

World Regional Studies ›› 2025, Vol. 34 ›› Issue (9): 186-198.DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1004-9479.2025.09.20230820
Received:2023-12-01
Revised:2024-04-10
Online:2025-09-15
Published:2025-09-30
Contact:
Yushan DUAN
通讯作者:
段玉山
作者简介:艾昕(1995—),女,博士,研究方向为地理课程与教学论,E-mail:aixinbs@163.com。
Xin AI, Yushan DUAN. Perspectives and values of place-based geography education[J]. World Regional Studies, 2025, 34(9): 186-198.
艾昕, 段玉山. 在地化地理教育的启示与价值[J]. 世界地理研究, 2025, 34(9): 186-198.
| 国家/区域(发文量) | 学科主题形式(发文量) | 预期学习成果(发文量) |
|---|---|---|
| 美国(43) | 地理科学(12)、生态与环境(18)、所有学科(5)、跨学科或项目式学习(8) | 学术成就(10)、社区意识(2)、社会正义(12)、可持续发展(4)、环境意识(5)、科学素养(4)、批判性思维(1)、对地方或社区的积极态度(4)、去殖民化(1) |
| 澳大利亚(19) | 地理科学(8)、生态与环境(4)、所有学科(2)、跨学科或项目式学习(4)、环境艺术(1) | 学术成就(1)、社区意识(1)、社会正义(6)、可持续发展(1)、科学素养(3)、批判性思维(1)、对地方或社区的积极态度(3)、去殖民化(3) |
| 英国(8) | 地理科学(2)、生态与环境(2)、所有学科(1)、跨学科或项目式学习(2)、文化与历史(1) | 学术成就(1)、社区意识(4)、 社会正义(2)、去殖民化(1) |
| 芬兰(4) | 地理科学(1)、生态与环境(3) | 学术成就(1)、社区意识(2)、社会正义(1) |
| 加拿大(3) | 地理科学(1)、生态与环境(2) | 可持续发展(1)、环境意识(1)、对地方或社区的积极态度(1) |
| 德国(3) | 地理科学(1)、生态与环境(2) | 学术成就(1)、可持续发展(1)、对地方或社区的积极态度(1) |
| 瑞典(3) | 生态与环境(2)、所有学科(1) | 学术成就(1)、环境意识(1)、对地方或社区的积极态度(1) |
| 新西兰(3) | 生态与环境(2)、跨学科或项目式学习(1) | 社区意识(1)、社会正义(1)、可持续发展(1) |
| 荷兰(2) | 地理科学(2) | 学术成就(1)、可持续发展(1) |
| 意大利(2) | 生态与环境(1)、跨学科或项目式学习(1) | 可持续发展(2) |
| 西班牙(2) | 所有学科(1)、跨学科或项目式学习(1) | 社区意识(1)、可持续发展(1) |
| 墨西哥(2) | 生态与环境(2) | 社区意识(1)、社会正义(1) |
| 南非(2) | 生态与环境(2) | 社会正义(1)、可持续发展(1) |
| 其他(21) | 地理科学(11)、生态与环境(5)、所有学科(1)、跨学科或项目式学习(2)、环境艺术(2) | 学术成就(5)、社区意识(5)、社会正义(1)、可持续发展(4)、环境意识(1)、去殖民化(1)、对地方或社区的积极态度(4) |
Tab.1 Country/region, disciplinary themes, and expected learning outcomes in contextualized geography education research
| 国家/区域(发文量) | 学科主题形式(发文量) | 预期学习成果(发文量) |
|---|---|---|
| 美国(43) | 地理科学(12)、生态与环境(18)、所有学科(5)、跨学科或项目式学习(8) | 学术成就(10)、社区意识(2)、社会正义(12)、可持续发展(4)、环境意识(5)、科学素养(4)、批判性思维(1)、对地方或社区的积极态度(4)、去殖民化(1) |
| 澳大利亚(19) | 地理科学(8)、生态与环境(4)、所有学科(2)、跨学科或项目式学习(4)、环境艺术(1) | 学术成就(1)、社区意识(1)、社会正义(6)、可持续发展(1)、科学素养(3)、批判性思维(1)、对地方或社区的积极态度(3)、去殖民化(3) |
| 英国(8) | 地理科学(2)、生态与环境(2)、所有学科(1)、跨学科或项目式学习(2)、文化与历史(1) | 学术成就(1)、社区意识(4)、 社会正义(2)、去殖民化(1) |
| 芬兰(4) | 地理科学(1)、生态与环境(3) | 学术成就(1)、社区意识(2)、社会正义(1) |
| 加拿大(3) | 地理科学(1)、生态与环境(2) | 可持续发展(1)、环境意识(1)、对地方或社区的积极态度(1) |
| 德国(3) | 地理科学(1)、生态与环境(2) | 学术成就(1)、可持续发展(1)、对地方或社区的积极态度(1) |
| 瑞典(3) | 生态与环境(2)、所有学科(1) | 学术成就(1)、环境意识(1)、对地方或社区的积极态度(1) |
| 新西兰(3) | 生态与环境(2)、跨学科或项目式学习(1) | 社区意识(1)、社会正义(1)、可持续发展(1) |
| 荷兰(2) | 地理科学(2) | 学术成就(1)、可持续发展(1) |
| 意大利(2) | 生态与环境(1)、跨学科或项目式学习(1) | 可持续发展(2) |
| 西班牙(2) | 所有学科(1)、跨学科或项目式学习(1) | 社区意识(1)、可持续发展(1) |
| 墨西哥(2) | 生态与环境(2) | 社区意识(1)、社会正义(1) |
| 南非(2) | 生态与环境(2) | 社会正义(1)、可持续发展(1) |
| 其他(21) | 地理科学(11)、生态与环境(5)、所有学科(1)、跨学科或项目式学习(2)、环境艺术(2) | 学术成就(5)、社区意识(5)、社会正义(1)、可持续发展(4)、环境意识(1)、去殖民化(1)、对地方或社区的积极态度(4) |
| 地方感维度 | 国家/区域(发文量) |
|---|---|
| 生态自然维度 | 美国(22)、澳大利亚(3)、芬兰(1)、加拿大(2)、荷兰(1)、意大利(1)、西班牙(1)、瑞典(2)、新西兰(1)、墨西哥(1)、南非(2)、其他国家或无具体国家(12) |
| 政治经济与社会文化维度 | 美国(15)、澳大利亚(13)、英国(6)、德国(1)、芬兰(2)、加拿大(1)、意大利(1)、西班牙(1)、新西兰(2)、墨西哥(1)、其他国家或无具体国家(6) |
