World Regional Studies ›› 2020, Vol. 29 ›› Issue (2): 296-306.DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1004-9479.2020.02.2018417
Previous Articles Next Articles
Chenran XIONG1,2(), Limao WANG1,2(), Qiushi QU1,2, Ning XIANG1,2, Bo WANG1,2
Received:
2019-01-11
Revised:
2019-02-28
Online:
2020-03-30
Published:
2020-03-27
Contact:
Limao WANG
熊琛然1,2(), 王礼茂1,2(), 屈秋实1,2, 向宁1,2, 王博1,2
通讯作者:
王礼茂
作者简介:
熊琛然(1985-),男,博士研究生,主要从事能源经济与地缘政治研究,E-mail: xiongcr.17b@igsnrr.ac.cn。
基金资助:
Chenran XIONG, Limao WANG, Qiushi QU, Ning XIANG, Bo WANG. Paradigms between geopolitics and geoeconomics: Controversy or integration[J]. World Regional Studies, 2020, 29(2): 296-306.
熊琛然, 王礼茂, 屈秋实, 向宁, 王博. 地理学之地缘政治学与地缘经济学:学科之争抑或学科融合?[J]. 世界地理研究, 2020, 29(2): 296-306.
Add to citation manager EndNote|Ris|BibTeX
URL: https://sjdlyj.ecnu.edu.cn/EN/10.3969/j.issn.1004-9479.2020.02.2018417
发展阶段 | 代表人物 | 理论反映 |
---|---|---|
帝国主义地缘政治学 | 拉采尔(Friedrich Ratzel) | 国家有机体论(National Organism) |
马汉(Alfred Mahan) | 海权论(Seapower) | |
麦金德(Halford Mackinder) | 陆权论(Landpower) | |
豪斯霍弗尔(Karl Haushofer) | 生存空间论(Lebensraum) | |
斯皮克曼(Nicholas Spykman) | 边缘地带论(Rimland) | |
冷战地缘政治学 | 坎南(George Kennan) | 遏制理论(Containment) |
格雷汉姆(Daniel O Graham) | 高边境论(High Frontier) | |
基辛格(Henry Kissinger) | 均势论(Balance of Power) | |
新世界秩序地缘政治学 | 布热津斯基(Zbigniew K. Brzezinski) | 大棋局论(The Grand Chessboard) |
亨廷顿(Smuel Huntington) | 文明冲突论(Clash of Civilization) | |
卡普兰(Robert Kaplan) | 乱世将临论(Coming Anarchy) | |
环境地缘政治学 | 霍默—狄克逊(Thomas Homer—Dixon) | 环境稀缺论(Environmental Scarcity) |
伦纳(Michael Renner) | 环境安全论(Environmental Security) | |
戈尔(Al Gore) | 战略环境论(Strategic Environmental Initiative) |
Tab.1 The development of western geopolitics
发展阶段 | 代表人物 | 理论反映 |
---|---|---|
帝国主义地缘政治学 | 拉采尔(Friedrich Ratzel) | 国家有机体论(National Organism) |
马汉(Alfred Mahan) | 海权论(Seapower) | |
麦金德(Halford Mackinder) | 陆权论(Landpower) | |
豪斯霍弗尔(Karl Haushofer) | 生存空间论(Lebensraum) | |
斯皮克曼(Nicholas Spykman) | 边缘地带论(Rimland) | |
冷战地缘政治学 | 坎南(George Kennan) | 遏制理论(Containment) |
格雷汉姆(Daniel O Graham) | 高边境论(High Frontier) | |
基辛格(Henry Kissinger) | 均势论(Balance of Power) | |
新世界秩序地缘政治学 | 布热津斯基(Zbigniew K. Brzezinski) | 大棋局论(The Grand Chessboard) |
亨廷顿(Smuel Huntington) | 文明冲突论(Clash of Civilization) | |
卡普兰(Robert Kaplan) | 乱世将临论(Coming Anarchy) | |
环境地缘政治学 | 霍默—狄克逊(Thomas Homer—Dixon) | 环境稀缺论(Environmental Scarcity) |
伦纳(Michael Renner) | 环境安全论(Environmental Security) | |
戈尔(Al Gore) | 战略环境论(Strategic Environmental Initiative) |
学派 | 学派思想 | 代表人物 |
---|---|---|
美国学派 | 市场控制与经济竞争 | 爱德华•卢特沃克(Edward N. Luttwak),理查德•索罗门(Richard H. Solomn),亨利•诺(Henry R.Nau),麦肯利•肯维(Mackinley Conway)等 |
