World Regional Studies ›› 2024, Vol. 33 ›› Issue (5): 111-122.DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1004-9479.2024.05.20222290
Chen YOU1,2,3(), Chaochao LIAO4()
Received:
2022-10-10
Revised:
2023-02-02
Online:
2024-05-15
Published:
2024-05-30
Contact:
Chaochao LIAO
通讯作者:
廖超超
作者简介:
游晨(1995—),男,讲师,研究方向为行政改革与地方治理,E-mail:youchen@zju.edu.cn。
基金资助:
Chen YOU, Chaochao LIAO. A review of foreign administrative division reform practices and research[J]. World Regional Studies, 2024, 33(5): 111-122.
游晨, 廖超超. 行政区划改革的国际实践与研究评述[J]. 世界地理研究, 2024, 33(5): 111-122.
中文 | 英文 |
---|---|
区划改革 | Territorial Reforms; Border Reforms; Redistricting; Gerrymandering; Realignment; Boundary Changes; Reorganization |
合并 | Amalgamations; Merger; Annexation; Consolidation; Incorporation |
拆分 | Split; Proliferation; Fragmentation; De-Amalgamation; De-Merger; Secession; Territorial Partition; Municipal Divorce |
Tab.1 The main keywords used for the search
中文 | 英文 |
---|---|
区划改革 | Territorial Reforms; Border Reforms; Redistricting; Gerrymandering; Realignment; Boundary Changes; Reorganization |
合并 | Amalgamations; Merger; Annexation; Consolidation; Incorporation |
拆分 | Split; Proliferation; Fragmentation; De-Amalgamation; De-Merger; Secession; Territorial Partition; Municipal Divorce |
1 | 朱建华,陈田,王开泳,等.改革开放以来中国行政区划格局演变与驱动力分析.地理研究,2015,34(2):247-258. |
ZHU J, CHEN T, WANG K, et al. Spatial pattern evolution and driving force analysis of administrative division in China since the reform and opening-up. Geographical Research, 2015, 34(2):247-258. | |
2 | 杨宇泽,叶林.发达国家城市合并的理论研究述评.公共管理与政策评论,2020,9(3):86-96. |
YANG Y, YE L. A literature review of theory and research on municipal amalgamation in developed countries public. Administration and Policy Review 9(3):86-96. | |
3 | 聂玉霞,宋明爽.国内外关于"村庄合并"研究述评.山东农业大学学报(社会科学版),2015,17(1):73-78. |
NIE Y, SONG M. A review of domestic and foreign research on "village integration. Journal of Shandong Agricultural University(Social Science Edition),2015,17(1):73-78. | |
4 | 邓大才."合并浪潮":农村基本建制单元重组与民主争议——以发达国家农村基层建制单元为考察对象.山东社会科学,2019(1):61-68. |
DENG D. The tide of merging: Unit restructure and democratic debate of basic rural organizations--With the object of the basic rural units of developed countries. Shandong Social Sciences,2019(1):61-68. | |
5 | 王开泳,陈田.国外行政区划调整的经验及对我国的启示.世界地理研究,2011,20(2):57-64. |
WANG K, CHEN T. The experience reference of administrative division adjustment in abroad and the apocalypses for China. World Regional Studies,2011,20(2):57-64. | |
6 | 侯爱敏.美国市县合并的五个突出特征及其对我国区划调整的启示.国际城市规划,2018,33(6):43-48. |
HOU A. Five distinctive features of American city-county consolidation and lessons for China's administrative division adjustment in metropolitan areas. Urban Planning International,2018,33(6):43-48. | |
7 | LIESBET H, GARY M. Unraveling the central state, but how? Types of multi-level governance. American Political Science Review,2003,97(2):233-243. |
8 | SHOBE W. Emerging issues in decentralized resource governance: Environmental federalism, spillovers, and linked socio-ecological systems. Annual Review of Resource Economics,2020,12(1):259-279. |
9 | HASSAN M, SHEELY R. Executive-legislative relations, party defections, and lower level administrative unit proliferation: Evidence from Kenya. Comparative Political Studies,2017,50(12):1595-1631. |
10 | GRIFFITHS R. Between dissolution and blood: How administrative lines and categories shape secessionist outcomes. International Organization,2015,69(3):731-751. |
11 | KRAXBERGER B. The geography of regime survival: Abacha's Nigeria. African Affairs,2004,103(412):413-430. |
12 | JACOBS A. Federations of municipalities: A practical alternative to local government consolidations in Japan? Governance,2004,17(2):247-274. |