| 心理维度 | 美国(6)、澳大利亚(3)、英国(2)、德国(2)、芬兰(1)、荷兰(1)、瑞典(1)、其他国家或无具体国家(3) |
Tab 2 Analysis of contextualized geography education research based on the dimension of sense of place
| 地方感维度 | 国家/区域(发文量) |
|---|---|
| 生态自然维度 | 美国(22)、澳大利亚(3)、芬兰(1)、加拿大(2)、荷兰(1)、意大利(1)、西班牙(1)、瑞典(2)、新西兰(1)、墨西哥(1)、南非(2)、其他国家或无具体国家(12) |
| 政治经济与社会文化维度 | 美国(15)、澳大利亚(13)、英国(6)、德国(1)、芬兰(2)、加拿大(1)、意大利(1)、西班牙(1)、新西兰(2)、墨西哥(1)、其他国家或无具体国家(6) |
| 心理维度 | 美国(6)、澳大利亚(3)、英国(2)、德国(2)、芬兰(1)、荷兰(1)、瑞典(1)、其他国家或无具体国家(3) |
| [1] | KROPOTKIN P. What geography ought to be. The Nineteenth Century,1885(18):940-956. |
| [2] | BAILEY L. The Nature-study Idea: An Interpretation of the New School-Movement to Put the Young into Relation and Sympathy with Nature. New York:Macmillan Company,1911. |
| [3] | CARSON R. The sense of wonder. New York:Harper & Row,1965. |
| [4] | 中华人民共和国教育部.普通高中地理课程标准(2017年版2020年修订). 北京:人民教育出版社,2020. |
| Ministry of Education of the People's Republic of China. Geography Curriculum Standards for Regular Senior Secondary Schools (2017 Edition, Revised in 2020). Beijing: People's Education Press, 2020. | |
| [5] | SALTER C. The geographic imperative. Journal of Geography,1995,94 (4):471-477. |
| [6] | SEAMON D. A Geography of the Lifeworld: Movement, Rest, and Encounter. New York: Routledge,1979. |
| [7] | 王小禹,袁孝亭. 国外地理课程标准课程目标的特征与趋势. 外国中小学教育,2012(3):54-60. |
| WANG X, YUAN X. Characteristics and trends of geography curriculum objects in foreign countries. Primary & Secondary Schooling Abroad,2012(3):54-60. | |
| [8] | 冯以浤. 地理教育国际宪章.地理学报,1993(4):289-296. |
| FENG Y. International charter on geographical education. Acta Geographica Sinica,1993(4):289-296. | |
| [9] | 张建珍,段玉山,龚倩. 2016地理教育国际宪章.地理教学,2017(19):4-6. |
| ZHANG J, DUAN Y, GONG Q. 2016 International charter on geographical education. Geography Teaching,2017(19):4-6. | |
| [10] | 龚倩,段玉山,蒋连飞, 等.英国地理课程中的"知识转向".全球教育展望,2018,47(7):57-65. |
| GONG Q, DUAN Y, JIANG L, et al. The "knowledge turn" of national geography curriculum in England.Global Education,2018,47(7):57-65. | |
| [11] | Department for education. The Education (National Curriculum) (Attainment Targets and Programme of Study in Geography in respect of the Third Key Stage) (England) Order 2008. (2008-08-01) [2023-12-03]. . |
| [12] | Department for education. Geography programmes of study: key stage 3. (2013-09-11) [2023-12-03]. . |
| [13] | BEDNARZ S. Geography for Life: National Geography Standards. Washington DC: National Geographic Research and Exploration,1994. |
| [14] | RUTHERFORD D.Reading the road map for 21st century education in the United States.Geography,2015,100 (1):28-35. |
| [15] | ZHU L, PAN X, GAO G. Assessing place location knowledge using a virtual globe. Journal of Geography,2016,115 (2):72-80. |
| [16] | MATTHEWS M. Making Sense of Place: Children's Understanding of Large-Scale Environments. London: Harvester Wheatsheaf,1992. |
