Comparative research on geo-economic cooperation between China and Central Asian countries from the perspective of OBOR

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1004-9479.2020.01.2018553

Abstract

Abstract:

The five countries of Central Asia participate in the construction of the Silk Road Economic Belt. The trade and investment cooperation between China and the five countries of Central Asia is directly related to the expansion of the geo- economic space of China. So it is of great significance to the construction of OBOR. In this paper, from the perspective of geo-economic and regional economic cooperation, using statistical analysis and comparative analysis methods, the auther studies and compares the development and changes of the economic aggregates of the five countries of Central Asia, their trade environment and the effectiveness of trade with China, their business environment and the effectiveness of China's investment in Central Asian countries. The main conclusions are as follows: The trade and investment environment of Central Asian countries is generally at a low level and still needs further improvement; Trade and investment between China with different countries of Central Asia are developing in the same direction; China and Central Asian countries are forming a pattern of energy imports and exports of civilian goods; Trade and investment between China with Central Asian countries are imbalances, it shows the characteristics of large differences among countries and concentrated of individual industries, which may increase the risk of China’s trade and investment in Central Asian countries.In order to further enhance the level of cooperation, we put forward the following suggestions: to improve the level of regional trade and investment facilitation; to take different strategies for different countries,to further develop the potential of all parties, expand the scale of trade and investment; to encourage two-way investment, and increase the breadth and depth of trade and investment，together to build a more rational regional system of trade and investment between China and the five countries of Central Asia.

Key words: geo-economic cooperation, trade and investment, envirment, effect, Central Asian countries, OBOR

摘要：

中亚五国是我国西出的首站，是参与丝绸之路经济带建设的重要国家，中国与中亚的贸易投资合作直接关系到我国地缘经济空间的拓展，对“一带一路”建设意义重大。本文从地缘经济和区域经济合作的角度，运用统计分析和比较分析的方法，研究比较了中亚五国经济总量的发展变化，中亚五国的贸易环境及其与中国贸易的成效，以及中亚五国的营商环境和中国对中亚各国投资的成效。主要结论如下：中亚国家的贸易投资环境总体处于较低水平，仍需得到进一步改善；中国对中亚不同国家的贸易和投资呈同向发展的趋势；中国与中亚国家正在形成能源资源进口与民用品出口的格局；中国对中亚国家的贸易投资不平衡，呈现出国别差异较大、个别行业分布过于集中的特点，可能会加大中国对中亚国家贸易投资的风险。为进一步提升双方合作，提出以下建议：提高区域贸易投资便利化水平；因国施策，进一步发挥各方潜力，扩大贸易投资规模；促进区域经济的均衡可持续发展；鼓励双向投资，提高贸易投资的广度和深度，与中亚共同构建更加合理的区域贸易投资体系。

关键词: 地缘经济合作, 贸易与投资, 环境, 成效, 中亚国家, “一带一路”倡议

Haiyan WANG. Comparative research on geo-economic cooperation between China and Central Asian countries from the perspective of OBOR[J]. World Regional Studies, 2020, 29(1): 18-29.

王海燕. “一带一路”视域下中国与中亚国家地缘经济合作比较研究[J]. 世界地理研究, 2020, 29(1): 18-29.