意大利 学派 | 国际竞争与经济合作 | 保罗•萨翁纳(Paul Savanna),卡尔罗•让(Carlo Jean),谢尔兆•菲奥热(Cherao Fejaore)等 |
俄罗斯 学派 | 经济合作与国家战略结合 | A·涅克列萨(А•И•Неклесса),Э•科切托夫(Э•Г•Кочетов)等 |
Tab.2 Three schools in geo-economics
学派 | 学派思想 | 代表人物 |
---|---|---|
美国学派 | 市场控制与经济竞争 | 爱德华•卢特沃克(Edward N. Luttwak),理查德•索罗门(Richard H. Solomn),亨利•诺(Henry R.Nau),麦肯利•肯维(Mackinley Conway)等 |
意大利 学派 | 国际竞争与经济合作 | 保罗•萨翁纳(Paul Savanna),卡尔罗•让(Carlo Jean),谢尔兆•菲奥热(Cherao Fejaore)等 |
俄罗斯 学派 | 经济合作与国家战略结合 | A·涅克列萨(А•И•Неклесса),Э•科切托夫(Э•Г•Кочетов)等 |
1 | [英]杰弗里•帕克.地缘政治学:过去、现在和未来. 刘从德,译. 北京:新华出版社, 2003.[Parker G. Geopolitics: Past, present and future. Translated by Liu Congde. Beijing: Xinhua Pubilishing Huose,2003. |
2 | Luttwak E N. From geopolitics to geo-economics: logic of conflict, grammar of commerce. National Interest,Summer, 1990: 17-19. |
3 | 洪菊花,骆华松. 地缘政治与地缘经济之争及中国地缘战略方向. 经济地理,2015,35(12):26-35. |
Hong J,Luo H. Controversy between geopolitics and geoeconomics and it's enlightenment on China's Geostrategic Direction. Economic Geography,2015, 35(12): 26-35. | |
4 | Tuathail J G O, Dalby S, Routledge P. Geopolitics reader. London and New York: Routledge, 1998. |
5 | Agnew J, Mitchell K, Tuathail G O. A companion to political geography. Landon: Blackwell Publishing,2006. |
6 | Cohen S. Geopolitics:The geography of international relations(2ed). Lanham, Md. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers,2009. |
7 | 倪世雄. 当代西方国际关系理论. 上海:复旦大学出版社,2001:400. |
Ni S. Contemporary western theory of international relations. Shanghai: Fudan Press,2001:400. | |
8 | Vihma A. Geo-economics defined and redefined. Geopolitics, 2018,23(1): 47-49. |
9 | Csurgai G. The increasing importance of geo-economics in power rivalries in the Twenty-First Century. Geopolitics, 2018,23(1):38-46. |
10 | Kuhn T S. The structure of scientific revolutions. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1996. |
11 | 约瑟夫•S•奈,约翰•D•唐纳胡. 全球化世界的治理. 王勇,门洪华,王荣军,等,译. 北京:世界知识出版社,2003. |
Nye J S, Donahu J D.Governance in a globalizing world. Translated by Wang Y, Men H, Wang R,et al. Beijing: World Affairs Press,2003. | |
12 | 李敦瑞. 地缘经济学的理论流派与发展趋向. 中南财经政法大学学报,2009(1):26-29. |
Li D. Theoretical schools and development trend of geo-economics. Journal of ZhongNan University of Economic and Law. 2009(1):26-29. | |
13 | Blackwill R D, Harris Jennifer M.. War by other means: Geoeconomics and statecraft. Massachusetts: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press,2016. |
14 | Э.Г.科切托夫.世界跨文明和谐与地缘经济学范式.上海财经大学学报,2007,9(5):3-10. |
Kochetov E G. Geoeconomics paradigm: new global geoeconomy and cross-civilized stage in harmonious world. Journal of Shanghai University of Finance and Economic,2007, 9(5): 3- 10. | |
