Spatial-temporal evolution of green trade pattern in countries along

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1004-9479.2023.10.20220445

Abstract

Abstract:

The green trade as one of the important content of green silk road construction, pays an important role in the extension of the green supply chain, guide the direction of the green investment and improve the green industry layout. Firstly, the green trade data of countries along the Silk Road from 2000 to 2019 are divided into four stages based on the ordered clustering method, and then the changes of regional status, intra-regional pattern and intra-regional competition and cooperation in global green trade in each stage are explored. The results show that :①From the perspective of global status and spatial structure, the global status of green trade of countries along the "sea line" has significantly increased from 2000 to 2019.The "multi-core" spatial structure of regional green trade is also becoming more and more obvious. Among them, Southeast Asia has been in the "core" echelon of the main position. ② From the perspective of the green trade structure between China and the countries along the "Silk Road", China's green trade deficit is unstable and in a long-term deficit state, and its external competitive advantage is increasing year by year, but it is still in a weak competitive advantage; However, the structure of green trade products between China and countries along the "Silk Road" is reasonable and highly complementary.

Key words: the 21st Century Maritime Silk Road, green trade, spatial-temporal evolution, the Cooperative and Competition Model of Trade

摘要：

绿色贸易是海上丝绸之路建设的重要组成部分之一，在延伸绿色产业链、引导绿色投资方向以及优化绿色产业布局等方面均发挥着重要的作用。基于有序聚类、中心度、贸易竞合关系等方法与模型，对2000—2019年“21世纪海上丝绸之路”沿线国家绿色贸易的地位及时空变化以及中国与域内国家绿色贸易竞争合作关系进行研究。结果表明：①从地位和空间结构来看，2000—2019年沿线国家绿色贸易地位在世界范围内有显著改善，区域绿色贸易的“多核心”空间结构进一步增强，东南亚一直处于“核心”梯队的主体地位。②从中国与沿线国家绿色贸易关系来看，中国长时期处于逆差状态，虽然竞争优势呈现逐年提升的趋势，但仍然较弱；中国与沿线国家之间的绿色贸易具有较强的互补性，产品结构逐步趋向更加合理。

关键词: “21世纪海上丝绸之路”, 绿色贸易, 时空演变, 贸易竞合模型

Laishun WANG, Jianzhong LIU, Yinbao ZHANG, Xinjia ZHANG. Spatial-temporal evolution of green trade pattern in countries along "the 21st Century Maritime Silk Road"[J]. World Regional Studies, 2023, 32(10): 63-75.

王来顺, 刘建忠, 张寅宝, 张欣佳. “21世纪海上丝绸之路”沿线国家绿色贸易格局的时空演变[J]. 世界地理研究, 2023, 32(10): 63-75.