Figures/Tables 8

References 37

1	[美]尼古拉斯·斯皮克曼. 和平地理学．上海:上海人民出版社，2016:101.[Spykman Nicholas. The Geography of the Peace. Shanghai: Shanghai People's Publishing House, 2016:101.]
2	哈]V．多多诺夫，L．穆扎帕洛瓦，D．穆扎穆德扎诺瓦．中亚：从外围到中心．俄罗斯研究，2014(2): 53-70．
	Dodonov Vyacheslav, Muzaparova Leyla, Mukhamedzhanova Dariya. Central Asia: from Peripherality to Centrality. Russian Studies, 2014, 186(2): 53-70.
3	孙壮志．中亚五国的地缘战略地位．东欧中亚研究，2000(4)：61-67．
	Sun Z. The geostrategic position of the five Central Asian countries. East European, Russian &Central Asian Studies, 2000(4):61-67.
4	赵常庆．中亚五国与中国西部开发的关系．东欧中亚市场研究，2001(12): 31-36．
	Zhao C. The relationship between the five Central Asian countries and Western Development. Russian Central Asian & East European Market, 2001(12):31-36.
5	杨恕．中亚的地缘政治——历史和现实．中国边疆史地研究，2003(3)：68-72．
	Yang S. Geopolitics of Central Asia: History and reality. China’s Borderland History and Geography Studies, 2003(3)：68-72.
6	胡鞍钢,马伟,鄢一龙．“丝绸之路经济带”：战略内涵、定位和实现路径．新疆师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版)，2014(2):1-10．
	Hu A, Ma W, Yan Y. Connotation, definition and passage of “Silk-road Economic Belt” Strategy. Journal of Xinjiang Normal University,2014(2): 1-10.
7	冯宗宪．中国向欧亚大陆延伸的战略动脉——丝绸之路经济带的区域、线路划分和功能详解.人民论坛·学术前沿，2014(4): 79-85．
	Feng Z. Strategic transport arteries connecting China to Eurasia—Details of the area, route delineation and function of the New Silk Road Economic Belt. Frontiers,2014(4): 79-85.
8	刘华芹,李钢．建设“丝绸之路经济带”的总体战略与基本架构．国际贸易,2014(3):4-9.
	Liu H, Li G. The general strategy and basic structure for building the "Silk Road Economic Belt". Intertrade, 2014 (3): 4-9.
9	邢广程．理解中国现代丝绸之路战略——中国与世界深度互动的新型链接范式．世界经济与政治，2014(12)：4-26．
	Xing G. On China's New Silk Road Strategy: A new linking model of deep interactions between China and the world. World Economics and Politics, 2014(12):4-26.
10	刘卫东．“一带一路”战略的科学内涵与科学问题．地理科学进展，2015(5):538-544．
	Liu W. Scientific understanding of the Belt and Road Initiative of China and related research themes. Progress in Geography, 2015, 34(5): 538-544.
11	杜德斌,马亚华．“一带一路”:中华民族复兴的地缘大战略．地理研究,2015(6):1005-1014．
	Du D, Ma Y. One Belt and One Road: The grand geo-strategy of China’s rise. Geographical Research, 2015,34(6): 1005 -1014.
12	陆大道．当代中国的全球观念与全球战略．地理科学，2016(4)：483-490．
	Lu D. The global concept and strategy of contemporary China: Analysis on the geopolitical and geoeconomic environment of the “Belt and Road Initiative”. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2016,36(4):483-490.
13	宋长青，葛岳静，刘云刚,等．从地缘关系视角解析“一带一路”的行动路径．地理研究，2018(1)：3-19．
	Song C, Ge Y, Liu Y, et al. Undertaking research on Belt and Road Initiative from the geo-relation perspective. Geographical Research, 2018,37(1):3-19.
14	王海燕．贸易投资便利化:中国与哈萨克斯坦．上海：华东师范大学出版社，2012．
	Wang H. Trade and investment facilitation: China and Kazakhstan. Shanghai: East China Normal University Press,2012.
15	刘华芹．上海合作组织贸易投资便利化评估与前景展望．国际贸易,2013(11):48-51．
	Liu H. Shanghai Cooperation Organization trade investment facilitation assessment and prospects. Intertrade, 2013 (11): 48-51.
16	程中海，孙培蕾．中国与中亚周边国家贸易便利化影响因素研究．商业研究，2014 (11)：99-105．
	Cheng Z, Sun P. Research on the factors influencing the trade facilitation between China and neighboring countries in Central Asia. Commercial Research, 2014 (11):99-105.
17	凌激．中国与中亚国家经贸合作现状、问题及建议．国际观察，2010(5)：17-22．
	Ling J. Current situation, problems and suggestions of economic and trade cooperation between China and Central Asian Countries. International Review, 2010 (5):17-22.
18	韩璐．深化上海合作组织经济合作:机遇、障碍与努力方向．国际问题研究,2018(3):56-68．
	Han L. Deepening economic cooperation in the Shanghai Cooperation Organization: Opportunities, barriers and approaches. International Studies, 2018(3): 56-68.
19	高国珍，王海龙．中国与中亚国家双边经贸合作潜力分析．国际经济合作，2015(8)：72-77．
	Gao G, Wang H. Analysis of the potential of bilateral economic and trade cooperation between China and Central Asian Countries. Journal of International Economic Cooperation, 2015 (8):72-77.
20	公丕萍,宋周莺,刘卫东．中国与“一带一路”沿线国家贸易的商品格局．地理科学进展，2015(5)： 571- 580．