| [17] | GILLESPIE C. How culture constructs our sense of neighborhood: Mental maps and children's perceptions of place. Journal of Geography.2010,109 (1):18-29. |
| [18] | 孔翔,苗长松. 空间的文化解读与转型期中国的和谐发展. 世界地理研究,2011,20(2):154-161. |
| KONG X, MIAO C. Cultural interpretation of space and the harmonious development of China in trasition.World Regional Studies, 2011,20(2):154-161. | |
| [19] | LEWIS P. The monument and the bungalow. The Geographical Review,1999,88(4):507-527. |
| [20] | GREEN M. Transformational design literacies: Children as active place-makers. Children's Geographies, 2014,12(2):189-204. |
| [21] | DEWEY J. The Child and the Curriculum. Chicago:University of Chicago Press,1910. |
| [22] | TAYLOR P. Places, spaces and Macy's: Place-space tension in the political geography of modernities. Progress in Human Geography,1999, 23(1):7-26. |
| [23] | CASTELLS M. The Rise of the Network Society. Oxford:Brasil Blackwell,1996. |
| [24] | MASSEY D. Power-geometry and a Progressive Sense of Place. Mapping the futures, London:Routledge,1993. |
| [25] | GETTING S. What is place-based education and why does it matter.Getting Smart in Partnership with Edulnnovation and Tenton Science Schools,2017:1-19. |
| [26] | SOBEL D. Place-Based Education. Massachusetts:The Orion Society,2005. |
| [27] | SMITH G. Place-based education: Learning to be where we are. Phi Delta Kappan,2022,83(8):584-594. |
| [28] | ORR D. Ecological Literacy: Education and the Transition to a Postmodern World. New York:State University of New York Press,1992. |
| [29] | THEOBALD P. Teaching the Commons: Place, Pride, and the Renewal of Community. Colorado:Westview Press,1997. |
| [30] | GRUENEWALD D, SMITH G. Place-based education in the global age: Local diversity. London:Routledge, 2014. |
| [31] | SMITH G, SOBEL D. Place- and Community-based Education in Schools. New York:Routledge,2010. |
| [32] | McINERNEY P, SMYTH J, DOWN B. 'Coming to a place near you?' The politics and possibilities of a critical pedagogy of place-based education. Asia-Pacific Journal of Teacher Education,2011,39(1):3-16. |
| [33] | BEAMES S. ROSS H. Journeys outside the classroom. Journal of Adventure Education & Outdoor Learning, 2010,10(2):95-109. |
| [34] | GRUENEWALD D. Accountability and collaboration: Institutional barriers and strategic pathways for place-based education. Ethics, Place and Environment,2005,8(3):261-283. |
| [35] | MARSHALL-CORNWALL J, WOOLDRIDGE S. Geography in education. The Geographical Journal,1995,121(2):190–196. |
| [36] | FIEN J. Towards a map of commitment: A socially critical approach to geographical education. International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education,1999,8(2):140-158. |
| [37] | RUSSO R. Social justice as general education. Journal of Geography,2004,103(3):102-110. |
| [38] | BOIVIN J. Farm-to-table: How one teacher fostered passionate, project-based, place-based learning. Journal of Sustainability Education,2020,24(1). |
