The progress and prospect of geo-economic research in China and the West

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1004-9479.2022.05.2021393

Abstract

Abstract:

Under the reshaping of the world political and economic map, regional grouping promoting the adjustment of global governance, and the change of international system brought about by the game of great powers, it is relevant to sort out the historical context of geo-economics. Based on the clarification of the geo-economic academic thought, this paper selected WOS and CNKI as the literature retrieval library, and used CiteSpace to sketch out the knowledge map of geo-economic research. The results of this study are as follows. Firstly, the geo-economic academic trend of China and the West has experienced the "greening period -development period - backtracking period". The budding period still exists in realistic political logic. The development period is liberal. The backtracking period re-emerged the national political connotation. Secondly, in recent years, the intensity of geo-economic research in the West is much higher than in China. The western authors are mainly distributed in the US, Russia, UK and Italy. The domestic scholars are mainly concentrated in the Chinese Academy of Sciences, Yunnan Normal University and East China Normal University. Thirdly, geo-economic literatures have a clear knowledge base and knowledge network, and the highly cited literatures are derived from the works of geography or political science. Geo-economics forms a knowledge structure based on power, and space as the logical starting point, economy as the logical spindle. The evolution process of hot topics is highly coupled with the development of academic thought. Competition in science and technology will become the focus of geo-economics research in the future. This paper suggests that geo-economic research should build a geo-economic theory with win-win cooperation and open development, and strengthen empirical research.

Key words: geo-economics, academic thoughts, knowledge domain, evolution, CiteSpace

摘要：

在科技革命重塑世界政经版图、区域集团化推动全球治理调整、大国博弈带来国际体系变革的背景下，梳理地缘经济研究脉络对于提升地缘经济理论品质具有重大意义。本文在厘清地缘经济思潮发展的基础上，借助Web of Science和CNKI数据库，运用知识可视化工具探究中西方地缘经济知识图谱的演进过程，研究结果如下：①在学术思潮发展层面，中西方地缘经济思潮经历了“萌芽期—发展期—回溯期”，萌芽期存在现实政治逻辑，发展期转向自由主义思潮，回溯期再度涌现国家政治内涵。②在时空演进层面，近年来西方地缘经济研究强度远高于国内，西方作者主要分布在美国、俄罗斯、英国和意大利，国内学者主要集中在中国科学院、云南师范大学、复旦大学等高校和科研机构。③在知识网络层面，地缘经济存在较强的学科交叉属性，拥有明确的知识基础，高被引文献源于政治学或地理学，形成以权力为逻辑基础、空间为逻辑起点、经济为逻辑主轴的知识架构，热点议题演进与学术思潮发展高度耦合，科技竞争将成为当前乃至未来很长一段时间的研究重点。最后，本文认为国内地缘经济研究应突破西方的理论桎梏，构建以合作共赢、开放发展为核心的理论体系，在方法论上应强化定量分析和实证研究。

关键词: 地缘经济, 学术思潮, 知识图谱, 演进过程, CiteSpace

Wenlong YANG, Wentian SHI. The progress and prospect of geo-economic research in China and the West[J]. World Regional Studies, 2022, 31(5): 905-918.

杨文龙, 史文天. 中西方地缘经济研究的进展与展望[J]. 世界地理研究, 2022, 31(5): 905-918.

