支持度模型及应用——以黄山风景区门户社区为例. 地理学报, 2014, 69 (10): 1557-1574.
	WANG Y, LU L. Community tourism support model and its application based on social exchange theory: Case studies of gateway communities of Huangshan scenic area. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2014, 69(10): 1557-1574.
21	JUROWSKI C, GURSOY D. Distance effects on residents' attitudes toward tourism. Annals of Tourism Research, 2004, 31(2): 296-312.
22	唐文跃, 龚晶晶, 童巧珍, 等. 国家公园建设背景下庐山社区管治模式研究——基于居民地方依恋的视角. 地域研究与开发, 2018, 37(6): 104-109.
	TANG W, GONG J, TONG Q, et al. Community governance model of mount Lu scenic area under the background of national park construction: Based on the perspective of residents' place attachment. Areal Research and Development, 2018, 37(6): 104-109.
23	王华, 郑艳芬. 遗产地农村社区参与旅游发展的制度嵌入性——丹霞山瑶塘村与断石村比较研究. 地理研究, 2016, 35(6): 1164-1176.
	WANG H, ZHEN Y. Tourism participation of rural communities at the heritage sites in the perspective of institutional embeddedness: A comparative study of Yaotang village and Duanshi village in the Danxia Mountain. Geographical Research, 2016, 35(6): 1164-1176.
24	CHADEROPA C. Legitimising transboundary conservation-development initiatives: A discourse analysis of policy-decision making and its implications for rural community participation. International Journal of Tourism Policy, 2013, 5(1/2): 128.
25	AKHMAD S, DANNY O, HUGH W. Inhibitors to host community participation in sustainable tourism development in developing countries. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 2014, 22(5): 801-820.
26	左冰. 西双版纳傣族园社区参与旅游发展的行动逻辑——兼论中国农村社区参与状况. 思想战线, 2012, 38(1): 100-104.
	ZUO B. The action logic of Xishuangbanna Dai nationality community participating in tourism development: Research on the participation of rural communities in China. Thinking, 2012, 38(1): 100-104.
27	翁时秀, 彭华. 权力关系对社区参与旅游发展的影响——以浙江省楠溪江芙蓉村为例. 旅游学刊, 2010, 25(9): 51-57.
	WENG S, PENG H. The impact of power relationship on community participation in tourism development——A case from Furong village at Nanxi River Basin, Zhejiang Province. Tourism Tribune, 2010, 25(9): 51-57.
28	IBRAHIM Y. Barries to community participation in tourism development in island destination. Journal of Tourism, Hospitality & Culinary Arts, 2013, 5(1): 102-124.
29	吕君. 欠发达地区社区参与旅游发展的影响因素及系统分析. 世界地理研究, 2012, 21(2): 118-128.
	LV J. Analysis on influential factors and system of community participation of tourism development in less developed areas. World Regional Studies, 2012, 21(2): 118-128.
30	王江, 罗仕伟. 社区参与旅游的限制性因素研究——以云南澄江禄充社区为例. 重庆师范大学学报(自然科学版), 2012, 29(4): 107-111.
	WANG J, LUO S. Limiting factors' study on community participation in tourism: A case study of Luchong in Chengjiang County, Yunnan Provice. Journal of Chongqing Normal University(Natural Science), 2012, 29(4): 107-111.
31	刘俊, 楼枫烨. 旅游开发背景下世居少数民族社区边缘化——海南三亚六盘黎族安置区案例. 旅游学刊, 2010, 25(9): 44-50.
	LIU J, LOU F. On the marginalization of ethnic minority community under the backdrop of tourism development: A case study of Liupan Li Nationality. Tourism Tribune, 2010, 25(9): 44-50.
32	VELNISA PAIMIN N F, MODILIH S, MOGINDOL S H, et al. Community participation and barriers in rural tourism: A case study in Kiulu, Sabah. SHS Web of Conferences, 2014, 12: 1-7.
33	TOSUN C. Expected nature of community participation in tourism development. Tourism Management, 2006, 27(3): 493-504.