13 | N-K HLEPAS. Incomplete Greek territorial consolidation: From the first (1998) to the second (2008-09) wave of reforms. Local Government Studies,2010,36(2):223-249. |
14 | BLESSE S, BASKARAN T. Do municipal mergers reduce costs? Evidence from a German federal state. Regional Science and Urban Economics,2016,59:54-74. |
15 | STREBEL M. Why voluntary municipal merger projects fail: Evidence from popular votes in Switzerland. Local Government Studies,2019,45(5):654-675. |
16 | WEESE E. Political mergers as coalition formation: An analysis of the Heisei municipal amalgamations. Quantitative Economics,2015,6(2):257-307. |
17 | SWIANIEWICZ P. From post-communist democratic laissez-faire to prevention of territorial fragmentation: Tightening the rules of municipal splits in Central and Eastern Europe after 1990. Miscellanea Geographica,2021,25(1):5-17. |
18 | KRECI V, YMERI B. The impact of territorial re-organizational policy interventions in the republic of Macedonia. Local Government Studies,2010,36(2):271-290. |
19 | SMITH R M, WALDNER L. Why majority-minority cities form: Non-White municipal incorporation in the United States,1990-2010. Urban Geography,2018,39(1):149-166. |
20 | Patronage GREEN E., creation district, and reform in Uganda. Studies in Comparative International Development,2010,45(1):83-103. |
21 | SWIANIEWICZ P, MIELCZAREK A. Georgian local government reform: State Leviathan redraws boundaries? Local Government Studies,2010,36(2):291-311. |
22 | ANDERSEN H. The emerging Danish government reform--Centralised decentralisation. Urban Research & Practice,2008,1(1):3-17. |
23 | LEWIS J. When decentralization leads to recentralization: Subnational state transformation in Uganda. Regional & Federal Studies,2014,24(5):571-588. |
24 | LELAND S, THURMAIER K. When efficiency is unbelievable: Normative lessons from 30 years of city-county consolidations. Public Administration Review,2005,65(4):475-489. |
25 | GIMÉNEZ V, PRIOR D. Long- and short-term cost efficiency frontier evaluation: Evidence from Spanish local governments. Fiscal Studies,2007,28(1):121-139. |
26 | DE CEUNINCK K, REYNAERT H, STEYVERS K, et al. Municipal amalgamations in the low countries: Same problems, different solutions. Local Government Studies,2010,36(6):803-822. |
27 | MIYAZAKI T. Municipal consolidation and local government behavior: Evidence from Japanese voting data on merger referenda. Economics of Governance,2014,15(4):387-410. |
28 | DIGDOWISEISO K, MURSHED S, BERGH S. What drives regional proliferation in Indonesia? Assessing the role of institutions. Lex localis- Journal of Local Self-Government,2022,20(1):27-54. |
29 | SWIANIEWICZ P. If territorial fragmentation is a problem, is amalgamation a solution?--Ten years later. Local Government Studies,2018,44(1):1-10. |
30 | KLAFF V, FUGUITT G. Annexation as a factor in the growth of U.S. cities,1950-1960 and 1960-1970. Demography,1978,15(1):1-12. |
31 | DURST N, CAI M, TILLISON-LOVE J, et al. The gerrymandering of cities and the politics of racial exclusion: Evidence from a spatial typology of municipal boundary changes. Journal of Urban Affairs,2021,45(9):1586-1607. |
32 | FITRANI F, HOFMAN B, KAISER K. Unity in diversity? The creation of new local governments in a decentralising Indonesia. Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies,2005,41(1):57-79. |
33 | MAVUNGU E. Frontiers of power and prosperity: Explaining provincial boundary disputes in postapartheid South Africa. African Studies Review,2016,59(2):183-208. |
34 | LAPOINTE S. "Love thy neighbour"? The effect of income and language differences on votes for municipal secessions. Regional Science and Urban Economics,2018,70:229-245. |
