Spatial-temporal evolution characteristics and influencing factors on integration of cultural industry and tourism industry in ethnic regions

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1004-9479.2022.03.2020537

Abstract

Abstract:

The integration of culture and tourism is the general trend for tourism development and an important direction in ethnic regions.Taking Inner Mongolia as an example, basing on multi-indicator panel data of 12 cities from 2009 to 2018, this paper used related methods to analyze the integration of cultural industry and tourism industry and influencing factors in ethnic regions.Results showed that:①The development trend of cultural industry was better, and regional differences in tourism industry were significant.②Cities were in the optimized development stage of transition from imbalance to imbalance-coordination. The integration degree was not high, and most cities were in the lagging situation of tourism industry. ③Spatial differentiation of cities was significant, integration level was in the spatial pattern of "Central> East> West ", Cities with relatively good coordination levels were scattered.④Government support was leading variable in low-value areas, consumption level was the leading variable in medium-value areas, and infrastructure service level was the leading variable in high-value areas.

Key words: cultural industry, tourism industry, integrated development, ethnic regions, Inner Mongolia

摘要：

文旅融合是中国旅游发展的大趋势，也是民族地区社会经济发展的重要方向。以内蒙古自治区为例，基于内蒙古12个盟市2009—2018年的多指标面板数据，运用熵权TopSIS、改进的容量耦合模型、标准差椭圆、重心模型和面板数据分位数回归模型分析民族地区文化产业和旅游产业融合的时空演变特征及影响因素。研究发现：①内蒙古各盟市文化产业发展态势向好，旅游产业区域差异明显；②各盟市处于中度失调向失调-协调过渡的优化发展阶段，融合协调度等级不高，大多数盟市一直处于旅游产业发展滞后的局面；③各盟市空间分异显著，协调度水平呈“蒙中>蒙东>蒙西”的局面，协调度水平相对较好的盟市呈分散分布，盟市间的文旅发展尚未形成合力；④政府支持是内蒙古文旅产业融合低值区的主导影响变量，消费水平是中值区的主导变量，基础设施是高值区的主导变量。

关键词: 文化产业, 旅游产业, 融合发展, 民族地区, 内蒙古

Chenrouyu ZHENG, Cundong YANG, Wenxing REN. Spatial-temporal evolution characteristics and influencing factors on integration of cultural industry and tourism industry in ethnic regions[J]. World Regional Studies, 2022, 31(3): 613-623.

郑陈柔雨, 杨存栋, 任雯星. 民族地区文旅产业融合的时空演变及影响因素分析[J]. 世界地理研究, 2022, 31(3): 613-623.

