Study on cultural customers' leisure involvement and place attachment of independent bookstores: A case study of Guangzhou 1200bookshop

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1004-9479.2021.02.2019527

Abstract

Abstract:

Taking Guangzhou 1200 Bookshop as an example,This paper adopts Enduring Involvement scale and Place Attachment scale to explore the relationship between leisure involvement and place attachment of cultural consumers in independent bookstores by using structural equation model and text analysis.The research shows that :(1) only the centrality dimension of leisure involvement has a significant positive relationship with each dimension of place attachment, and has a greater impact on place dependence than on place identity; (2) the attractiveness dimension of leisure involvement has a significant positive impact on place dependence, while the dimension of self-expression has a significant positive impact on place identity; (3) local dependence has a significant positive impact on place identity; (4) the place attachment characteristics of cultural consumers to 1200bookshop were mainly functional dependence and spiritual identity.This study verified and modified the model of "leisure involvement - place attachment", which was transferred to urban daily leisure activity space,expanded the scope of the model, and provided practical support for the operation and development model of independent bookstores.

Key words: leisure involvement, place attachment, independent bookstores, 1200bookshop

摘要：

以广州1200bookshop为例，采用涉入量表和地方依恋量表，运用结构方程模型和文本分析探讨独立书店文化消费者的休闲涉入和地方依恋的关系。研究表明：（1）休闲涉入只有中心性对地方依恋的每个维度均有显著的正向关系，且对地方依赖的影响大于地方认同；（2）吸引力对地方依赖有显著正向影响，而自我表现对地方认同有显著的正向影响；（3）地方依赖对地方认同有显著的正向影响；（4）文化消费者对1200bookshop的地方依恋特征主要是功能性依赖和精神性认同。研究将“休闲涉入-地方依恋”模型迁移到城市日常休闲活动空间，验证并修正了该模型，拓展了该模型的适用范围，同时也为独立书店的经营和发展模式提供实践支持。

关键词: 独立书店, 休闲涉入, 地方依恋, 地方依赖

Wanru CHEN, Shuang LI, Yanci WU. Study on cultural customers' leisure involvement and place attachment of independent bookstores: A case study of Guangzhou 1200bookshop[J]. World Regional Studies, 2021, 30(2): 422-432.

陈婉茹, 李爽, 伍艳慈. 独立书店消费者的休闲涉入和地方依恋研究[J]. 世界地理研究, 2021, 30(2): 422-432.