35 | KAISER C. Functioning and impact of incentives for amalgamations in a federal State: The Swiss case. International Journal of Public Administration,2014,37(10):625-637. |
36 | PIERSKALLA J.Splitting the difference? The politics of district creation in Indonesia. Comparative Politics,2016,48(2):249-268. |
37 | BRINK A. The break-up of municipalities: Voting behavior in local referenda. Economics of Governance,2004,5(2):119-135. |
38 | VRANGBÆK K. Structural reform in Denmark,2007-09: Central reform processes in a decentralised environment. Local Government Studies,2010,36(2):205-221. |
39 | BRUSIS M. Party Strategies and administrative-territorial reforms in Poland. West European Politics,2013,36(2):405-425. |
40 | VABO S, FIMREITE A, HOULBERG K. Why such a different choice of tools? Analysing recent local government reforms in Denmark and Norway. Local Government Studies,2023, 49(2):355-374. |
41 | MAHPUDIN M, INDRIYANY I, HIKMAWAN M. Between elites and society: The politics of territorial splits in a decentralizing era, case of Lebak district, Indonesia. Journal of Governance,2021,6(1):155-176. |
42 | KUHLMANN S, BOUCKAERT G. Local Public Sector Reforms in Times of Crisis: National Trajectories and International Comparisons. London: Palgrave Macmillan,2016. |
43 | CARR J, S-S BAE, LU W. City-county government and promises of economic development: A tale of two cities. State and Local Government Review,2006,38(3):131-141. |
44 | REDDING S, STURM D. The Costs of remoteness: Evidence from German division and reunification. American Economic Review,2008,98(5):1766-1797. |
45 | SWIANIEWICZ P, ŁUKOMSKA J. Is small beautiful? The quasi-experimental analysis of the impact of territorial fragmentation on costs in Polish local governments. Urban Affairs Review,2019,55(3):832-855. |
46 | HANSEN S, HOULBERG K, PEDERSEN L. Do municipal mergers improve fiscal outcomes? Scandinavian Political Studies,2014,37(2):196-214. |
47 | BLOM-HANSEN J, HOULBERG K, SERRITZLEW S.Size, democracy, and the economic costs of running the political system. American Journal of Political Science,2014,58(4):790-803. |
48 | HARJUNEN O, SAARIMAA T, TUKIAINEN J. Political representation and effects of municipal mergers. Political Science Research and Methods,2021,9(1):72-88. |
49 | REINGEWERTZ Y. Do municipal amalgamations work? Evidence from municipalities in Israel. Journal of Urban Economics,2012,72(2-3):240-251. |
50 | HIROTA H, YUNOUE H. Evaluation of the fiscal effect on municipal mergers: Quasi-experimental evidence from Japanese municipal data. Regional Science and Urban Economics,2017,66:132-149. |
51 | RODRIGUES M, MEZA O. "Is there anybody out there?" Political implications of a territorial integration. Journal of Urban Affairs,2018,40(3):426-440. |
52 | ALLERS M, DE NATRIS J, RIENKS H, et al. Is small beautiful? Transitional and structural effects of municipal amalgamation on voter turnout in local and national elections. Electoral Studies,2021,70:102284. |
53 | SAARIMAA T, TUKIAINEN J. Local representation and strategic voting: Evidence from electoral boundary reforms. European Journal of Political Economy,2016,41:31-45. |
54 | GENDŹWIŁŁ A, KJAER U. Mind the gap, please! Pinpointing the influence of municipal size on local electoral participation. Local Government Studies,2021,47(1):11-30. |
55 | SAVITCH H, VOGEL R. Suburbs without a city: Power and city-county consolidation. Urban Affairs Review,2004,39(6):758-790. |
56 | ACUFF C. An empirical examination of representational equity in consolidated governments,1965-2002. Urban Affairs Review,2022,58(6):1523-1553. |