Figures/Tables 10

References 27

1	刘安乐,杨承玥,明庆忠,等.中国文化产业与旅游产业协调态势及其驱动力.经济地理,2020,40(6):203-213.
	LIU A, YANG C, MING Q, et al. Spatial-temporal coordination and driving forces of provincial culture industry and tourism industry in China. Economic Geography, 2020,40(6):203-213.
2	RICHARDS G. Cultural tourism: A review of recent research and trends. Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management, 2018(36):12-21.
3	希拉里·迪克罗,鲍勃·麦克彻.文化旅游.北京:商务印书馆,2017.
	DU CROS H, MCKERCHER B.Cultural Tourism. Beijing: The Commercial Press, 2017.
4	SMITH M, RICHARDS G. The Routledge Handbook of Cultural Tourism. London: Routledge,2013.
5	CHHABRA D. Cultural tourism research methods. Annals of Tourism Research, 2011,38(4):1669-1671.
6	WELLS C, LYON S.Cultural heritage and economic encounters in the age of global tourism.Anthropology News,2010,51(8):24.
7	CHEN H, RAHMAN I. Cultural tourism: An analysis of engagement, cultural contact, memorable tourism experience and destination loyalty. Tourism Management Perspectives, 2017(26):153-163.
8	DI LASCIO F, GIANNERINI S, SCORCU A, et al. Cultural tourism and temporary art exhibitions in Italy: A panel data analysis. Statistical Methods & Applications, 2011,20(4):519-542.
9	HAIGH M.Cultural tourism policy in developing regions:The case of Sarawak,Malaysia.Tourism Management,2020, 81(1):1-11.
10	翁钢民,李凌雁.中国旅游与文化产业融合发展的耦合协调度及空间相关分析.经济地理,2016,36(1):176-185.
	WENG G, LI L. The coupling coordination degree and spatial correlation analysis on integrational development of tourism industry and cultural industry in China. Economic Geography,2016,36(1):176-185.
11	南宇,孙建飞,张萍.丝绸之路背景下甘南藏族自治州旅游产业与文化产业融合问题研究.干旱区资源与环境,2017,31(3):203-208.
	NAN Y, SUN J, ZHANG P. The integration of tourism industry and cultural industry in Gannan Tibetan Autonomous Prefecture. Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment,2017,31(3):203-208.
12	袁俊,张萌.中国文化创意产业园与旅游业融合效果的地区对比.世界地理研究.2016, 25(6):119-127.
	YUAN J, ZHANG M. Regional comparison of integration effect between cultural and creative industry parks and tourism industry. World Regional Studies,2016,25(6):119-127.
13	牛玉,汪德根.基于游客视角的历史街区旅游发展模式影响机理及创新:以苏州平江路为例.地理研究,2015, 34(1):181-196.
	NIU Y, WANG D. Influence mechanism and innovation of tourism development pattern of historic streets based on the perspective of tourists: A case of Pingjiang road of Suzhou. Geographical Research, 2015, 34(1): 181-196.
14	尹华光,王换茹,姚云贵.武陵山片区文化产业与旅游产业融合发展模式研究.中南民族大学学报(人文社会科学版),2015, 35(4): 39-43.
	YIN H, WANG H, YAO Y. Study on the development model of the integration of cultural industry and tourism industry in Wuling mountain area. Journal of South-Central Minzu University (Humanities and Social Sciences Edition), 2015, 35(4): 39-43.
15	张朝枝,朱敏敏.文化和旅游融合:多层次关系内涵、挑战与践行路径.旅游学刊,2020,35(3):62-71.
	ZHANG C, ZHU M.The integration of culture and tourism: Multi-understandings, various challenges and approaches.Tourism Tribune,2020,35(3):62-71.
16	李兰冰,刘秉镰.中国区域经济增长绩效、源泉与演化:基于要素分解视角.经济研究,2015(8):58-72.
	LI L, LIU B. China's regional economic growth performance, source and evolution: Based on the perspective of factor decomposition. Economic Research Journal, 2015(8):58-72.
17	丁赛,王国洪,王经绫,等.民族地区县域文旅产业发展指标体系的构建和分析.民族研究,2019(2):38-51+140.
	DING S, WANG G, WANG J, et al. The establishment and analysis of the index system of county-level culture and tourism industry in ethnic minority areas. Ethno-National Studies, 2019(2):38-51+140.
18	王经绫.民族地区文化和旅游融合发展影响要素的系统建构—基于71个民族县域文旅融合发展要素调查问卷的分析. 西南民族大学学报(人文社科版), 2020(8): 24-30.
	WANG J. The system integration of the factors influencing the development of cultural and tourism integration in ethnic areas: Based on the questionnaire analysis of the elements of cultural and tourism integration development in 71 ethnic counties. Journal of Southwest Minzu University (Humanities and Social Science), 2020(8): 24-30.
19	ZHANG Z, LI Y. Coupling coordination and spatiotemporal dynamic evolution between urbanization and geological hazards: A case study from China. Science of the Total Environment, 2020(728):1-12.
20	刘安乐,王成,杨承玥,等.边疆山区旅游城市的交通与旅游发展耦合关系—以丽江市为实证案例.经济地理,2018,38(1):196-203.
	LIU A, WANG C, YANG C, et al. The association mechanism between traffic and tourism development of tourist cities in frontier mountainous area: Taking Lijiang city as an example.Economic Geography,2018,38(1):196-203.
21	曾冰.区域经济分析与ArcGIS软件应用.江西人民出版社,2018.
	ZENG B. Regional Economic Analysis and ArcGIS Software Application. Jiangxi People's Press,2018.
22	KOENKER R. Quantile regression for Longitudinal data. Journal of Multivariate Analysis, 2004(91):74-89.
23	王芳,高晓路.内蒙古县域经济空间格局演化研究.地理科学,2014,34(7):818-824.
	WANG F, GAO X. Research on the evolution of county economic spatial pattern in Inner Mongolia. Scientia Geographica Sinica,2014,34(7):818-824.
24	但红燕,徐武明. 旅游产业与文化产业融合动因及其效应分析—以四川为例.生态经济,2015,31(7):110-113+117.
	DAN H, XU W. The study on motives and effects of tourism industry and culture industry merge: In the case of Sichuan Province. Ecological Economy,2015,31(7):110-113+117.
25	周春波.文化产业与旅游产业融合动力:理论与实证.企业经济,2018,38(8):146-151.
	ZHOU C. The fusion power of cultural industry and tourism industry: Theory and demonstration. Enterprise Economy, 2018, 38(8):146-151.
26	李丽,徐佳.中国文旅产业融合发展水平测度及其驱动因素分析.统计与决策,2020(20):49-52.
	LI L, XU J. Measurement of the integration level of China's cultural tourism industry and analysis of its driving factor. Statistics and Decision,2020(20):49-52.
27	谷文双.民族地区文化旅游业发展探析—以贵州民族地区为例.贵州民族研究,2016,37(11):170-175.
	GU W. Exploration on the culture and tourism development in the minority concentrated region:Taking Guizhou minority concentrated region as an example. Guizhou Ethnic Studies,2016,37(11):170-175.