Figures/Tables 9

References 38

1	郭瑞. 与"海上丝绸之路"沿线国贸易对我国经济增长的影响.曲阜:曲阜师范大学, 2019.
	GUO R. The impact of trade with countries along the "Maritime Silk Road" on China's economic growth. Qufu: Qufu Normal University,2019
2	孙亚楠.绿色壁垒对我国农产品贸易的影响及对策研究——评«基于绿色贸易壁垒视角的中国农产品出口贸易研究».生态经济,2022,38(6):230-231.
	SUN Y.Research on the influence of green barriers on China's agricultural products trade and countermeasures——Comment on "Research on China's Agricultural Products Export Trade Based on the Perspective of Green Trade Barriers". Ecological Economy,2022,38(6): 230-231.
3	胡蓓蓓,刘科群,董现垒.中国绿色贸易与国民幸福指数的关联性研究.统计与决策,2020,36(12):100-104.
	HU B, LIU K, DONG X.Research on the correlation between China's green trade and national happiness index. Statistics & Decision,2020,36(12): 100-104.
4	闫宁.我国区域绿色贸易的发展格局与时空演化研究.全国流通经济,2022(7):37-39.
	YAN N.Research on the development pattern and temporal and spatial evolution of China's regional green trade. China Circulation Economy,2022(7): 37-39.
5	李培超,郑楠.论绿色发展的伦理导向与环境保护道德机制的建构.伦理学研究,2016(3):8-12.
	LI P, ZHENG N. On the ethical orientation of green development and the construction of environmental protection moral mechanism.Studies in Ethics,2016(3): 8-12.
6	邓小云.贯彻落实绿色发展理念的思路与对策.东岳论丛,2016,37(9):178-182.
	DENG X. Ideas and countermeasures for implementing the concept of green development. Dongyue Tribune,2016,37(9):178-182.
7	HAI L. Price effects of the United States(US) antidumping investigations in a non-market economy case: Vietnam's shrimp exports to the US. The International Trade Journal, 2020, 34(2): 179-200.
8	孙红雨,佟光霁. 绿色贸易壁垒对中俄农产品出口贸易的影响研究. 改革, 2019(2): 149-157.
	SUN H, TONG G. Research on the impact of green trade barriers on Sino-Russian agricultural export trade. Reform,2019(2): 149-157.
9	MELO J, SOLLEDER J. Barriers to trade in environmental goods: how important they are and what should developing countries expect from their removal. World Development, 2020(130): 104910.
10	刘健西. 贸易自由化进程中的农产品贸易壁垒:演进与发展.农村经济,2019 (8): 111-118.
	LIU J. Agricultural trade barriers in the process of trade liberalization. Rural Economy, 2019 (8): 111-118.
11	ASICI A, ACAR S. Does income growth relocate ecological footprint?. Ecological Indicators, 2016(61): 707-714.
12	RASLI A, QURESHI M, ISAH-CHIKAJI A,et al. New Toxics, Race to the bottom and revised environmental kuznets curve: the case of local and global pollutants. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2018(81): 3120-3130.
13	邵帆. 绿色贸易壁垒成因的博弈分析. 价格月刊, 2011(8): 61-64.
	SUN F. Game analysis of the causes of green trade barriers. Prices Monthly, 2011(8): 61-64.
14	宁坤,林冬冬. 绿色贸易壁垒对我国茶叶出口影响及对策分析. 学理论, 2015(30): 34-35.
	NING K, LIN D. The impact of green trade barriers on my country's tea export and its countermeasures. Theory Research, 2015(30): 34-35.
15	杨曦,彭水军. 碳关税可以有效解决碳泄漏和竞争力问题吗?——基于异质性企业贸易模型的分析. 经济研究, 2017, 52(5): 60-74.
	YANG X, PENG S. Does carbon tariff prevent carbon leakage and competitiveness losses?—Analyses based on the trade models with firm heterogeneity. Economic Research Journal, 2017, 52(5): 60-74.
16	CHRISTOPH B, JARED C, THOMAS F. Embodied carbon tariffs. The Scandinavian Journal of Economics, 2018, 120(1): 183-210.
17	WINCHEESTER N. Can tariffs be used to enforce paris climate commitments?. The World Economy, 2018, 41(10): 2650-2668.
18	BRANDI C, SCHWAB J, BERGER A,et al. Do environmental provisions in trade agreements make exports from developing countries greener?. World Development, 2020(129): 104899.
19	HUANG J, OU-YANG Q, FENG C. Green trade assessment for sustainable development of chinese ferrous metal industry. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2020(249): 119382.
20	张东阳,郑学党.两岸环境产品贸易增长因素研究.中国人口·资源与环境, 2015, 25(S2): 51-54.
	ZHANG D, ZHENG X. Research on growth factors of cross-strait environmental products trade. China Population,Resources and Environment,2015,25(S2):51-54.
21	KRUGMAN P. Scale economies, product differentiation, and the pattern of trade. The American Economic Review, 1980, 70(5): 950-959.