57 | YAMADA K, ARAI K. Do boundary consolidations alter the relationship between politicians and voters? The case of municipal mergers in Japan. Local Government Studies,2021,47(4):519-545. |
58 | JAKOBSEN M, KJAER U. Political representation and geographical bias in amalgamated local governments. Local Government Studies,2016,42(2):208-227. |
59 | KJAER U, HJELMAR U, LETH OLSEN A. Municipal amalgamations and the democratic functioning of local councils: The case of The Danish 2007 Structural Reform. Local Government Studies,2010,36(4):569-585. |
60 | SHIMIZU K. Electoral consequences of municipal mergers. Journal of East Asian Studies,2012,12(3):381-408. |
61 | SUZUKI K, HA H. Municipal merger and local democracy: An assessment of the merger of Japanese municipalities. Lex localis - Journal of Local Self-Government,2018,16(4):759-784. |
62 | FURUKAWA A. Efficient municipal consolidation and local public spending: A theoretical approach. Applied Economics Letters,2022,29(8): 746-749. |
63 | MCQUESTIN D, DREW J, DOLLERY B. Do municipal mergers improve technical efficiency? An empirical analysis of the 2008 Queensland municipal merger program. Australian Journal of Public Administration,2018,77(3):442-455. |
64 | GROSSMAN G, PIERSKALLA J, BOSWELL DEAN E. Government fragmentation and public goods provision. The Journal of Politics,2017,79(3):823-840. |
65 | LEWIS B. Does local government proliferation improve public service delivery? Evidence from Indonesia. Journal of Urban Affairs,2017,39(8):1047-1065. |
66 | PICKERING S, TANAKA S, YAMADA K. The impact of municipal mergers on local public spending: Evidence from remote-sensing data. Journal of East Asian Studies,2020,20(2):243-266. |
67 | BOURDIN S, TORRE A. The territorial big bang: Which assessment about the territorial reform in France? European Planning Studies,2021,29(11):1981-1998. |
68 | KONOPSKI M. The role of administrative borders in determining regional identity: The case of Podlasie, Poland. Moravian Geographical Reports,2021,29(1):53-70. |
69 | ZIMMERBAUER K, PAASI A. When old and new regionalism collide: Deinstitutionalization of regions and resistance identity in municipality amalgamations. Journal of Rural Studies,2013,30:31-40. |
70 | BURGESS R, HANSEN M, OLKEN B A, et al. The political economy of deforestation in the tropics. The Quarterly Journal of Economics,2012,127(4):1707-1754. |
71 | ALESINA A, GENNAIOLI C, LOVO S. Public goods and ethnic diversity: Evidence from deforestation in Indonesia. Economica,2019,86(341):32-66. |
72 | LIPSCOMB M, MOBARAK A. Decentralization and pollution spillovers: Evidence from the re-drawing of county borders in Brazil. The Review of Economic Studies,2017,84(1):464-502. |
[1] | Jiahong GUO, Canfei HE, Qi GUO. A demand-side perspective of evolutionary economic geography [J]. World Regional Studies, 2024, 33(1): 83-95. |
[2] | Yujie CHEN, Yuan YUAN, Ye LIU. Research on the effect of urban blue space on the residents' health: [J]. World Regional Studies, 2023, 32(12): 142-154. |
[3] | Zihao YU, Debin DU, Chengliang LIU, Qifan XIA, Chaofeng QIAN. A literature review on water conflict [J]. World Regional Studies, 2020, 29(5): 893-904. |
[4] | Zhanren ZHANG, Xiaoxue YANG, Zhengyun ZHAN. A review of the dynamic research on the division of labor in global R & D network [J]. World Regional Studies, 2019, 28(6): 59-67. |
[5] | Yuwen HAN, Chengcai TANG, Chunyu YANG, Ning LV. An analysis of knowledge map on traditional village tourism research in Mainland China based on CiteSpace [J]. World Regional Studies, 2019, 28(5): 200-209. |
[6] | . Review of Domestic Research on the Social-Cultural Impact of Tourism Since the year of 2000 [J]. WRS, 2016, (5): 142-152. |
Viewed | ||||||
Full text |
|
|||||
Abstract |
|
|||||