目标层	准则层	指标层
文化产业综合水平	文化产业效用水平	公共图书馆总流通人次/万人
		文化娱乐人均消费支出/元
		文化文物事业费/万元
	文化产业资本要素	文化艺术事业人员数/人
		艺术表演团体数/个
		艺术表演场所数/个
		文化馆及博物馆数/个
		物质文化遗产数/个
		非物质文化遗产数/个
旅游产业综合水平	旅游产业效用水平	入境旅游人数/人次
		国内旅游收入/亿元
		旅游外汇收入/万美元
		国内旅游人数/万人次
	旅游产业资本要素	旅行社个数/个
		住宿餐饮业从业人员/人
		星级宾馆资源/单体数
		A级旅游景区资源/单体数
		民族特色旅游资源/单体数

目标层	准则层	指标层
文化产业综合水平	文化产业效用水平	公共图书馆总流通人次/万人
		文化娱乐人均消费支出/元
		文化文物事业费/万元
	文化产业资本要素	文化艺术事业人员数/人
		艺术表演团体数/个
		艺术表演场所数/个
		文化馆及博物馆数/个
		物质文化遗产数/个
		非物质文化遗产数/个
旅游产业综合水平	旅游产业效用水平	入境旅游人数/人次
		国内旅游收入/亿元
		旅游外汇收入/万美元
		国内旅游人数/万人次
	旅游产业资本要素	旅行社个数/个
		住宿餐饮业从业人员/人
		星级宾馆资源/单体数
		A级旅游景区资源/单体数
		民族特色旅游资源/单体数

变量	变量选取	变量表征
解释变量	公路里程/公里	基础设施
	普通高等学校在校学生数/人	人力资本
	社会消费品零售总额/万元	消费水平
	公共财政支出/万元	政府支持
	第三产业增加值占GDP比重/%	产业基础
	固定资产投资额/万元	市场供给

变量	变量选取	变量表征
解释变量	公路里程/公里	基础设施
	普通高等学校在校学生数/人	人力资本
	社会消费品零售总额/万元	消费水平
	公共财政支出/万元	政府支持
	第三产业增加值占GDP比重/%	产业基础
	固定资产投资额/万元	市场供给

回归	面板数据分位数回归									一般回归
回归	0.1	0.2	0.3	0.4	0.5	0.6	0.7	0.8	0.9	一般回归
截距项	0.121^***	0.135^***	0.160^***	0.185^***	0.190^***	0.186^***	0.180^***	0.194^***	0.249^***	0.141^***
公路里程	0.095^***	0.086^***	0.058^***	0.059^***	0.061^***	0.078^**	0.129^**	0.227^***	0.276^***	0.173^***
普通高等学校在校学生数	0.071^**	0.047^*	0.039^*	0.043	0.043	0.036	0.016	0.036	0.107	0.080^*
社会消费品零售总额	0.075^*	0.086^**	0.105^***	0.126^***	0.123^***	0.115^***	0.116^**	0.076	0.099^**	0.071^*
公共财政支出	0.116^***	0.101^***	0.108^***	0.093^***	0.110^***	0.108^***	0.088	0.087	0.046	0.136^***
第三产业增加值占GDP比重	0.089^***	0.109^***	0.096^**	0.053	0.039	0.053	0.076	0.027	-0.048	0.057
固定资产投资额	-0.003	-0.010	-0.031^*	-0.024^*	-0.024^*	-0.021	-0.016	-0.012	-0.058	-0.03^*