| [39] | AMBROSINO C, RIVERA M. Using ethological techniques and place-based pedagogy to develop science literacy in Hawaiʻi's high school students. Journal of Biological Education,2022,56(1):3-13. |
| [40] | HURSH D, HENDERSON J, GREENWOOD D. Environmental education in a neoliberal climate. Environmental Education Research,2015,21(3):299-318. |
| [41] | WOOLTORTON S, WHITE P, PALMER M, et al. Learning cycles: Enriching ways of knowing place. Australian Journal of Environmental Education. 2021,37(1):1-18. |
| [42] | REIHANA K, WEHI P, HARCOURT N, et al. Indigenisation of conservation education in New Zealand. Pacific Conservation Biology,2021,27(4):493-504. |
| [43] | ARDOIN N. Toward an interdisciplinary understanding of place: Lessons for environmental education. Canadian Journal of Environmental Education,2006,11(1):112-126. |
| [44] | ARDOIN N, SCHUH J, GOULD R. Exploring the dimensions of place: A confirmatory factor analysis of data from three ecoregional sites. Environmental Education Research,2012,18(5):583-607. |
| [45] | LECKEY E, LITTRELL M, OKOCHI C, et al. Exploring local environmental change through filmmaking: The lentes en cambio climático program. The Journal of Environmental Education,2021,52(4):207-222. |
| [46] | WOOLTORTON S, COLLARD L, HORWITZ P, et al. Sharing a place-based indigenous methodology and learnings. Environmental Education Research,2020,26(7):917-934. |
| [47] | RIGGS C, LEE D. Assessing educator perceptions of garden-based learning in K-12 science education. The American Biology Teacher,2022,84(4):213-218. |
| [48] | DANN S L, SCHROEDER B. Developing great lakes literacy and stewardship through a nonformal science education camp. Journal of Contemporary Water Research & Education,2015,156(1):21-36. |
| [49] | DALE R, POWELL R, STERN M, et al. Influence of the natural setting on environmental education outcomes. Environmental Education Research,2020,26(5):613-631. |
| [50] | AMBROSINO C, RIVERA M. Using ethological techniques and place-based pedagogy to develop science literacy in Hawaiʻi's high school students. Journal of Biological Education,2022,56(1):3-13. |
| [51] | WALLIS L, HORNBLOW M, SMIT N, et al. From little things, big things grow: Building connections through place‐based education in the Tasmanian midlands biodiversity hotspot. Ecological Management & Restoration,2021(22):152-163. |
| [52] | HOUGHAM R, EITEL K C, MILLER B. Technology-enriched STEM investigations of place: Using technology to extend the senses and build connections to and between places in science education. Journal of Geoscience Education,2015,63(2):90-97. |
| [53] | FAVIER T, VAN GORP B, CYVIN J, et al. Learning to teach climate change: Students in teacher training and their progression in pedagogical content knowledge. Journal of Geography in Higher Education,2021,45(4):594-620. |
| [54] | GALLAY E, FURLAN BRIGHENTE M, et al. Place‐based civic science—collective environmental action and solidarity for eco‐resilience. Child and Adolescent Mental Health,2022,27(1):39-46. |