Figures/Tables 6

References 62

1	BOUDEVILLE J. Problems of Regional Economic Planning. Edinburgh: Edinburgh UP, 1966.
2	LUTTWAK E. From geopolitics to geo-economics: Logic of conflict, grammar of commerce. National Interest, 1990, 20(20): 17-23.
3	杜德斌, 马亚华. "一带一路"——全球治理模式的新探索. 地理研究, 2017, 36(7): 1203-1209.
	DU D, MA Y. One Belt and One Road: A new way of global governance. Geographical Research, 2017, 36(7): 1203-1209.
4	陆大道, 杜德斌. 关于加强地缘政治地缘经济研究的思考. 地理学报, 2013, 68(6): 723-727.
	LU D, DU D. Some thoughts on the strengthening of geopolitical and geoeconomic studies. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2013, 68(6): 723-727.
5	叶成城. 从全球主义到现实主义: 地缘经济学的发展和新趋势. 国外社会科学, 2019(1): 119-129.
	YE C. From globalism to realism: The development and new trends of geoeconomics. Social Sciences Abroad, 2019(1): 119-129.
6	兹比格涅夫·布热津斯基.大棋局: 美国的首要地位及其地缘战略. 上海: 上海人民出版社,2007.
	BRZEZINSKI Z. The Grand Chessboard: American Primacy and Its Geostrategic Imperatives. Shanghai: Shanghai Ren Min Press, 2007.
7	韩银安. 地缘经济学与中国地缘经济战略. 北京: 世界知识出版社, 2011.
	HAN Y. Geoeconomics and China's Geoeconomic Strategy. Beijing: World Affairs Press, 2011.
8	张丽君. 地缘经济时代. 北京: 中央民族大学出版社, 2006.
	ZHANG L. Geo-economic Age. Beijing: The China Minzu University Press, 2006.
9	罗伯特·基欧汉, 约瑟夫·奈.权力与相互依赖: 转变中的世界政治.北京: 中国人民公安大学出版社, 2002.
	ROBERT K, JOSEPH N. Power and Interdependence: World Politics in Transition. Beijing: Peking University Press, 2002.
10	TUATHAIL G, TOAL G. Critical Geopolitics: The Politics of Writing Global Space. Minneapolis: U of Minnesota Press, 1996.
11	伊曼纽尔·沃勒斯坦. 现代世界体系(第一卷). 北京: 高等教育出版社, 1998.
	WALLERSTEIN I. The Modern World System I. Beijing: High Education Press, 1998.
12	GEORGE T C, ABLA A. The Theoretical Evolution of International Political Economy: A Reader. New York: Oxford University Press, 1997.
13	郭学堂. "地缘经济"的发展及其现实意义. 社会科学, 2000(4): 25-28.
	GUO X. The development of "geoeconomy" and its practical significance. Journal of Social Sciences, 2000(4): 25-28.
14	ANDERSON J, JEFFREY A. German Unification and The Union of Europe: The Domestic Politics of Integration Policy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1999.
15	PEDERSEN T. Cooperative hegemony: Power, ideas and institutions in regional integration. Review of International Studies, 2002, 28(4): 677-696.
16	MISKIMMON A. Germany and The Common Foreign and Security Policy of the European Union. Berlin: Springer, 2007.
17	SPARKE M. Geopolitical fears, geoeconomic hopes, and the responsibilities of geography. Annals of The Association of American Geographers, 2007, 97(2): 338-349.
18	SPARKE M. From geopolitics to geoeconomics: Transnational state effects in the borderlands. Geopolitics, 1998, 3(2): 62-98.
19	卢光盛. 国际关系理论中的地缘经济学. 世界经济研究, 2004(3): 11-16.
	LU G. Geoeconomics in the theory of international relations. World Economy Studies, 2004(3): 11-16.
20	李红, 韦永贵,徐全龙. 基于中国视角的地缘经济合作研究进展——以中国―东盟合作研究为例. 热带地理, 2015, 35(5): 719-729.
	LI H, WEI Y, XU Q. Progress in geo-economic cooperation research from China's perspective: A case study of the cooperation between China and Asian. Tropical Geography, 2015, 35(5): 719-729.
21	韩银安.浅析地缘经济学.外交学院学报, 2004(1): 70-75.
	HAN Y. On geo-economics. Foreign Affairs Review, 2004(1): 70-75.
22	Hegemony PRYS M., domination, detachment : Differences in regional powerhood. International Studies Review, 2010, 12(4): 479-504.
23	GODEHARDT N, NABERS D. Regional Orders and Regional Powers. New York: Routledge, 2011.
24	LIUHTO K. Energy in Russia's foreign policy. PEI Electronic Publication, 2010 (10): 1-95.
25	GREY S, BERGIN T, MUSAIEVA S, et al. Special Report: Putin's Allies Channelled Billions to Ukraine Oligarch. London: Reuters, 2014.
26	毛汉英. 中国周边地缘政治与地缘经济格局和对策.地理科学进展, 2014, 33(3): 289-302.
	MA H. Geopolitical and geoeconomic situation in the surrounding areas and China's strategies. Progress in Geography, 2014, 33(3): 289-302.
27	胡志丁, 葛岳静, 鲍捷, 等.南亚地缘环境的空间格局与分异规律研究. 地理科学, 2013, 33(6): 685-692.
	HU Z, GE Y, BAO J, et al. The spatial pattern and differentiation laws of geo-setting in South Asia. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2013, 33(6): 685-692.
28	王淑芳, 葛岳静, 刘玉立. 中美在南亚地缘影响力的时空演变及机制. 地理学报, 2015, 70(6): 864-878.
	WANG S, GE Y, LIU Y. The spatio-temporal evolution and driving mechanism of geopolitical influence of China and the US in South Asia. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2015, 70(6): 864-878.
29	马腾, 葛岳静, 黄宇, 等.基于流量数据的中美两国与东北亚地缘经济关系研究. 地理学报, 2020, 75(10): 2076-2091.
	MA T, GE Y, HUANG Y, et al. Geo-economic relations of China and the US in Northeast Asia: An analysis based on flow data. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2020, 75(10): 2076-2091.
30	熊琛然, 王礼茂, 屈秋实, 等.中国与周边国家地缘经济关系的双向互动分析. 世界地理研究, 2019, 28(5): 11-23.
	XIONG C, WANG L, QU Q, et al. Study on the mutual interaction of geo-economic relations between China and its neighboring countries. World Regional Studies, 2019, 28(5): 11-23.
31	杨文龙, 杜德斌, 刘承良, 等.中国地缘经济联系的时空演化特征及其内部机制. 地理学报, 2016, 71(6): 956-969.
	YANG W, DU D, LIU C, et al. Study on the spatial-temporal evolution and internal mechanism of geo-economic connections of China. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2016, 71(6): 956-969.
32	孟德友, 马颖忆, 王晗, 等. 中国商品贸易结构不均衡性对地缘经济格局的影响. 地理科学, 2015, 35(10): 1238-1246.
	MENG D, MA Y, WANG H, et al. The impact of imbalance of Chinese goods trade structure on the geo-economic spatial pattern. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2015, 35(10): 1238-1246.