Figures/Tables 8

References 28

1	向勇.独立书店的价值定位与营造策略.人民论坛,2019(23):126-128.
	Xiao Y. Value orientation and construction strategy of independent bookstores. People's Tribune,2019(23):126-128.
2	邵娟.场景理论视域下实体书店的公共阅读空间建构.科技与出版,2019(08):31-35.
	Shao J. The construction of public reading space in physical bookstores from the perspective of scene theory. Science-Technology & Publication, 2019(08):31-35.
3	Nguyen T.V.T., Han Y.H., Sahito N., et al. The bookstore-café: emergence of a new lifestyle as a "third place" in Hangzhou, China. Space and Culture, 2019,33(2),216-233.
4	KS. Bricker, Kerstetter DL. Level of specialization and place attachment: An exploratory study of whitewater recreationists. Leisure sciences, 2000,22(4):233-257.
5	Stedman R. Is it really just a social construction?The contribution of the physical environment to sense of place. Society and Natural Resources,2003,16(8):671-685.
6	王坤,黄震方,方叶林,等.文化旅游区游客涉入对地方依恋的影响测评.人文地理,2013,28(03):135-141.
	Wang K, Huang Z, Fang Y, et al. Impacts of tourists' involvement on place attachment in cultural tourist attractions. Human Geography,013,28(03):135-141.
7	Sherif M,Cantril H.The psychology of ego-involvements: Social attitudes and identifications. NY: John Wiley Sons Inc,1947:280-347.
8	Selin S, Howard D. Ego involvement and leisure behavior: A conceptual specification. Journal of Leisure Research,1988,20(3):237-244.
9	余勇,田金霞.骑乘者休闲涉入、休闲效益与幸福感结构关系研究——以肇庆星湖自行车绿道为例.旅游学刊,2013,28(02):67-76.
	Yu Y, Tian J. A research on structural relationship among leisure involvement, leisure benefits and sense of happiness for bicycle riders: A case study of bikeway green corridor circling Star Lake in Zhaoqing. Tourism Tribune,2013,28(02):67-76.
10	陆敏,顾雪芝,姜辽.居民城市公园游憩涉入与地方依恋——以江苏省常州市红梅公园为例. 地域研究与开发,2014,33(02):122-129.
	Lu M, Gu X, Jiang L. Residents' recreation involvement and place attachment of urban park: A case study of Changzhou Hongmei Park. Areal Research and Development, 2014,33(02): 122-129.
11	Zaichkowsky J. L. The personal involvement inventory: Reduction, revision, and application to advertising. Journal of Advertising, 1994, 23(4): 60-70.
12	Laurent G., Kapferer J. Measuring consumer involvement profiles. Journal of Marketing Research, 1985,22(2):41-53.
13	McIntyre N. The personal meaning of participation: Enduring involvement. Journal of Leisure Research, 1989,21(2): 167-179.
14	邹统钎.旅游目的地管理. 北京:高等教育出版社,2011.
	Zou T. Tourism destination management. Beijing: Higher Education Press, 2011.
15	Scanell L, Gifford R. Defining place attachment: A tripartite organizing framework. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 2010, 30(1): 1-10.
16	Kyle G, Grafe A, Manning R. Predictors of behavioral loyalty among hikers along the Appalachian Trail. Leisure Sciences, 2004, 26(1):99-118.
17	Kyle G. T., Mowen A. J. Tarrant M. Linking place preferences with place meaning: An examination of the relationship between place motivation and place attachment. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 2004,24(4):439-454.
18	Lee T H, Shen Y L. The influence of leisure involvement and place attachment on destination loyalty: Evidence from recreationists walking their dogs in urban parks. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 2013, 33: 76-85.
19	Gross M J, Brown G. An empirical structural model of tourists and places: progressing involvement and place attachment into tourism. Tourism Management, 2008,29(6) : 1141-1151.
20	Prayag G, Ryan C. Antecedents of tourist's loyalty to Mauritius: The role and influence of destination image, place attachment, personal involvement, and satisfaction. Journal of Travel Research, 2012,51(3) : 342-356.
21	陆相林,孙中伟.旅游涉入、满意度、地方依恋作用机制研究——以西柏坡红色游客为例. 干旱区资源与环境,2017,31(07):183-188.
	Lu X, Sun Z. Mechanism of Red Tourist's involvement, satisfaction and local attachment: A case study of Xibaipo Red Tourism Scenic Area. Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment,2017,31(07):183-188.
22	陈宽裕,林士丰,欧人豪.自行车活动参与者游憩涉入、地方依恋与目的地忠诚度关系之研究. 休闲观光与运动健康学报,2012,2(2):18-36.
	Chen K, Lin SJ.A study of the relationship between recreational involvement, place attachment , and destination loyalty among bike riders. Journal of Leisure, Tourism, Sport, & Health, 2012,2(2):18-36.
23	Moore R L, Scott D. Place attachment and context: Comparing a park and a trail within. Forest Science, 2003, 49(6) : 877-884.
24	张鉯崴,官绮君,戚令宜.游客游憩涉入、体验价值与地方依恋关系之研究——以新竹县内湾风景区为例. 观光与休闲管理期刊.2016,4(1):22-38.
	Zhang Y, Giam Q, Qi L. The relationships among recreation involvement, experiential value and place attachment: The study of Neiwan Scenic Area, Hsinchu. Journal of Tourism and Leisure Management,.2016,4(1):22-38.
25	唐文跃.皖南古村落居民地方依恋特征分析——以西递、宏村、南屏为例. 人文地理, 2011,26(03): 51-55.
	Tang W. The characteristics of place attachment of ancient village residents——A case study of Xidi, Hongcun and Nanping villages, southern Anhui. Human Geography, 2011,26(03):51-55.
26	冯岩松.SPSS22.0统计分析应用教程. 北京:清华大学出版社.2015:370-371.
	Feng Y. SPSS22.0 Statistical analysis application tutorial. Beijing: Tsinghua University Press, 2015:370-371.
27	吴明隆.结构方程模型——AMOS的操作与应用. 重庆:重庆大学出版社.2010:5.
	Wu M. Structural equation model——Operations and applications of AMOS. Chongqing: Chongqing University Press.2010:5.
28	Steele Fritz.The sense of place. Boston:CBI Pub Co., 1981.