22	马淑琴,戴军,温怀德. 贸易开放、环境规制与绿色技术进步——基于中国省际数据的空间计量分析. 国际贸易问题, 2019(10): 132-145.
	MA S, DAI J, WEN H. Trade openness,environmental,regulation and green technology progress—Spatial econometric analysis based on provincial data in China. Journal of International Trade,2019(10):132-145.
23	夏启繁,杜德斌.21世纪海上丝绸之路能源贸易结构及与中国的贸易关系演变.地理研究,2022,41(7):1797-1813.
	XIA Q, DU D. Evolution of energy trade structure in the 21st Century Maritime Silk Road and its trade relations with China. Geographical Research,2022,41(7):1797-1813.
24	张新放,吕靖.21世纪海上丝绸之路港口体系时空格局演变.经济地理,2019,39(11):33-40.
	ZHANG X,LYV J. Spatial-temporal pattern and evolution of port system along the 21st-Century Maritime Silk Road. Economic Geography,2019,39(11):33-40.
25	彭飞,胡锦琳,伏捷,等."21世纪海上丝绸之路"沿线国家水产品贸易网络分析.热带地理,2021,41(6):1188-1198.
	PENG F, HU J, FU J, et al. The trade network of aquatic products of Countries along the "21st Century Maritime Silk Road".Tropical Geography,2021,41(6):1188-1198.
26	蔡海亚,潘坤友.21世纪海上丝绸之路沿线国家(地区)航运竞争力综合评价与空间差异.经济地理,2021,41(11):28-37.
	CAI H, PAN K. Comprehensive evaluation and spatial difference of port shipping competitiveness of countries(regions)along the 21st Century Maritime Silk Road. Economic Geography, ,2021,41(11):28-37.
27	王列辉,苏晗,朱艳.21世纪海上丝绸之路沿线港口城市的功能类型与生命周期.世界地理研究,2022,31(3):453-465.
	WANG L, SU H, ZHU Y. Port-city relationship and life cycle of port cities along the Maritime Silk Road. World Regional Studies,2022,31(3):453-465.
28	牟乃夏,廖梦迪,张恒才,等."海上丝绸之路"沿线重要港口区位优势度评估.地球信息科学学报,2018,20(5):613-622.
	MOU N, LIAO M, ZHANG H,et al. Evaluation on location advantages of the ports along the Maritime Silk Road. Journal of Geo-information Science,2018,20(5):613-622.
29	中国一带一路网. «"一带一路"建设海上合作设想».(2017-06-20)[2022-06-17]..
	Belt and Road Portal. Vision for maritime cooperation under the Belt and Road Initiative.(2017-06-20)[2022-06-17]..
30	姚峪岩,张翼飞,金紫洋,等. "一带一路"绿色贸易合作与竞争格局研究. 世界地理研究, 2021, 30(4): 792-801.
	YAO Y, ZHANG Y, JIN Z,et al.Study on the green trade cooperation and competition pattern of the "Belt and Road".World Regional Studies,2021,30(4): 792-801.
31	袁丽华,陈小强,宋长青,等. 环印度洋区域国家地缘经济格局分析. 地理学报, 2021, 76(4): 955-972.
	YUAN L, CHEN X, SONG C, al el. Spatio-temporal patterns of geo-economics of the countries in the Indian Ocean Region:Based on merchandise trade volume data from 1992 to 2017. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2021, 76(4): 955-972.
32	HIDALGO C, HAUSMANN R. The building blocks of economic complexity. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 2009, 106(26): 10570-10575.
33	HAUSMANN R, HIDALGO C. The network structure of economic output. Journal of Economic Growth, 2011, 16(4): 309-342.
34	WANG Y, SONG C, SIGLEY G,et al. Using social networks to analyze the spatiotemporal patterns of the rolling stock manufacturing industry for countries in the Belt and Road Initiative. Isprs International Journal of Geo-information, 2020, 9(7): 431.
35	陈小强,袁丽华,宋长青,等. 人文地理研究中时间阶段划分的量化工具与应用. 经济地理, 2021, 41(1): 21-29.
	CHEN X, YUAN L, SONG C,et al. Quantitative tools and applications of time stages division in human geography research. Economic Geography, 2021, 41(1): 21-29.
36	张彬.中美双边货物贸易互补性的演变与分析——基于1991-2011年数据的分析.国际贸易问题,2013(12):58-67.
	ZHANG B. Evolution and analysis of complementarity in China-US bilateral goods trade: A study based on 1991-2011 data. Journal of International Trade,2013(12):58-67.
37	原帼力,帕丽哈扎提·阿不拉.我国与"一带一路"沿线国家农产品贸易格局及竞合关系研究.商业经济研究,2021(22):137-140.
	YUAN G, ABULA P. Research on the trade pattern and competition and cooperation relationship of agricultural products between my country and the countries along the "Belt and Road".Journal of Commercial Economics, 2021(22): 137-140.
38	曹俊文,申婧怡.双循环格局下中国出口绿色贸易水平测度及影响因素分析.当代财经,2022(4):100-110.
	CAO J, SHEN J. Measurement of China's export green trade level and analysis of the influencing factors under the dual circulation pattern. Contemporary Finance & Economics,2022(4):100-110.