| [55] | FAGERHOLM N, EILOLA S, et al. Place-based landscape services and potential of participatory spatial planning in multifunctional rural landscapes in Southern highlands, Tanzania. Landscape Ecology,2019(34):1769-1787. |
| [56] | SMITH G A. Place-based education: Breaking through the constraining regularities of public school. Environmental Education Research,2007,13(2):189-207. |
| [57] | MURNI S, CHIANG C, HURIT A AU. Impact of a place-based education curriculum on indigenous teacher and students. International Journal of Instruction, 2018,11(1):311-328. |
| [58] | GRANIT-DGANI D. Paths to Place-based Education. Hebrew:The Mofet Institute,2021. |
| [59] | POWELL D. Childhood obesity, corporate philanthropy and the creeping privatisation of health education. Critical Public Health,2014,24(2):226-238. |
| [60] | LIEBERMAN G, HOODY L. Closing the Achievement Gap: Using the Environment as an Integrating Context for Learning. London:Science Wizards,1998. |
| [61] | GRUENEWALD D. Foundations of place: A multidisciplinary framework for place-conscious education. American Educational Research Journal,2003,40(3):619-654. |
| [62] | MILLER D, TWUM S. The experiences of selected teachers in implementing place-based education. Education,2017,23(1):92-108. |
| [63] | GRUENEWALD D A. The best of both worlds: A critical pedagogy of place. Educational Researcher,2023, 32(4):3-12. |
| [64] | SEMKEN S, FREEMAN C. Sense of place in the practice and assessment of place‐based science teaching. Science Education,2008,92(6):1042-1057. |
| [65] | LARSEN T, HARRINGTON JR. Developing a learning progression for place. Journal of Geography,2018,117(3):100-118. |
| [66] | CASTREE N, FULLER D, LAMBERT D. Geography without Borders. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers,2007, 32(2):129-132. |
| [67] | 马倩怡,段玉山,吴蓉. 国外儿童地理学研究进展与启示. 世界地理研究,2022,31(1):177-188. |
| MA Q, DUAN Y, WU R. A review and prospect of international studies of children's geographies.World Regional Studies,2022,31(1):177-188. | |
| [68] | WAITE S. Knowing your place in the world': How place and culture support and obstruct educational aims. Cambridge Journal of Education,2013,43(4):413–433. |
| [69] | RIZVI F. Towards cosmopolitan learning. Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education,2009,3(1):253–256. |
| [70] | WATTCHOW B, BROWN M. A Pedagogy of Place: Outdoor Education for a Changing World. VICTORIA:Monash University Publishing,2011. |
| [71] | NESPOR J. Education and place: A review essay. Educational Theory,2008,58(4):475-489. |
| [72] | KROPOTKIN P. What geography ought to be. The Nineteenth Century,1885(18):940-956. |
| [73] | 于洁,叶超.地理学思想教学的五个要领.世界地理研究,2021,30(6):1330-1337. |
| YU J, YE C.Five essentials on teaching geographic thought.World Regional Studies,2021,30(6):1330-1337. |
| Viewed | ||||||
|
Full text |
|
|||||
|
Abstract |
|
|||||