变量	操作定义	量表来源	题项
吸引力	感知休闲活动的重要性及参与其中可能获得愉悦的程度	McIntyre & Pigram，1992^[26]	5
自我表现	指个人通过参加某种休闲活动不断认识自我，强化个人形象的过程		4
中心性	指休闲活动对个人生活的影响以及其在社交生活的相关程度		4
地方依恋	一种精神性依赖，是对某个地方作为社会角色自我感知的一部分的认知	邹统钎，2011^[14]	4
地方依赖	一种功能性依赖，体现地方资源及其提供的设施对拟开展活动的重要性	邹统钎，2011^[14]	6

变量	操作定义	量表来源	题项
吸引力	感知休闲活动的重要性及参与其中可能获得愉悦的程度	McIntyre & Pigram，1992^[26]	5
自我表现	指个人通过参加某种休闲活动不断认识自我，强化个人形象的过程		4
中心性	指休闲活动对个人生活的影响以及其在社交生活的相关程度		4
地方依恋	一种精神性依赖，是对某个地方作为社会角色自我感知的一部分的认知	邹统钎，2011^[14]	4
地方依赖	一种功能性依赖，体现地方资源及其提供的设施对拟开展活动的重要性	邹统钎，2011^[14]	6

潜变量	观测变量	因子载荷量	信度系数	测量误差	C.R.	AVE
吸引力	A1在1200书店休闲，我感觉很快乐	0.654	0.428	0.572	0.838	0.510
	A2我很享受在1200书店的休闲时光	0.696	0.484	0.516
	A3我对在1200书店休闲很感兴趣	0.813	0.661	0.339
	A4在1200书店休闲对我很重要	0.693	0.480	0.520
	A5相比其他休闲活动，我更喜欢在1200书店休闲	0.706	0.498	0.502
自我表现	S1在1200书店休闲让我深刻认识自我	0.787	0.619	0.381	0.783	0.546
	S2在1200书店休闲时，我可以做自己	0.704	0.496	0.504
	S3在1200书店休闲时，可以透露出我的很多方面	0.723	0.523	0.477
中心性	C1我的大部分休闲生活都是围绕1200书店休闲展开的	0.879	0.773	0.227	0.779	0.548
	C2 1200书店在我的休闲生活中占有中心地位	0.736	0.542	0.458
	C3我的大多数朋友是通过1200书店认识的	0.574	0.329	0.671
地方认同	PI11200书店对我来说意味着很多	0.765	0.585	0.415	0.777	0.545
	PI2我对1200书店的依恋感很强	0.867	0.752	0.248
	PI4 1200书店对我来说很特别	0.546	0.298	0.702
地方依赖	PD1没有其他休闲场所比得上1200书店	0.769	0.591	0.409	0.864	0.563
	PD2我去1200书店比去其他地方时得到更多的满意度	0.820	0.672	0.328
	PD3在1200书店休闲比在其他地方休闲更重要	0.862	0.743	0.257
	PD4我在其他地方不会做类似在1200书店里做的事情	0.584	0.341	0.659
	PD5 1200书店是我做喜欢的事情的最好地方	0.685	0.469	0.531

潜变量	观测变量	因子载荷量	信度系数	测量误差	C.R.	AVE
吸引力	A1在1200书店休闲，我感觉很快乐	0.654	0.428	0.572	0.838	0.510
	A2我很享受在1200书店的休闲时光	0.696	0.484	0.516
	A3我对在1200书店休闲很感兴趣	0.813	0.661	0.339
	A4在1200书店休闲对我很重要	0.693	0.480	0.520
	A5相比其他休闲活动，我更喜欢在1200书店休闲	0.706	0.498	0.502
自我表现	S1在1200书店休闲让我深刻认识自我	0.787	0.619	0.381	0.783	0.546
	S2在1200书店休闲时，我可以做自己	0.704	0.496	0.504
	S3在1200书店休闲时，可以透露出我的很多方面	0.723	0.523	0.477
中心性	C1我的大部分休闲生活都是围绕1200书店休闲展开的	0.879	0.773	0.227	0.779	0.548
	C2 1200书店在我的休闲生活中占有中心地位	0.736	0.542	0.458
	C3我的大多数朋友是通过1200书店认识的	0.574	0.329	0.671
地方认同	PI11200书店对我来说意味着很多	0.765	0.585	0.415	0.777	0.545
	PI2我对1200书店的依恋感很强	0.867	0.752	0.248
	PI4 1200书店对我来说很特别	0.546	0.298	0.702
地方依赖	PD1没有其他休闲场所比得上1200书店	0.769	0.591	0.409	0.864	0.563
	PD2我去1200书店比去其他地方时得到更多的满意度	0.820	0.672	0.328
	PD3在1200书店休闲比在其他地方休闲更重要	0.862	0.743	0.257
	PD4我在其他地方不会做类似在1200书店里做的事情	0.584	0.341	0.659
	PD5 1200书店是我做喜欢的事情的最好地方	0.685	0.469	0.531

潜变量	吸引力	自我表现	中心性	地方依赖	地方认同
吸引力	0.714
自我表现	0.518^**	0.739
中心性	0.171^**	0.300^**	0.740
地方依赖	0.380^**	0.393^**	0.536^**	0.738
地方认同	0.467^**	0.487^**	0.528^**	0.646^**	0.750