33	宋涛, 程艺, 刘卫东, 等.中国边境地缘经济的空间差异及影响机制. 地理学报, 2017, 72(10): 1731-1745.
	SONG T, CHENG Y, LIU W, et al. The spatial disparity and impact mechanism of geo-economy in the border areas of China. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2017, 72(10): 1731-1745.
34	丁云宝. "一带一路"视域下的新地缘经济观. 同济大学学报(社会科学版), 2019(2): 35-44.
	DING Y. The new geo-economic views under the background of the Belt and Road Initiative. Journal of Tongji University (Social Science Section), 2019(2): 35-44.
35	王海燕. "一带一路"视域下中国与中亚国家地缘经济合作比较研究. 世界地理研究, 2020, 29(1): 18-29.
	WANG H. Comparative research on geo-economic cooperation between China and Central Asian Countries under the perspective of OBOR. World Regional Studies, 2020, 29(1): 18-29.
36	李正, 陈才, 熊理然. 欧美地缘经济理论发展脉络及其内涵特征探析. 世界地理研究, 2014, 23(1): 10-18.
	LI Z, CHEN C, XIONG L. An analysis on the theory origin and development vein of geo-economics abroad. World Regional Studies, 2014, 23(1): 10-18.
37	陈悦, 陈超美, 刘则渊, 等. CiteSpace知识图谱的方法论功能. 科学学研究, 2015, 33(2): 242-253.
	CHEN Y, CHEN C, LIU Z, et al. The methodology function of CiteSpace mapping knowledge domains. Studies in Science of Science, 2015, 33(2): 242-253.
38	NAU H. The myth of America's decline: Leading the world economy into the 1990s.New York: Oxford University Press, 1990.
39	杜德斌, 段德忠, 刘承良, 等. 1990年以来中国地理学之地缘政治学研究进展. 地理研究, 2015, 34(2): 199-212.
	DU D, DUAN D, LIU C, et al. Progress of geopolitics of Chinese geography since 1990. Geographical Research, 2015, 34(2): 199-212.
40	萨缪尔·亨廷顿. 文明的冲突与世界秩序的重建. 北京: 新华出版社, 2002.
	HUNTINGTON S. The Clash of Civilizations and The Remaking of World Order. Beijing: Xin Hua Publishing House, 2002.
41	BRATTBERG E, HAMILTON D. Global Flow Security: A New Security Agenda for The Transatlantic Community in 2030. Washington, D.C: Center for Transatlantic Relations, Paul H. Nitze School of Advanced, 2014.
42	HSIUNG J. The age of geoeconomics, China's global role, and prospects of cross-strait integration. Journal of Chinese Political Science, 2009, 14(2): 113-133.
43	WRIGHT T. Sifting through interdependence. Washington Quarterly, 2013, 36(4): 7-23.
44	王铮, 韩钰, 胡敏, 等. 地理本性进化与全球地缘政治经济基础探析. 地理学报, 2016, 71(6): 940-955.
	WANG Z, HAN Y, HU M, et al. The global geopolitical and geopolinomical structure from the evolution of geographic natures. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2016, 71(6): 940-955.
45	郭焕成, 张继宏. 国际地缘经济板块及其内在机制研究. 经济地理, 1994(2): 1-5.
	GUO H, ZHANG J. Study of the international geo-economic sector and its internal mechanism. Economic Geography, 1994(2): 1-5.
46	THUROW L. Head to head: The coming economic battle among Japan, Europe, and America. Contemporary Sociology, 1992, 23(1): 12.
47	O'LOUGHLIN J, ANSELIN L. Geo-economic competition and trade bloc formation: United States, German, and Japanese exports, 1968-1992. Economic Geography, 1996, 72(2): 131-160.
48	FLINT C. Geographic Perspectives on World-Systems Theory. Boston: Oxford Research Encyclopedia of International Studies, 2010.
49	潘峰华, 赖志勇, 葛岳静. 经贸视角下中国周边地缘环境分析——基于社会网络分析方法. 地理研究, 2015, 34(4): 775-786.
	PAN F, LAI Z, GE Y. The surrounding geopolitical environment of China: A social network analysis based on trade data. Geographical Research, 2015, 34(4): 775-786.
50	KRUGMAN P. Geography and Trade. Boston: MIT press, 1993.
51	陈玉刚, 周超, 秦倩. 批判地缘政治学与南极地缘政治的发展. 世界经济与政治, 2012(10): 116-131.
	CHEN Y, ZHOU C, QIN Q. Critical political geography and the development of Antarctic geo-politics. World Economics and Politics, 2012(10): 116-131.
52	胡志丁, 陆大道. 基于批判地缘政治学视角解读经典地缘政治理论. 地理学报, 2015, 70(6): 851-863.
	HU Z, LU D. The re-interpretation of the classical geopolitical theories from a critical geopolitical perspective. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2015, 70(6): 851-863.
53	AGNEW J. Emerging China and critical geopolitics: Between world politics and Chinese particularity. Eurasian Geography and Economics, 2010, 51(5): 569-582.
54	PASCUAL C, ZAMBETAKIS E. The geopolitics of energy. Energy Security: Economics, Politics, Strategies, and Implications, 2010(1): 9-35.
55	方婷婷. 能源安全困境与俄欧能源博弈. 世界经济与政治论坛, 2015(5): 125-139.
	FANG T. Energy security dilemma and Russia-Europe energy game. Forum of World Economics & Politics, 2015(5): 125-139.
56	毛汉英. 中国与俄罗斯及中亚五国能源合作前景展望. 地理科学进展, 2013, 32(10): 1433-1443.
	MAO H. Prospects of energy cooperation of China with Russia and central Asian countries. Progress in Geography, 2013, 32(10): 1433-1443.
57	胡志丁, 葛岳静, 徐建伟. 尺度政治视角下的地缘能源安全评价方法及应用. 地理研究, 2014,33(5):853-862.
	HU Z, GE Y, XU J. Geopolitical energy security evaluation method and its application based on politics of scale. Geographical Research, 2014, 33(5): 853-862.
58	韩银安. 地缘经济学竞争模式研究. 国际安全研究, 2008(5): 15-21.
	HAN Y. Study on the competitive model of geo-economics. Journal of International Security Studies, 2008(5): 15-21.
59	NOWAK M. Five rules for the evolution of cooperation. Science, 2006, 314(5805): 1560-1563.
60	Oil OBI C., US global security and the challenge of development in West Africa. Codesria Bulletin, 2005(1): 3-4.
61	周骁男, 陈才. 论地缘政治与地缘经济的研究范式. 东北师大学报(哲学社会科学版), 2007(2): 76-80.
	ZHOU X, CHEN C. On the standard research paradigm of geopolitics and geo-economics. Journal of Northeast Normal University (Philosophy and Social Sciences), 2007(2): 76-80.
62	叶自成. 中国大战略:中国成为世界大国的主要问题及战略选择. 北京: 中国社会科学出版社, 2003.
	YE Z. China's Great Strategy: China's Major Problems and Strategic Choices to Become a World Power. Beijing: China Social Sciences Press, 2003.