15 | Cowen D,Smith Neil. After geopolitics? from the geopolitical social to geoeconomics. Antipode, 2009,41(1):22- 48. |
16 | 张丽君. 地缘政治让位于地缘经济. 经济地理,2001,21(S1):33 - 38. |
Zhang L. Geopolitics gives way to geoeconomis.Economic Geography,2001,21(S1):33-38. | |
17 | 李正,陈才,熊理然. 欧美地缘经济理论发展脉络及其内涵特征探析. 世界地理研究,2014,23(1):10-18. |
Li Z, Chen C, Xiong L. An analysis on the theory origin and development vein of geo-economics Abroad. World Regional Studies,2014,23(1):10-18. | |
18 | 刘雪莲,徐立恒.当代地缘政治学研究的新视域与新动向.山东社会科学,2011(1): 134-137. |
Liu X, Xu L. The new sight and trend of contemporary geopolitics. Shandong Social Sience,2011(1):134-137. | |
19 | 刘从德.地缘政治学导论.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2010:236-241. |
Liu C. An Introduction to geopolitics. Beijing: China RenMin University Press,2010:236-241. | |
20 | 陆大道,杜德斌.关于加强地缘政治地缘经济研究的思考.地理学报,2013,68(6):723-727. |
Lu D, Du D. Some thoughts on the strengthening of geopolitical and geo-economic studies. Acta Geographica Sinica,2013,6(6):723-727. | |
21 | Rozov N S. Geopolitics,geoeconomics, and geoculture:the interrelation of dynamic spheres in the history of Russia. Russian Social Science Review,2012,53(6):4-26. |
22 | 多米尼克•莫伊西.情感地缘政治学. 姚芸竹,译. 北京:新华出版社,2010:6. |
Moisi D.The geopolitics of emotion. Translated by Yao Y.Beijing: Xinhua Publishing Huose,2010:6. | |
23 | Sparke M.Geopolitical Fears, Geoeconomic hopes and the responsibilities of geography. Annals of the Association of American Geographers,2007,97(2):338- 349. |
24 | 周骁男. 地缘政治与地缘经济的研究路径比较. 长春工业大学学报:社会科学版,2005,17(4):39-41. |
Zhou X. Comparison on geopolitics and geoeconomics. Journal of Changchun University of Technology:Social Sciences Edition,2005,17(5):39-41. | |
25 | Mercille J.The radical geopolitics of US foreign policy: Geopolitical and Geoeconomic logics of power. Political Geography,2008( 27):570-586. |
26 | Cohen S B. Geopolitical realities and United States foreign policy. Political Geography, 2003(22):1–33. |
27 | 陈才. 地缘关系与世界经济地理学科建设. 世界地理研究,2001,10(3):1-7. |
Chen C. Geo- relation and course construction of World Economic Geography. World Regional Studies, 2001, 10(3):1-7. | |
28 | 王铮,胡敏,王宇,等. 新地缘政治经济结构进化与治理. 北京:科学出版社,2017. |
Wang Z, Hu M, Wang Y. Xin diyuan zhengzhi jingji jiegou yu zhili. Beijing: Science Press, 2017. | |
29 | 张起.国际政治哲学. 北京:社会科学文献出版社,2015. |
Zhang Q. Philosophy of international Politics. Beijing: Social Sciences Academic Press,2015. | |
30 | 鲁德拉•希尔,彼得•卡赞斯坦. 超越范式:世界政治研究中的分析折中主义. 秦亚青,季玲,译. 上海:上海世纪出版集团,2012:15. |
Sil R, Katzenstein P J. Beyond Paradigms: Analytic eclecticism in the study of world politics. Translated by Qin Y, Ji L. Shanghai: Shanghai Century Publishing(Group). | |