	Gong P, Song Z, Liu W. Commodity structure of trade between China and countries in the Belt and Road Initiative area. Progress in Geography, 2015,34(5):571-580.
21	刘二虎，陈瑛．丝绸之路经济带背景下中亚五国投资环境比较研究．世界地理研究，2018(4):100- 107．
	Liu E, Chen Y. Research on investment environmental comparison in Central Asia under the background of the Silk Road Economic Belt. World Regional Studies, 2018,27(4):100-107.
22	杨立卓,刘雪娇,余稳策． “一带一路”背景下我国与中亚国家贸易互补性研究．上海经济研究，2015(11): 94-103．
	Yang L, Liu X, Yu W. Research On the trade complementarity Between China and Central Asian countries under the background of “the Belt and Road Initiative”. Shanghai Journal of Economics, 2015 (6):94-103.
23	魏兰叶,陈晓. 中国在中亚直接投资对双边贸易的影响——基于丝绸之路经济带的研究视角．现代经济探讨, 2017(12)：41-48．
	Wei L, Chen X. The impact of China's direct investment in Central Asia on bilateral trade—Based on the Research perspective of the Silk Road Economic Belt. Modern Economic Research, 2017(12): 41-48.
24	郑蕾，刘志高．中国对“一带一路”沿线直接投资空间格局．地理科学进展，2015(5)：563-570．
	Zheng L, Liu Z. Spatial pattern of Chinese outward direct investment in the Belt and Road Initiative area. Progress in Geography, 2015, 34(5):563-570.
25	李东阳，杨殿中．中国对中亚五国直接投资与双边贸易关系研究．财经问题研究，2012(12)：90-95．
	Li D, Yang D. Research on China's direct investment and bilateral trade relations with five Central Asian countries. Research on Financial and Economic Issues, 2012 (12): 90-95.
26	郭惠君，孙玉琴．中国对中亚国家直接投资的出口贸易效应研究．现代管理科学，2016 (8)：24-26．
	Guo H, Sun Y. Research on export trade effects of China's direct investment in Central Asian countries. Modern Management Science, 2016(8): 24-26.
27	闫杰，刘清娟，热依汗·吾甫尔．中国对中亚五国直接投资的贸易效应——基于丝绸之路经济带视角的研究．上海经济研究， 2017(3):58-64．
	Yan J, Liu Q, Reyihan W. On the trade effect of Chinese outward foreign direct investment in Central Asia countries:in the view of the Silk Road Economic Belt. Shanghai Journal of Economics, 2017(3):58-64.
28	王海燕．中国企业进入中亚市场的机遇与前景．俄罗斯中亚东欧市场，2009(3):25－32．
	Wang H. Opportunities and prospects for Chinese companies to enter the Central Asian market. Russian Central Asian & East European Market, 2009(3): 25－32.
29	何伦志，王德全．西部大开发与建立中亚自由贸易区的构想．新疆大学学报：哲学社会科学,2000(4)：1-5．
	He L,Wang D.The conception of Great Western Development and establishment of Free Trade Zone in Central Asia. Journal of Xinjiang University： Philosophy and Social Science Edition, 2000 (4):1-5.
30	王海燕．中哈自由贸易区：机遇、挑战与前景．国际经济合作,2009(11):33-38．
	Wang H. China- Kazakhstan Free Trade Area: opportunities, challenges and prospects. International Economic Cooperation, 2009(11):33-38.
31	刘志中．“新丝绸之路”背景下中国中亚自由贸易区建设研究．东北亚论坛，2014(1)：113-118．
	Liu Z. Research on the construction of China and Central Asia Free Trade Area under the background of “New Silk Road”. Northeast Asia Forum, 2014(1):113-118.
32	李钢．“上海五国”——建立跨亚欧经济合作区构想．国际贸易, 2001(1):10-14．
	Li G. "Shanghai five countries" - Conception of establishing a Trans-Asia-Europe Economic Cooperation Zone. International Trade, 2001 (1):10-14.
33	李立凡．论上海合作组织经济与贸易合作——兼论中国对推动上合组织经贸一体化的设想．世界经济研究，2007(4):79-84．
	Li L. On the Economic and Trading Collaboration within the Framework of Shanghai Organization Cooperation.World Economy Study, 2007(4): 79-84.
34	朱显平，邹向阳．上海合作组织框架下的区域经济一体化：进展与动力．俄罗斯中亚东欧研究，2010(3)： 47-54．
	Zhu X, Zou X. Regional economic integration under the framework of Shanghai Cooperation Organization: Progress and motivation. Russian, Central Asian & East European Studies, 2010(3): 47-54.
35	董锁成，黄永斌，李泽红,等．丝绸之路经济带经济发展格局与区域经济一体化模式．资源科学，2014 (12): 2451-2458．
	Dong S, Huang Y, Li Z, et al. Economic development patterns and regional economic integration modes for the Silk Road Economic Zone. Resources Science, 2014,36 (12): 2451-2458.
36	М. С. Имоналиев. Укрепляющиеся отношения между странами Центральной Азии и КНР: аспекты и потенциал двустороннего сотрудничества между Кыргызской Ресбупликой и Китайской Народной Республикой. Бишкек: Нацианальный институт стратегических исследований　Кыргызской Ресбупликой.2015.
37	Сыроежкин Константин Львович．«Сверили часы» в Циндао．Казахстанская правда, 15 июня 2018 г. .