持续时间	突现强度	突现词	持续时间	突现强度	突现词
1993—1999	2.237	北美自由贸易区	1991—1996	1.960	GATT
1993—1998	1.764	亚太经济合作	1993—2003	1.696	conflict
1994—2008	3.919	地缘经济战略	1993—2007	1.614	political geography
1995—2002	2.587	地缘经济时代	1994—2013	1.665	critical geopolitics
1995—2003	2.301	东北亚地区	2003—2012	1.878	geography
2002—2006	3.158	中国-东盟自由贸易区	2003—2011	1.599	empire
2003—2009	2.755	国家利益	2006—2007	1.849	neoliberalism
2004—2010	5.422	欧氏距离	2008—2012	1.472	innovation
2004—2008	3.273	区域经济合作	2012—2016	2.967	United States
2004—2007	2.791	和平崛起	2013—2016	3.212	foreign policy
2006—2009	2.757	合作	2014—2017	2.828	economy
2009—2012	6.227	地缘经济关系	2014—2016	2.095	Europe
2010—2017	3.463	经济联系	2015—2018	4.703	geo-economics
2013—2016	4.007	中国	2015—2020	2.170	Russia
2014—2017	4.773	丝绸之路经济带	2016—2016	2.146	investment
2015—2020	5.916	一带一路	2018—2020	3.844	politics
2015—2020	4.797	地缘环境	2018—2020	2.533	India
2016—2020	13.139	“一带一路”	2018—2020	2.276	US
2017—2020	8.148	“一带一路”倡议	2019—2020	2.742	geopolitics
2018—2020	6.546	地缘关系	2019—2020	2.742	China