31 | 陈才. 区域经济地理学. 北京:科学出版社,2009. |
Chen C.Regional economic geography. Beijing: Science Press,2009. | |
32 | 文云朝.关于地缘研究的理论探讨.地理科学进展,1999,18(2):172-175. |
Wen Y. An theoretical study about the geopolitical research. Progress in Geography,1999,1(2):172- 175. | |
33 | [英]杰弗里•帕克.二十世纪的西方地理政治思想.李亦呜,等,译.北京:解放军出版社,1992:2.[Parker G. Western geopolitical thoughts in the 20th Century. Translated by Li Y. Beijing: Chinese People's Liberation Army Publishing House,1992:2.] |
34 | 周骁男,陈才. 论地缘政治与地缘经济的研究范式. 东北师大学报:哲学社会科学版,2007(2):76- 80. |
Zhou Xiaonan, Chen Cai. On the standard research paradigm of geopolitics and geo-economics.Journal of Northeast Normal University:Philosophy and Social Sciences, 2007(2):76-0. | |
35 | [英]麦金德.历史的地理枢纽. 林尔蔚,陈江,译. 北京:商务印书馆,1985.[Mackinder H J. Geographical pivot of history. Translated by Lin E,Chen J. Beijing: The Commercial Press,195.] |
36 | [美]兹比格纽•布热津斯基.大棋局:美国的首要地位及其地缘战略.中国国际问题研究所,译.上海:上海人民出版社,1998. [Brzezinski Z. The Grand Chessboard: American Primacy and its Geostrategy. Translated by China Institute of International Studies. Shanghai: Shanghai Renmin Press,1998.] |
37 | Erdmann A P N. A New Era of Geo-economics: Assessing the interplay of economic and political risk. IISS Seminar23-25 March, 2012. |
38 | Global Agenda Councils.Geo-economics seven challenges to globalization, World Economic Forum, Jan.2015. |
39 | 苏东辉,骆华松,蔡定昆. 区外大国与东南亚地缘经济关系测度分析.世界地理研究,2013,22(1):1-11. |
Su D,Luo H, Cai D. Analysis of geo-economic relationships between the region of Southeast Asia and major outside countries. World Regional Studies, 2013,22(1):1-11. | |
40 | Antoniades A. The new resilience of emerging and developing countries: systemic interlocking, currency swaps and geoeconomics. Global Policy,2017,8(2):170-180. |
41 | 胡瑞华. 试析冷战后美俄地缘政治空间竞争.人文地理,2010(5):108-111. |
Hu R.The Post-Cold War American-Russian relations from the geopolitical perspective.Human Geography, 2010(5):108-111. | |
42 | 葛汉文. 批判地缘政治学的发展与地缘政治研究的未来. 国际观察,2010(4):42-48. |
Ge H. Development of critical geopolitics and the future of geopolitical Study. International Review,2010(4):42-48. | |
43 | Kaplan R D. The geography of Chinese power: How far will China reach Land and at Sea?. Foreign Affairs,2010,89(3):22-41. |
44 | Thurow L. Head to Head:The Coming Economic Battle Among Japan, Europe and America. New York: Morrow Publishers, 1992:246. |
45 | [美]亨利•基辛格. 大外交. 海口:海南出版社,2012.[ Kissinger H.The Diplomacy.Haikou: Hainan Press,2012.] |
46 | Mearsheimer J J. Back to the future: instability in Europe after the Cold War. International Security, 1990, 15(1):5-56. |
Viewed | ||||||
Full text |
|
|||||
Abstract |
|
|||||