34	HORN C, SIMMONS D. Community adaptation to tourism: Comparisons between Rotorua and Kaikoura, New Zealand. Tourism Management, 2002, 23(2): 133-143.
35	TOSUN C. Stages in the emergence of a participatory tourism development approach in the developing world. Geoforum, 2005, 36(3): 33-352.
36	TOSUN C. Limits to community participation in the tourism development process in developing countries. Tourism Management, 2000, 21(6): 613-633.
37	HERRERO-PRIETO L C, GOMEZ-VEGA M. Cultural resources as a factor in cultural tourism attraction. Tourism Economics, 2017, 23(2): 260-280.
38	陈飙, 钟洁, 杨桂华. 云南香格里拉藏族社区参与旅游发展过程的限制性因素研究. 西南民族大学学报(人文社科版), 2007,192(8): 165-169.
	CHEN B, ZHONG J, YANG G. Study on the restrictive factors of the Tibetan community's participation in tourism development in Shangri-La, Yunnan. Journal of Southwest University for Nationalities(Humanities and Social Science), 2007,192(8): 165-169.
39	KIM S, PARK E, PHANDANOUVONG T. Barriers to local residents' participation in community-based tourism: Lessons from Houay Kaeng village in Laos. SHS Web of Conferences, 2014, 12(01045): 1-8.
40	KALA D, BAGI S C. Barriers to local community participation in tourism development: Evidence from mountainous state Uttarakhand, India. Tourism, 2018, 66(3): 318-333.
41	HARALAMBOS M, HOLBORN M. Sociology: Themes and Perspectives. London: Collins, 1991: 2-3.
42	DUNCAN J S. The superorganic in American cultural geography. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 2015, 70(2): 181-198.
43	MITCHELL D. There is no such thing as culture: Towards a re-conceptualization of the idea of culture in geography. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers (New Series), 1995, 20(1): 102-116.
44	HUGGINS R, THOMPSON P. Culture and place-based development: A socio-economic analysis. Regional Studies, 2015, 49(1): 130-159.
45	周尚意. 区域三大本性与主体性. 地理教育, 2015(6): 1.
	ZHOU S. The three major natures and subjectivity of the region. Education of Geography, 2015(6): 1.
46	ROMAO J, GUERREIRO J, RODRIGUES P. Regional tourism development: Culture, nature, life cycle and attractiveness. Current Issues in Tourism, 2013, 16(6): 517-534.
47	STORPER M. Community and Economics. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008.
48	WILSON S, FESENMAIER D R, FESENMAIER J, et al. Factors for success in rural tourism development. Journal of Travel Research, 2001, 40(2): 132-138.
49	中国科学院"科技领导力研究"课题组, 苗建明, 霍国庆. 领导力五力模型研究. 领导科学, 2006(9): 20-23.
	Research Group of Science and Technology Leadership Research of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, MIAO J, HUO G. Research on leadership five forces models.Leadership Science, 2006(9): 20-23.
50	王浦劬, 臧雷振. 治理理论与实践: 经典议题研究新解. 北京: 中央编译出版社, 2017.
	WANG P, ZANG L. Governance in Theory and Practice: New Perspectives on A Classical Topic. Beijing: Central Compilation & Translation Press, 2017.
51	陈标, 艾凌. 社区居民集体行动: 困境与激励. 开放导报, 2017,195(6): 17-19.
	CHEN B, AI L. Collective action of community residents: Dilemma and incentives. China Opening Journal, 2017,195(6): 17-19.
52	戴维·波普诺. 社会学. 北京: 中国人民大学出版社, 1987.
	POPENOE D. Sociology. Beijing: China Renmin University Press, 1987.
53	朱贻庭, 崔宜明. 伦理学大辞典. 上海: 上海辞书出版社, 2002.
	ZHU Y, CUI Y. Dictionary of Ethics. Shanghai: Shanghai Dictionary Press, 2002.