持续时间	突现强度	突现词	持续时间	突现强度	突现词
1993—1999	2.237	北美自由贸易区	1991—1996	1.960	GATT
1993—1998	1.764	亚太经济合作	1993—2003	1.696	conflict
1994—2008	3.919	地缘经济战略	1993—2007	1.614	political geography
1995—2002	2.587	地缘经济时代	1994—2013	1.665	critical geopolitics
1995—2003	2.301	东北亚地区	2003—2012	1.878	geography
2002—2006	3.158	中国-东盟自由贸易区	2003—2011	1.599	empire
2003—2009	2.755	国家利益	2006—2007	1.849	neoliberalism
2004—2010	5.422	欧氏距离	2008—2012	1.472	innovation
2004—2008	3.273	区域经济合作	2012—2016	2.967	United States
2004—2007	2.791	和平崛起	2013—2016	3.212	foreign policy
2006—2009	2.757	合作	2014—2017	2.828	economy
2009—2012	6.227	地缘经济关系	2014—2016	2.095	Europe
2010—2017	3.463	经济联系	2015—2018	4.703	geo-economics
2013—2016	4.007	中国	2015—2020	2.170	Russia
2014—2017	4.773	丝绸之路经济带	2016—2016	2.146	investment
2015—2020	5.916	一带一路	2018—2020	3.844	politics
2015—2020	4.797	地缘环境	2018—2020	2.533	India
2016—2020	13.139	“一带一路”	2018—2020	2.276	US
2017—2020	8.148	“一带一路”倡议	2019—2020	2.742	geopolitics
2018—2020	6.546	地缘关系	2019—2020	2.742	China