编码1	编码2	产品简介
44	441872	竹及竹制品
84	840290、840410、840420、840490、840690、841182、841199、841290、841780、841790、841919、841939、841960、841989、841990、842121、842129、842139、842199、847420、847982、847989、847990	锅炉、机器、械器具及其零件
85	850164、850231、850239、850300、850490、851410、851420、851430、851490、854140、854390	电机、电气设备及其零件
90	901380、901390、901580、902610、902620、902680、902690、902710、902720、902730、902750、902780、902790、903149、903180、903190、903289、903290、903300	光学、计量、检验仪器设备、精密仪器设备及其零部件、附件

编码1	编码2	产品简介
44	441872	竹及竹制品
84	840290、840410、840420、840490、840690、841182、841199、841290、841780、841790、841919、841939、841960、841989、841990、842121、842129、842139、842199、847420、847982、847989、847990	锅炉、机器、械器具及其零件
85	850164、850231、850239、850300、850490、851410、851420、851430、851490、854140、854390	电机、电气设备及其零件
90	901380、901390、901580、902610、902620、902680、902690、902710、902720、902730、902750、902780、902790、903149、903180、903190、903289、903290、903300	光学、计量、检验仪器设备、精密仪器设备及其零部件、附件

系数	第一阶段	第二阶段	第三阶段	第四阶段
中国绿色贸易TC系数	－0.413 3	－0.334 6	－0.070 1	0.050 2
其他“海丝”沿线国家绿色贸易TC系数	－0.296 5	－0.157 5	－0.103 1	－0.069 6
差值	－0.116 8	－0.177 1	0.033 0	0.119 8

系数	第一阶段	第二阶段	第三阶段	第四阶段
中国绿色贸易TC系数	－0.413 3	－0.334 6	－0.070 1	0.050 2
其他“海丝”沿线国家绿色贸易TC系数	－0.296 5	－0.157 5	－0.103 1	－0.069 6
差值	－0.116 8	－0.177 1	0.033 0	0.119 8

分类	排名	第一阶段	第二阶段	第三阶段	第四阶段
相对竞争优势	1	0.853 8（土耳其）	0.811 1（斯里兰卡）	0.624 0（泰国）	0.865 2（阿联酋）
	2	0.400 2（印度）	0.736 7（印度）	0.443 5（马来西亚）	0.826 8（沙特阿拉伯）
	3	0.276 1（希腊）	0.624 4（希腊）	0.383 7（意大利）	0.809 0（巴林）
相对竞争劣势	1	－0.809 2（意大利）	－0.738 0（韩国）	－0.713 0（韩国）	－0.598 0（韩国）
	2	－0.519 8（菲律宾）	－0.539 4（意大利）	－0.224 3（新加坡）	－0.255 2（新加坡）
	3	－0.463 8（韩国）	－0.441 2（菲律宾）	－0.203 1（菲律宾）	－0.106 5（意大利）