作者	因素1	因素2	因素3	因素4	因素5
Tosun^[36] （2000）	操作性限制因素：旅游公共管理的中央集权；缺乏协作；缺乏信息。	结构性限制因素：旅游从业者的态度；缺乏专家；缺乏法制基础；缺乏训练有素的旅游人力资源；缺乏资金渠道	文化限制因素：贫困人口能力限制；社区参与无意识
陈飙^[38] （2007）	产业均衡	矛盾转移	供求平衡等
Kim S^[39] (2014)	教育程度低，缺乏旅游知识	简陋的居住条件，缺乏资金支持	日常忙碌，没有时间参与旅游	社区对旅游季节性、低收入的行业认知	权力悬殊、制度阻碍与对官方的不信任
Paimin V^[32]（2014）	知识有限	缺乏资金	语言沟通不畅	缺乏信息	有限的政府支持
Kala^[40] （2018）	实践性因素：知识欠缺；教育程度低	社会-文化因素：简陋的居住条件；忙碌的生计；妇女角色被动	顾虑性因素（Apprehension）：旅游季节性认知、缺乏专家、消极影响认知	制度性因素：权力悬殊

作者	因素1	因素2	因素3	因素4	因素5
Tosun^[36] （2000）	操作性限制因素：旅游公共管理的中央集权；缺乏协作；缺乏信息。	结构性限制因素：旅游从业者的态度；缺乏专家；缺乏法制基础；缺乏训练有素的旅游人力资源；缺乏资金渠道	文化限制因素：贫困人口能力限制；社区参与无意识
陈飙^[38] （2007）	产业均衡	矛盾转移	供求平衡等
Kim S^[39] (2014)	教育程度低，缺乏旅游知识	简陋的居住条件，缺乏资金支持	日常忙碌，没有时间参与旅游	社区对旅游季节性、低收入的行业认知	权力悬殊、制度阻碍与对官方的不信任
Paimin V^[32]（2014）	知识有限	缺乏资金	语言沟通不畅	缺乏信息	有限的政府支持
Kala^[40] （2018）	实践性因素：知识欠缺；教育程度低	社会-文化因素：简陋的居住条件；忙碌的生计；妇女角色被动	顾虑性因素（Apprehension）：旅游季节性认知、缺乏专家、消极影响认知	制度性因素：权力悬殊

受访者	性别	年龄	身份
YDH	女	30	木牌农家乐老板娘
NYH	男	44	聂家堰组长，景区拍照、县城做零工
YDJ	男	50	聂家堰村民，在县城做零工
YAM	女	70	聂家堰村民，在景区摆摊
WTB	男	60	聂家堰老组长
YP	男	35	白塘村村委会文书
MZY	男	34	牌楼冲村民，欣怡农家乐老板
WGJ	女	42	杨成农家乐老板娘
MRK	男	38	牌楼冲村民，迎仙桥农家乐老板
PXM	男	60	牌楼冲老组长，如今在外承包项目
RGZ	女	53	宝石苑农家乐老板娘
MZL	男	48	牌楼冲村民，在外务工
LSA	男	40	牌楼冲村民，印斗阁农家乐老板
ZY	女	31	黑冲农家乐老板娘
LHJ	男	57	黑冲组长，务农和零工
XG	男	36	杉木河公司员工，负责杉木河景区安保
WY	男	48	世遗局副局长
WH	男	51	麻卡公司工作人员

受访者	性别	年龄	身份
YDH	女	30	木牌农家乐老板娘
NYH	男	44	聂家堰组长，景区拍照、县城做零工
YDJ	男	50	聂家堰村民，在县城做零工
YAM	女	70	聂家堰村民，在景区摆摊
WTB	男	60	聂家堰老组长
YP	男	35	白塘村村委会文书
MZY	男	34	牌楼冲村民，欣怡农家乐老板
WGJ	女	42	杨成农家乐老板娘
MRK	男	38	牌楼冲村民，迎仙桥农家乐老板
PXM	男	60	牌楼冲老组长，如今在外承包项目
RGZ	女	53	宝石苑农家乐老板娘
MZL	男	48	牌楼冲村民，在外务工
LSA	男	40	牌楼冲村民，印斗阁农家乐老板
ZY	女	31	黑冲农家乐老板娘
LHJ	男	57	黑冲组长，务农和零工
XG	男	36	杉木河公司员工，负责杉木河景区安保
WY	男	48	世遗局副局长
WH	男	51	麻卡公司工作人员

[1]	Nian FAN, Rongpei HAN, Kun LIANG. Study on the spatial characteristics and influencing factors of rural tourism villages in Guizhou Province [J]. World Regional Studies, 2021, 30(6): 1308-1319.
[2]	Ya LUO, Jianhong YANG, Qiuwen ZHOU, Xu ZHOU, Jiusheng ZHONG, Xinyue HU, Qiyun GAO. Characteristic of positive and negative terrains and its effect on population distribution in the mountainous area, Guizhou Plateau [J]. World Regional Studies, 2021, 30(1): 204-212.
[3]	Dongya CHENG, Xudong LI. Research on the coupling coordination relationship between population, economy and agro-ecological environment in Wumen Mountain, Guizhou Province [J]. World Regional Studies, 2021, 30(1): 125-135.
[4]	. Analysis on Influential Factors of Poverty in Contiguous Destitute Areas of Guizhou Province with Grey Correlation [J]. WRS, 2017, 26(1): 158-167.