国别	1993年				2000年				2010年				2017年
	GDP		人均GDP		GDP		人均GDP		GDP		人均GDP		GDP		人均GDP
	亿美元	排名	美元	排名	亿美元	排名	美元	排名	亿美元	排名	美元	排名	亿美元	排名	美元	排名
哈国	52	97	305	144	183	72	1231	108	1481	50	9005	67	1563	54	8585	73
乌国	55	95	252	151	137	77	551	135	390	82	1367	140	675	70	2128	134
土国	54	96	1343	87	114	50	1116	113	226	97	4479	96	417	84	7522	79
塔国	6.8	142	122	165	9.9	149	159	176	56	143	741	161	72	139	819	161
吉国	6.7	143	162	148	13.7	141	278	159	48	144	875	156	71	140	1139	153

国别	1993年				2000年				2010年				2017年
	GDP		人均GDP		GDP		人均GDP		GDP		人均GDP		GDP		人均GDP
	亿美元	排名	美元	排名	亿美元	排名	美元	排名	亿美元	排名	美元	排名	亿美元	排名	美元	排名
哈国	52	97	305	144	183	72	1231	108	1481	50	9005	67	1563	54	8585	73
乌国	55	95	252	151	137	77	551	135	390	82	1367	140	675	70	2128	134
土国	54	96	1343	87	114	50	1116	113	226	97	4479	96	417	84	7522	79
塔国	6.8	142	122	165	9.9	149	159	176	56	143	741	161	72	139	819	161
吉国	6.7	143	162	148	13.7	141	278	159	48	144	875	156	71	140	1139	153

国别	得分	世界位	同比上年得分	性质
哈国	69	42	+5.4	有限度的中等自由经济体
吉国	61.1	89	+1.5	有限度的中等自由经济体
塔国	58.2	109	+6.9	比较压制的较不自由经济体
乌国	52.3	148	+6.3	比较压制的较不自由经济体
土国	47.4	170	+5.5	受压制经济体

国别	得分	世界位	同比上年得分	性质
哈国	69	42	+5.4	有限度的中等自由经济体
吉国	61.1	89	+1.5	有限度的中等自由经济体
塔国	58.2	109	+6.9	比较压制的较不自由经济体
乌国	52.3	148	+6.3	比较压制的较不自由经济体
土国	47.4	170	+5.5	受压制经济体

国别	1992	2000	2005	2010	2012	2013	2014	2015	2016	2017
哈国	38000	155696	680611	2044852	2568157	2859596	2245167	1429724	1310842	1800000
土国	450	1616	10996	156964	1037250	1003090	1047044	864468	590176	695000
吉国	3600	17761	97220	419964	516232	513770	529794	434181	568173	545000
乌国	5300	5146	68056	248327	287519	455145	427612	349792	361609	496100
塔国	300	1717	15794	143256	185670	195812	251594	184885	176255	137000
共计	47650	181936	872677	3013363	4594828	5027413	4501211	3263050	3007055	3673100