[1]	Zaijun LI, Meijuan HU. Spatial-temporal evolution and formation mechanism of ecological well-being performance in Jiangsu Province [J]. World Regional Studies, 2023, 32(3): 124-135.
[2]	Jingya XU, Zhouying SONG. The evolution of China's mobile phone export trade pattern and its influencing factors [J]. World Regional Studies, 2023, 32(3): 17-27.
[3]	Yuangang HAN, Huizhong DONG, Hongjie ZHANG, Zhengxu CAO. Spatiotemporal evolution and influencing factors of environmental efficiency in China's marine economic circle [J]. World Regional Studies, 2023, 32(3): 89-100.
[4]	Bo TANG, Deguan CHEN, Hao LUO, Weixing XIE, Lin LIN. Spatial evolution and influencing factors of high-tech industries in Foshan City under the high-quality development [J]. World Regional Studies, 2023, 32(2): 136-145.
[5]	Wenya WANG, Mingfeng WANG, Yinghao ZHANG, Fan WANG. Research progress of internet and digital rural in China [J]. World Regional Studies, 2023, 32(2): 70-81.
[6]	Xiang ZHANG, Chenjiao MA, Xia DONG, Zhaohui WANG, Xingming LI. Spatio-temporal evolution and driving factors of international chain hotels' transnational expansion: A case study of Marriott Hotel Group [J]. World Regional Studies, 2023, 32(1): 31-42.
[7]	Yichuan ZHANG, Meng HU, Hong LI. A review of the progress and hot issues of Gravity Model based on the CiteSpace: A comparative analysis of literature from the economic geography perspective [J]. World Regional Studies, 2023, 32(1): 130-140.
[8]	Xiaobiao LIN, Hengbi ZHENG, Shanggang YIN, Yuqi LU. The spatio-temporal pattern evolution and convergence of global religious diversity after World War Ⅱ [J]. World Regional Studies, 2023, 32(1): 5-18.
[9]	Shanshan YAN, Chengliang LIU. Spatial evolution and influential factors of China's foreign technology transfer network [J]. World Regional Studies, 2023, 32(1): 19-30.
[10]	Weihua YIN, Nannan LIU, Feiyu LU. Cultural industry and tourism's integrated development and its spatial evolution in the Yangtze River Economic Belt [J]. World Regional Studies, 2022, 31(5): 1009-1020.
[11]	Hui LI, Qilong REN, Chunmei ZHANG. Study on the spatial-temporal evolution and driving factors of urban logistics links in Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei Region [J]. World Regional Studies, 2022, 31(5): 1046-1056.
[12]	Qi ZHAO, Shengjun ZHU. The effect of technological relatedness and land finance on regional industrial evolution [J]. World Regional Studies, 2022, 31(5): 953-966.
[13]	Cheng ZHANG, Jiaqi YANG. The game situation of the strategic interests of the Arctic route and China's countermeasures [J]. World Regional Studies, 2022, 31(5): 919-928.
[14]	Xu YIN, Peng LI, Zhiming FENG, Zhen YOU, Chiwei XIAO. Characteristics of spatio-temporal differences and evolution types of Vietnamese population from 2000 to 2019 [J]. World Regional Studies, 2022, 31(5): 941-952.
[15]	Xiang KONG, Kaihang CHEN, Yiman LI. The temporal and spatial evolution of market segmentation and its spatial spillover in the Yangtze River Delta Region [J]. World Regional Studies, 2022, 31(4): 827-836.